Gravitational potential energy questions

In summary: No, the calculation of gravitational potential energy works the same in a system where both objects are in motion.
  • #1
andytrust
2
0
Hello,
I haven't learned a lot of physics and math, but I don't know how I misunderstand the following concepts:

Why is the gravitational potential energy of a system of two bodies described in one term instead of two? If each body in a two-body system effects a gravitational force on the other one, wouldn't both objects have their own gravitational potential energy (albeit they would be the same value), instead of sharing one energy?

My second question: The derivation for the escape velocity of an object at the Earth's surface (as found for instance on Wikipedia here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Escape_velocity#Derivation_using_G_and_M), seems to me to assume that the Earth remains static while the object is moving away from it. If the object were sufficiently large, wouldn't the Earth and its gravitational field move after it, making it harder for the object to escape the Earth's gravitational field, so that it would not reach infinity? Why doesn't this happen?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
andytrust said:
Why is the gravitational potential energy of a system of two bodies described in one term instead of two? If each body in a two-body system effects a gravitational force on the other one, wouldn't both objects have their own gravitational potential energy (albeit they would be the same value), instead of sharing one energy?
I guess you could say that each object has its own gravitational potential energy that is half of the total. But that'd be more complicated than just having the one potential energy for the pair together.

Actually, this might be a better line of reasoning: in many cases, one of the two bodies will be stationary, or at least so massive (compared to the other) that it effectively doesn't move. Example: the Earth and a satellite. In those cases, it makes sense to say that one body (the smaller one) has its own individual potential energy. Essentially, you assign all the potential energy of the system to the smaller body. But in the general case, both bodies are free to move, and then it's impossible to define a potential energy for one body alone based only on that body's position. You have to incorporate the position of both bodies. So it just makes sense to assign the potential energy to the system of the two bodies, and not try to split it up between them.

Plus, the formula just works :wink:

andytrust said:
My second question: The derivation for the escape velocity of an object at the Earth's surface (as found for instance on Wikipedia here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Escape_velocity#Derivation_using_G_and_M), seems to me to assume that the Earth remains static while the object is moving away from it. If the object were sufficiently large, wouldn't the Earth and its gravitational field move after it, making it harder for the object to escape the Earth's gravitational field, so that it would not reach infinity? Why doesn't this happen?
You're right, the derivation does assume that the Earth remains fixed in place. Escape velocity is really only a meaningful concept in a static gravitational field - which in practice means, only for small things like rockets.
 
  • #3
andytrust said:
Why is the gravitational potential energy of a system of two bodies described in one term instead of two?
The number of bodies doesn't matter. The gravitational potential energy difference between two points a and b, GPE(b) - GPE(a) is the negative of the work peformed by gravity when the object moves from a to b. For a finite number of finite sized bodies, GPE for one of those bodies at some point 'p', relative to the center of mass of the other bodies can be defined by defining GPE(∞) = 0, and then defining the potential energy at a point 'p' with respect to ∞, to be GPE(p) = GPE(∞) - GPE(p).

The derivation for the escape velocity of an object at the Earth's surface
This derivation ignores the mass of that object. The true escape velocity of a two body system, would require that the initial kinetic energy at point p be greater than or equal to GPE(p).
 
Last edited:
  • #4
diazona said:
You're right, the derivation does assume that the Earth remains fixed in place. Escape velocity is really only a meaningful concept in a static gravitational field - which in practice means, only for small things like rockets.

Jeff Reid said:
The number of bodies doesn't matter. The gravitational potential energy difference between two points a and b, GPE(b) - GPE(a) is the negative of the work peformed by gravity when the object moves from a to b.

Thank you for clarifying this. I guess my question is: does it mean that when gravitational potential energy is calculated (I guess this also applies for electrical potential energy), you have to assume the object(s) doing the work remain stationary (in an inertial frame of reference)?
If that is so, does the idea of gravitational potential energy have any meaning in a system where all the bodies are moving?
 

1. What is gravitational potential energy?

Gravitational potential energy is the energy an object possesses due to its position in a gravitational field. It is a form of potential energy that is dependent on an object's mass, height, and the strength of the gravitational field.

2. How is gravitational potential energy calculated?

The formula for gravitational potential energy is PE = mgh, where PE is the potential energy, m is the mass of the object, g is the acceleration due to gravity, and h is the height of the object relative to a reference point. It is important to note that this formula only applies to objects near the surface of the Earth.

3. Can gravitational potential energy be negative?

Yes, gravitational potential energy can be negative. This occurs when the object is below the reference point and is a result of the convention used in the formula for gravitational potential energy.

4. How does gravitational potential energy change with height?

As the height of an object increases, its gravitational potential energy also increases. This is because the object has more potential to do work as it falls towards the ground due to the increase in height.

5. What factors affect the amount of gravitational potential energy an object has?

The amount of gravitational potential energy an object has is affected by its mass, height, and the strength of the gravitational field it is in. The greater the mass and height of the object, and the stronger the gravitational field, the higher its potential energy will be.

Similar threads

Replies
27
Views
11K
Replies
10
Views
1K
Replies
10
Views
901
Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
19
Views
951
  • Mechanics
Replies
4
Views
697
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • Mechanics
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
125
Back
Top