Oil Spill Density: Answers to Questions

In summary, the oil leak in the Gulf has raised questions about its behavior and why it is not rising to the surface despite having a lower density than water. The temperature and pressure at the depth of the leak may be affecting its density, and there is limited information on the actual numbers. It has been observed that the majority of the oil is billowing around a few hundred feet above the bottom, but there is uncertainty about its movements. Some sources suggest that the oil may be slowly rising or sinking, while others say it is stable at its current depth. The density behavior of heavy oils in freshwater and the use of chemicals to wash away heavy oil have been discussed, but there is a need for more accurate information. It has been noted that crude
  • #1
gwangi
4
0
this oil leak in the Gulf has got me wondering about a few things. There are a lot of questions being asked and the only answers seem vague and uninformed. I'm new here so bear with me as I learn the etiquette.
My primary question is why is this oil staying near the bottom when its STP density is less than water? I know that unlike water the long chain hydrocarbon molecules are subject to compression, so I assume that the low temperature and high pressure have a definite affect, but does anyone have any actual numbers? How dense is crude at +10 F and 5000 feet down? What is the temp of the oil itself as it exits the pipe?
additionally: under what natural conditions does its specific gravity (is that the correct use of the term?) become less than water and the stuff begin to rise to the surface?
thanks in advance for any information you can provide
 
Last edited:
Earth sciences news on Phys.org
  • #2
Who says it is staying near the bottom? I thought that it is rising up to the top.
 
  • #3
phyzguy said:
Who says it is staying near the bottom? I thought that it is rising up to the top.

The only source of information I have is the standard news that everyone hears, and according to that the vast majority of the stuff is billowing around a few hundred feet above the bottom, while only a small quantity is actually floating. And even that description changes day by day. Is it slowly rising to the top? Is it slowly sinking to the bottom? Is it stable at its current depth? It all depends on who you listen to. I'm hoping somebody here can provide me with some actual facts based on science rather than media speculation.
 
Last edited:
  • #5
Wonder if the chemicals that are being adding make a difference to the API Gravity? I have used it in oil plants.

You go to the spill. cover it with the liquid (it was called XZIT) then use water to wash the heavy oil away. It certainly stops it from clinging to the ground, pavement or any structure.
 
  • #6
I misread an earlier comment in another thread. The poster said that the temp at the wellwead leak was +10 F above freezing (+42 F) not +10 F.
Found some interesting and pertinent at engineering toolbox. but it looks like I have to spend some in a relearning curve before I can apply any of it. thanks for the link astronuc.
 
  • #7
Crude oil is a mixture of many hydrocarbon components ranging from light ends (propane & Butane) and mid range components C5-C8 or C9 (natural gasoline) and very heavy hydrocarbons which can have a density greater than water. When this crude first emerges from the pipeline at the sea floor it is hot relative to the sea water, this oil temperature is known by the oil company, but I have not seen it published.

During the mixing with the sea water as it rises, some of the heavier components can become split from the lighter components and sink. Tar is the end stage of crude oil with the light ends removed. this can be very sticky and aglomerate with sand and stay near the bottom and move with the currents like light rocks.
 
  • #8
Very good PRDan4th ... best explanation I have seen so far. :)

That process is obvious in the oil sands of Fort McMurray.
 
  • #9
PRDan4th said:
Crude oil is a mixture of many hydrocarbon components ranging from light ends (propane & Butane) and mid range components C5-C8 or C9 (natural gasoline) and very heavy hydrocarbons which can have a density greater than water. [...]
While the very heavy asphaltene components may have a density of ~1.1 g/cm^3, I believe these are an extremely small fraction of the total petroleum product failing to rise to the surface, especially with cold seawater density at ~1.03 g/cm^3. My (limited) understanding is that the majority of the (less dense than water) petroleum products that fail to rise to the surface do so because they http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emulsion" [Broken] with various temperature layers in the water column; the density of the emulsified hydrocarbon + cold water is still greater the clean warmer water above, trapping the hydrocarbons in the thermal layer.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #10
Why not introduce bio-active particles that bind to hydrocarbons and each other, and also produce some kind of gas, e.g. methane that is trapped? Result: oil "coagulates" into jelly-like, huge blobs that float and can be collected.
 
  • #11
socean said:
Why not introduce bio-active particles that bind to hydrocarbons and each other, and also produce some kind of gas, e.g. methane that is trapped? Result: oil "coagulates" into jelly-like, huge blobs that float and can be collected.

The same thing could be accomplished by just stopping the Corexit.

Then the 60,000bpd (so it seems now) would just make a big blanket and kill even more of the Gulph.
 
  • #12
Piterson said:
Oil is a general term used to denote petroleum products which mainly consist of hydrocarbons. Crude oils are made up of a wide spectrum of hydrocarbons ranging from very volatile, light materials such as propane and benzene to more complex heavy compounds such as bitumens, asphaltenes, resins and waxes. Refined products such as petrol or fuel oil are composed of smaller and more specific ranges of these hydrocarbons.
Piterson: Crude oil is indeed made up of many hydrocarbon constituents, yet by now the methanes, ethanes, propanes and butanes have all weathered away. Propane becomes a gas around -37F and butane around +36F. (Did you know that when you buy 'propane' for your BBQ it is about 35% butane in the winter and up to 70% butane in the summer?) It is the C5s and heaver that are problematic.

This is what has happened in the oil sands ... the lighter elements have disappeared into the atmosphere and only the heavy are left - this means the oil can be (must be) mined using conventional (and some unconventional) methods.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #13
croghan27 said:
Piterson: Crude oil is indeed made up of many hydrocarbon constituents, yet by now the methanes, ethanes, propanes and butanes have all weathered away. Propane becomes a gas around -37F and butane around +36F. (Did you know that when you buy 'propane' for your BBQ it is about 35% butane in the winter and up to 70% butane in the summer?)
At standard atmospheric pressure propane is a gas at low temperatures. Double the pressure and in the presence of water it can remain a ~semi-solid clathrate up to +32F and beyond.
https://eee.uci.edu/programs/hongchem/RDGPhaseDiagrams.pdf
 
  • #14
You guys have been responding to a mass spammer. That's what they do now days, they search for keywords, find a post on the internet, post a canned blurb to go with the keyword and insert a spam link.
 
  • #15
Evo said:
You guys have been responding to a mass spammer. That's what they do now days, they search for keywords, find a post on the internet, post a canned blurb to go with the keyword and insert a spam link.

A mass spammer??

Has that person found the Higg's boson of etalk?
 
  • #16
Evo said:
You guys have been responding to a mass spammer. That's what they do now days, they search for keywords, find a post on the internet, post a canned blurb to go with the keyword and insert a spam link.

I must be missing something becasue I can't see any "spam link". Could you please explain this further EVO?
 

What is an oil spill and how does it occur?

An oil spill is the release of liquid petroleum hydrocarbon into the environment, typically occurring in bodies of water such as oceans or rivers. It can occur through accidents during oil extraction, transportation, or storage, as well as natural seepage from the earth's crust.

What factors affect the density of an oil spill?

The density of an oil spill is affected by several factors, including the type and composition of the oil, the temperature of the surrounding environment, and the presence of other substances such as dispersants or sediments.

Why is the density of an oil spill important?

The density of an oil spill is important because it affects the behavior and fate of the oil in the environment. Oil that is less dense than water will float on the surface, while oil that is more dense will sink and potentially cause more damage to underwater ecosystems.

How is the density of an oil spill measured?

The density of an oil spill can be measured using various methods, including laboratory analysis, remote sensing techniques, and in-situ measurements using specialized equipment. The most common measurement is done by comparing the weight of a known volume of oil to the weight of an equal volume of water.

What are the environmental impacts of an oil spill?

An oil spill can have significant environmental impacts, including harm to aquatic life, damage to shorelines and coastal ecosystems, and contamination of water and soil. The long-term effects can be devastating and can take years to fully recover.

Similar threads

  • Engineering and Comp Sci Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • General Discussion
2
Replies
49
Views
7K
Replies
30
Views
18K
Replies
21
Views
4K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Mechanics
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
16
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
12
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
3K
Back
Top