Register to reply

Computer Password Protected by the 4th Amendment or the 5th or Neither?

by Greg Bernhardt
Tags: amendment, password, protected
Share this thread:
Greg Bernhardt
#1
Feb26-12, 10:00 PM
Admin
Greg Bernhardt's Avatar
P: 9,553
Can the government compel you to provide your computer password if they think there is illicit material stored in an encrypted part of the hard drive? *If there was ever a case when it seemed like the Constitution was no Continue reading →

Read More...
Phys.Org News Partner Social sciences news on Phys.org
Computer games give a boost to English
Saddam Hussein?a sincere dictator?
Canadians rank highly when it comes to public science knowledge, attitudes, and engagement
turbo
#2
Feb26-12, 10:18 PM
PF Gold
turbo's Avatar
P: 7,363
Not just "the government". You can be compelled to offer up your PC for a search if you are involved in a civil suit.
Evo
#3
Feb26-12, 10:22 PM
Mentor
Evo's Avatar
P: 26,545
Sure if they've got a warrant they can demand access to anything the warrant specifies.

turbo
#4
Feb26-12, 10:31 PM
PF Gold
turbo's Avatar
P: 7,363
Computer Password Protected by the 4th Amendment or the 5th or Neither?

Quote Quote by Evo View Post
Sure if they've got a warrant they can demand access to anything the warrant specifies.
I was suing a crook for back-pay, and he counter-sued for $650,000, and the court let him have a warrant to search my PC because I had used it at home to deal with customers. It was a fishing expedition that yielded nothing of use to him, but it was still a big pain in the butt.
dimensionless
#5
Mar3-12, 04:52 PM
P: 464
I imagine that one could theoretically be subpoenaed to provide such information, however, I think it could also constitute self incrimination, in which case, they could not compel a person to provide passwords.
skeptic2
#6
Mar3-12, 06:06 PM
P: 1,814
Let's not forget that the expressed purpose of the Fifth Amendment was to prevent the torturing of prisoners. Making it a crime to fail to give up a password and sentencing a defendant to prison is essentially the same thing.

- There was a recent decision by the seventh circuit court of appeals that enables the police to search cell phones without a warrant.

- Even forcing a suspect to take a drug test, alcohol test or DNA test is problematic. How are any of these not a form of testifying against oneself? Calling driving a privilege and agreeing to providing a sample as part of that privilege doesn't resolve the problem. Suppose a law were passed that made owning a house a privilege and before buying a house, prospective owners had to sign a statement permitting the police to conduct searches without a warrant?
nsaspook
#7
Mar3-12, 07:25 PM
P: 642
The 5th (maybe) http://mi.findacase.com/research/wfr...995.EMI.htm/qx
DutchNight
#8
Mar6-12, 07:35 AM
P: 5
All passwords are protected by a bad memory.
You can't be forced to give information you can't remember, can you?
skeptic2
#9
Mar6-12, 03:24 PM
P: 1,814
Quote Quote by turbo View Post
I was suing a crook for back-pay, and he counter-sued for $650,000, and the court let him have a warrant to search my PC because I had used it at home to deal with customers. It was a fishing expedition that yielded nothing of use to him, but it was still a big pain in the butt.
Had you refused to provide your password, assuming you had one, what would the court have done? Hold you in contempt? Dismiss the case? Decided in favor of the defendant? Did you consider invoking the 4th or 5th amendments?
dimensionless
#10
Mar6-12, 07:29 PM
P: 464
Quote Quote by skeptic2 View Post
Let's not forget that the expressed purpose of the Fifth Amendment was to prevent the torturing of prisoners.
Yes. And, also, without the Fifth Amendment, a suspect can be forced to incriminate one's self for a crime not committed.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Pengwuinos are now a protected species General Discussion 10
LatEx reference in protected area of PF? Forum Feedback & Announcements 1
UV protected swim clothes General Discussion 10
Does a TV need to be protected from the Earth's magnetic field? Advanced Physics Homework 4
CIA protected Adolf Eichmann in 1950's Current Events 1