New Reply

Pedagogy: story lines for introducing GR?

 
Share Thread Thread Tools
Aug21-12, 07:46 PM   #18
 
Recognitions:
Science Advisor Science Advisor

Pedagogy: story lines for introducing GR?


Quote by bcrowell View Post
There are various roads from SR to GR. In a couple of years I may get a chance to teach a semester-length class on relativity for liberal arts students. Any comments on what story line works best?

<snip>
I use the story line #3 in class (health science students, algebra-based intro). Nobody has mentioned that liberal arts majors are going to be totally lost by all the jargon being thrown around here- presumably you realize that :)

Edit- I also introduce GR by analogy to the surface of the Earth- moving North-South vs. East-West introduces the notion of a 'fictitious force', combined with the paradox that force-free mechanics (motion in straight lines) appears violated for free body motion, because we can cancel gravity with a fictitious force. Thus gravity and curvature are interchangeable.

I don't know how much sticks, but I enjoy telling the story... :)
Oct1-12, 10:37 AM   #19
 
Quote by atyy View Post
Thorne does claim in his popular book about wormholes that GR can be considered a field in flat spacetime. I'm not sure if the physically relevant portion of the FLRW solution can be done this way, but I believe the physically relevant parts of the Schwarzschild solution can be.
Correct! Actually I think that he publish a "lesson plan" of how to teach GR using wormholes. (http://www.physics.uofl.edu/wkomp/te.../wormholes.pdf)

I cite this as a way that you might attract liberal arts majors who might be more interested in the historical side of GR. :)

After all, we cannot simple come from a simple Piagetian based teaching style but must include social communication, scaffolding and interaction (Vygotisky) while appealing to twenty first century learning need to address different intellengences (music, art, kinestetic, etc.)
New Reply
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: Pedagogy: story lines for introducing GR?
Thread Forum Replies
Math Pedagogy General Math 2
Different pedagogy between 2 professors General Discussion 1
Pedagogy of QM Double Slit Experiment General Physics 0
Pedagogy of QM Double Slit Experiment General Physics 17