What causes sand to get hotter then water?

  • Thread starter jjjsarnis
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Water
In summary, sand gets hotter than water due to its lower specific heat capacity and its ability to absorb and retain heat from the sun more efficiently. Additionally, sand particles are closer together, allowing for better heat conduction. This results in a higher temperature in sand compared to water, which has a higher specific heat capacity and is less dense, making it more difficult to heat up. The color of the sand also plays a role, as darker sand absorbs more heat than lighter sand. These factors contribute to sand getting hotter than water under similar conditions.
  • #1
jjjsarnis
15
0
question: on a sunny day at the beach, the reason the sand gets hot and the water stays relatively cool is attributed to the fdiffernce in which property between water and sand?

is it specific heat or thermal conduvtivitiy??

our class and our teacher argued over this all class, thanks for your help
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
jjjsarnis said:
question: on a sunny day at the beach, the reason the sand gets hot and the water stays relatively cool is attributed to the fdiffernce in which property between water and sand?

is it specific heat or thermal conduvtivitiy??

Both.

The low specific heat ensures that something receiving a smaller heat flux gains a larger increase in temperature. The low conductivity (which is mostly due to the poor thermal contact between sand grains) ensures that the temperature gradient created can be large for a given rate of downward heat removal.

In other words :

First the surface layers of water and sand get heated directly by the sunlight. If none of this heat is conducted away, the sand will reach a higher temperature than water because of the lower specific heat. However, the heat does get conducted away. But again, since it is conducted away more slowly by the sand, than by the water, the surface of the sand stays hotter.

With calculus (differential equations), this can be modeled reasonably easily.
 
  • #3
Gokul43201 said:
Both.

The low specific heat ensures that something receiving a smaller heat flux gains a larger increase in temperature. The low conductivity (which is mostly due to the poor thermal contact between sand grains) ensures that the temperature gradient created can be large for a given rate of downward heat removal.
I agree with the low specific heat point. To undergo a temperature increase of one degree, the sand requires much less heat than water. So the same amount of heat/unit area incident upon sand and upon water will increase the temperature of the sand much more.

But I am not sure about the thermal conductivity. Its thermal conductivity is the same as sawdust and I don't think sawdust would feel as hot as sand if you set them out in the sun.

AM
 

1. What is the main reason behind sand getting hotter than water?

The main reason behind sand getting hotter than water is because of the difference in their specific heat capacities. Water has a higher specific heat capacity than sand, which means it requires more energy to increase its temperature compared to sand. Therefore, sand heats up faster and to a higher temperature than water when exposed to the same amount of heat.

2. How does the color of sand affect its temperature compared to water?

The color of sand does not have a significant impact on its temperature compared to water. The main factor is still the difference in their specific heat capacities. However, darker colored sand may absorb more heat from the sun and therefore become hotter than lighter colored sand.

3. Does the shape or size of sand particles play a role in its temperature compared to water?

Yes, the shape and size of sand particles can affect its temperature compared to water. Finer sand particles have a larger surface area, which allows them to absorb more heat from the sun and become hotter than larger sand particles. Additionally, the shape of the sand particles can affect their ability to retain heat, with rounder particles retaining heat better than angular particles.

4. Why does sand retain its heat longer than water?

Sand retains its heat longer than water because of its lower thermal conductivity. This means that it takes longer for heat to transfer through sand compared to water. Therefore, when the source of heat is removed, sand will continue to stay hot for a longer period compared to water.

5. Can the surrounding environment affect the temperature of sand and water differently?

Yes, the surrounding environment can affect the temperature of sand and water differently. For example, if the air temperature is hotter than the temperature of the water or sand, they will both heat up. However, since sand has a lower specific heat capacity, it will reach a higher temperature faster than water. On the other hand, if the air temperature is cooler than the temperature of sand and water, they will both cool down, but sand will retain its heat longer due to its lower thermal conductivity.

Similar threads

Replies
25
Views
2K
Replies
18
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
14
Views
3K
Replies
32
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • General Engineering
2
Replies
67
Views
4K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
8
Views
1K
Back
Top