Biology Forum: Do We Need Pain?

  • Thread starter Aquamarine
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Pain
In summary, while it is theoretically possible to design a system that eliminates physical pain, it is not currently possible to do so.
  • #1
Aquamarine
160
4
As suggested, I try asking this question in the biology forum.

https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=45269

I know that there are different pathways in the brain for pleasure and pain. But at some point these must connect in order to make a decision. So from a biological point of view, is it possible to avoid the feeling of pain? Or would any kind of diminishing of reward feel as pain for a higher form of life? Or if possible to have a system based only on pleasure, would this be inferior to a system based both on pleasure and pain?
 
Biology news on Phys.org
  • #2
What kind of pain are you talking about? Emotional or physical?

the answer is probably going to be different

Physical pain is a must. Without pain you cannot react to harmfull situation. How are you suppose to know if your body is in danger and substainning damage.

The same could be said for emotional pain. Is emotional pain part of socialogical learning?
 
  • #3
iansmith said:
What kind of pain are you talking about? Emotional or physical?

the answer is probably going to be different

Physical pain is a must. Without pain you cannot react to harmfull situation. How are you suppose to know if your body is in danger and substainning damage.

The same could be said for emotional pain. Is emotional pain part of socialogical learning?
But could physical pain be replaced by diminished pleaure, is one supposes that the normal everyday level would be intense pleasre? So physical damage would at worst be signaled by the feeling most of us today feel in everyday life.
 
  • #4
There is a neurological disorder known as "Congenital Insensitivity to Pain." Sufferers never adjust posture and so cripple their limbs. They often burn themselves, bite their tongues, break their toes by walking into things. It is not a pleasant condition.

Congenital Insensitivity to Pain with Anhidrosis (lack of sweating) is a rare autosomal-recessive disorder usually manifested in childhood by a history of unrecognized trauma, indifference to pain stimuli or self-mutilation. This disorder is a rare sensory and autonomic neuropathy which is defined as the absence of normal subjective and objective responses to noxious stimuli in patients shown to have normal central and peripheral nervous systems.

http://helium.vancouver.wsu.edu/~woodc/CIPA.html [Broken]
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #5
loseyourname said:
There is a neurological disorder known as "Congenital Insensitivity to Pain." Sufferers never adjust posture and so cripple their limbs. They often burn themselves, bite their tongues, break their toes by walking into things. It is not a pleasant condition.



http://helium.vancouver.wsu.edu/~woodc/CIPA.html [Broken]
Yes, but those people have no system at all for reacting to physical damage. The question is wether a system could be designed where for example less pleasure or pure reflexes without feeling take the place of pain.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #6
Then the question would be if there is any advantage to fell less pain and more pleasure and would it be select for in any type of way.
 
  • #7
So, Aquamarine, you are advocating a system that ranges from neutrality to euphoria in place of the existing system which ranges from horrific pain to euphoria.

What's to say people wouldn't then experience neutrality with the same discomfort that they now experience horrific pain? Wouldn't "neutrality" just become the new "horrific pain?" It's all a matter of perception, after all.

- Warren
 
  • #8
chroot said:
So, Aquamarine, you are advocating a system that ranges from neutrality to euphoria in place of the existing system which ranges from horrific pain to euphoria.

What's to say people wouldn't then experience neutrality with the same discomfort that they now experience horrific pain? Wouldn't "neutrality" just become the new "horrific pain?" It's all a matter of perception, after all.

- Warren
That sounds like my original question. :smile:

Using that argument, chronic pain or mental anguish is largely uninteresting since people would adapt and stop feeling the pain after a while. Necessarily, all people would are always equally happy regardless of conditions, if these change slowly. But the evidence is that people never adapt and are constantly feeling misery from constant pain.
 
  • #9
Aquamarine said:
Yes, but those people have no system at all for reacting to physical damage. The question is wether a system could be designed where for example less pleasure or pure reflexes without feeling take the place of pain.

There are a variety of ways in which evolution can solve any given problem. We could have been endowed with prehensile mandibles rather than opposable thumbs, for instance. Bats could use night vision instead of echolocation. It is dubious to call any of these systems "designed" as they stand, so assuming you're question is whether or not we as humans can design such a modification to human pain perception: in principle, it's possible. In practice, who knows? We certainly can't do it right now. What we can do is give a person the drug ecstasy, which suppresses all feeling of pain while simultaneously heightening feelings of pleasure. All I can say is that this system doesn't seem to currently have the ability to produce properly functioning human beings.
 
  • #10
Aquamarine said:
That sounds like my original question. :smile:

Using that argument, chronic pain or mental anguish is largely uninteresting since people would adapt and stop feeling the pain after a while. Necessarily, all people would are always equally happy regardless of conditions, if these change slowly. But the evidence is that people never adapt and are constantly feeling misery from constant pain.

The natural response to pain is avoidance. In a "neutral" situation, there would be no particular drive toward avoidance or attraction. The avoidance response to pain is essential to preventing further injury, either through not coming into contact with something injurious (i.e., the hot stove), or through avoiding use of an injured limb until it has healed. This becomes very obvious when dealing with veterinary medicine. An animal that is given sufficient pain killers after an injury to not feel pain, or too mild of pain, is likely to continue trying to use the injured limb and make it worse. You have to give just enough painkillers to take the worst of the pain away so they continue to eat, but so they still feel the injury enough to be a bit guarded about how they move or behave to keep from making it worse.

Even people tend to overdo things when healing from an injury when the pain starts to subside. Think about that time following surgery when the bad pain goes away but the wound is still healing and dependent upon stitches to keep it together, and how many people start trying to do normal activities against medical advice because it doesn't hurt anymore, and wind up popping stitches and causing more trouble.
 

1. What is the purpose of pain in biology?

Pain serves as a protective mechanism in biology, alerting the body to potential harm or injury. It helps individuals avoid dangerous situations and promotes self-preservation.

2. Is pain necessary for survival?

While pain may not be essential for survival, it plays an important role in maintaining overall wellbeing and preventing potential harm to the body. For example, individuals with congenital insensitivity to pain often suffer from severe injuries and health complications.

3. How does pain affect the body?

Pain triggers a series of physiological responses in the body, including increased heart rate, blood pressure, and stress hormones. It also activates the brain's reward and pleasure centers, which can lead to a sense of relief after the pain subsides.

4. Can pain be beneficial?

Yes, pain can be beneficial in certain situations. As mentioned earlier, it serves as a protective mechanism for the body. Additionally, pain can also help individuals learn from their experiences and avoid potential harm in the future.

5. Can pain be managed or controlled?

Yes, pain can be managed or controlled through various methods such as medication, physical therapy, and relaxation techniques. However, it is important to note that pain should not always be completely eliminated as it serves a crucial role in protecting the body. Instead, it should be managed to a level that is tolerable for the individual.

Similar threads

  • Biology and Medical
Replies
15
Views
2K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
13
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
33
Views
2K
Replies
25
Views
4K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
2
Views
3K
Back
Top