Why do photons not pass straight through objects?

  • Thread starter lntz
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Photons
In summary, the conversation discusses the analogy of an atom and a football, the difference in energy levels of electrons, and the transparency of glass. It is explained that photons primarily interact with electrons and that the size of a photon is not comparable to the size of an atom. The concept of size in quantum mechanics is also discussed, as well as the role of photons in producing blue skylight. Lastly, it is mentioned that quantum physics is needed to explain the opacity and transparency of materials.
  • #1
lntz
54
0
so i often hear the analogy of an atom being on the same scale as a foot ball in the center of a pitch, with the electrons all in their orbitals at some large distance away.

in chemistry we have been discussing the difference in energy levels of electrons and using these to describe the colours of certain compounds.

i am imagining that the spaces between atoms are much larger than the 'gap' a photon can fit through, so what is it that causes the photon to change electrons energy states?

also, if the transparency of glass is explained by saying it has an amorphous structure, why does this make it transparent? i would have thought density played a part here, but what do i know?

anyway, if you can clear any of this up for me, i'd be very grateful.

thanks.
 
Science news on Phys.org
  • #2
Photons primarily interact with electrons in matter. Both photons and electrons behave as waves. Because electrons don't have a specific position, there really aren't any gaps for a photon to fit through.

As for transparency of glass, it's not because photons somehow manage to fit "between" particles. They move right through. Photon can only be absorbed by electrons in matter if it can take an electron from its current energy level to a higher one. If there are no energy levels available corresponding to energy of the photon, the photon is not absorbed.

Glass being amorphous has nothing to do with it, though. Quartz is the crystalline form of the same material, and quartz is also transparent. As well as many other crystals.
 
  • #3
There are various intuitive pictures you can take to explain this, none correct. You can view the photon as much larger than the atom (with a "size" of the wavelength of the photon), so it's not going to fit in the gaps between electrons in an atom and it's going to hit everything in its way. Or you can view the electron cloud as occupying the whole space around the atom, so there is no gap in the first place.

There is not a unique concept of "size" in quantum mechanics, and there is no analog to the macroscopic concept of size. For colliding two objects, we use something called the cross section to describe the size, where the cross section is a cross sectional area. The difficulty comes from the fact that the cross section of a particle depends on what it is colliding with, and what kind of collision is taking place, and it can be 0 or finite or infinite.
 
  • #4
It is now known that photons of visible sunlight pass through and scatter off of individual atoms of air in the atmosphere, producing polarized blue skylight. This scattering (which attenuates the direct sunlight) does not depend on electron energy levels or ionization of the air. Lord Rayleigh worked out the equations of scattering (the famous 1/λ4 law) and the polarization in his paper "On the Light from the Sky, its Polarization and Colour", in Phil. Mag. XLI, pages 107-120 and 274-279 (1871).

This paper was published about 25 years before the discovery of the electron, 35 years before Rutherford scattering, and 45 years before Bohr's model of the atom. Needless to say, Lord Rayleigh's model did not require any of these.
 
  • #5
Bob S said:
This paper was published about 25 years before the discovery of the electron, 35 years before Rutherford scattering, and 45 years before Bohr's model of the atom. Needless to say, Lord Rayleigh's model did not require any of these.
Yes, to do wave optics, all you need are Maxwell's Equations. They do not, however, completely explain propagation of electromagnetic wave through matter. In particular, none of it explains why some materials are opaque and some are transparent despite very similar electric properties. You do need quantum physics to explain that one.
 

1. Why do photons not pass straight through objects?

Photons, which are particles of light, do not pass straight through objects because they interact with the atoms and molecules of the object. As photons travel through a material, they may be absorbed, reflected, or scattered by the atoms and molecules that make up the material. This interaction causes the photons to change direction and lose energy, making it difficult for them to pass straight through.

2. How do photons interact with objects?

Photons interact with objects through a process called absorption. When a photon collides with an atom or molecule, it may be absorbed, causing the atom or molecule to become excited and change its energy level. This absorption leads to the photons losing energy, changing direction, or being scattered.

3. Why do some objects appear opaque while others are transparent?

The opacity or transparency of an object depends on the material's ability to absorb or transmit photons. Objects that are opaque have atoms and molecules that strongly absorb photons, while transparent objects have atoms and molecules that do not absorb photons as much, allowing them to pass through with minimal interaction.

4. Can photons pass through all types of materials?

No, photons cannot pass through all types of materials. The ability of photons to pass through a material depends on the material's composition and the energy of the photons. For example, x-rays can easily pass through soft tissues like skin and muscle, but they are absorbed by denser materials like bones.

5. How does the thickness of an object affect the passage of photons?

The thickness of an object can affect the passage of photons by increasing the chance of interactions between photons and the material. As photons travel through an object, they have a higher chance of being absorbed, scattered, or reflected the thicker the object is. This is why thicker materials, such as a thick piece of glass, can appear more opaque than thinner materials, like a windowpane.

Similar threads

  • Special and General Relativity
3
Replies
74
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
9K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
3K
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
191
Replies
2
Views
11K
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
1K
Back
Top