Resolving Retaining Wall Issue: Seeking Advice ASAP!

  • Thread starter CreatesMoreWork
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Wall
In summary, the builder is looking for ways to stabilize a hillside which has moved and is holding back a slab with a retaining wall. They are considering driving rebar into the slab, tunneling beneath it, or tying back the existing wall.
  • #1
CreatesMoreWork
5
0
I saw a similar thread on this issue - so I'm cross posting this forum with a builders forum as well - as I'm very worried about this, and am seeking input ASAP... I apologize if this is off-topic - but I really need some advice ASAP...

Last week I cleared an area out next to a fence that has a slight slope on it (about 1' within 2-3' distance). I cut the ground down equal to the neighbor's fence line, and then put in a retaining wall consisting of 2x12s, staked in with 18" steel stakes.

Then, I poured a long slab with the intention of building a firewood shelter on it. The next day, I noticed that one part of the retaining wall has moved about 1/2" or so - so I staked it with 48" long, 1/2 thick rebar at several points to arrest the movement.

I'm now trying to determine the best path to stabilize the hillside and arrest further movement of this slab, or the retaining wall beneath it... I've been considering driving some rebar in at an angle against the slab, or even tunneling beneath it in places to pour smaller bench footings...but I'm not sure...

When you have a second, could you take a look at the attached and give me your thoughts on this...

Thanks -
 

Attachments

  • Hillside1.jpg
    Hillside1.jpg
    81.5 KB · Views: 670
  • Hillside2.jpg
    Hillside2.jpg
    90.8 KB · Views: 675
  • Hillside3.jpg
    Hillside3.jpg
    79.5 KB · Views: 657
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
Could you provide a sideways picture?
 
  • #3
How high up is the top part of that slab? It looks about a foot or so to me. That can be a lot of weight you're holding back.

You sure don't have any real room to do anything on the side with the fence. Did the 2x12's actually move or did they bend? Also, what orientation are the 2x12's in? Is the wide dimension of the board parallel or perpendicular to the ground?

Either way, I don't think this is going to be easy. At first glance I'd say you are looking at one of three things:

1) The movement stops and all will stay put and life is good.
2) You pull it all up and possibly use 4x4's with rebar through each piece to stabilize.
3) You tie back the existing wall somewhat like they do with collapsing basement walls
http://www.engineeredfoundations.com/images/basement_Wall_Repair/retain04.jpg [Broken]

I'd be curious to see what the folks on the builder's forum come up with. I always wondered if there were other options for something like this.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #4
FredGarvin said:
How high up is the top part of that slab? It looks about a foot or so to me. That can be a lot of weight you're holding back.

You sure don't have any real room to do anything on the side with the fence. Did the 2x12's actually move or did they bend? Also, what orientation are the 2x12's in? Is the wide dimension of the board parallel or perpendicular to the ground?

Thanks Fred... The top of the slab is probably 19" or so in total height about the ground plane of the neighbor's yard (12" + 7" of the slab). The 2x12s moved, I think - in the worst place about 1/2" out - they're oriented vertically (see the attached drawing).

Images follow of the two places where the wall has moved - looking down on the wall from above. Also attached are two drawings - showing the current condition, and some thoughts on mitigating some of the problem.

Some friends who've looked at it think that the movement may just be from the wall squeezing out the backfill (since it's soft) - and that the slab is just exerting downward pressure - not lateral movement.

Right now the consensus is to drive a couple of 4' rebar beneath the slab at 45 degree angles, to arrest/slow any additional movement, and then wait the winter (our rainy season) to see what happens...
 

Attachments

  • drawing1.jpg
    drawing1.jpg
    32.9 KB · Views: 455
  • drawings2.jpg
    drawings2.jpg
    22.3 KB · Views: 428
  • gap1.jpg
    gap1.jpg
    53.9 KB · Views: 484
  • #5
See the last attached image of the second gap...
 

Attachments

  • gap2.jpg
    gap2.jpg
    38.1 KB · Views: 436
  • #6
Some friends who've looked at it think that the movement may just be from the wall squeezing out the backfill (since it's soft) - and that the slab is just exerting downward pressure - not lateral movement.

The movement of the retaining wall?, The slab is generating a surcharge on the backfill therefore it is contributing to lateral pressure.

Right now the consensus is to drive a couple of 4' rebar beneath the slab at 45 degree angles, to arrest/slow any additional movement, and then wait the winter (our rainy season) to see what happens...

Well depending on the soil, specially for some types of clay there will be swelling because of humidity thus increasing the lateral pressure on the retaining wall.

Btw, the slab is 7 inches thick? just concrete right (no reinforcement)?
 
  • #7
Yeah, 7 inches thick - with 1/2" rebar reinforcement in a box frame about 1/3 of the way from the bottom of the slab...
 
  • #8
Angled supports, sound good. But make sure that you have left holes in the retaining wall, for the rain water to drain through, or else it will serve as a dam and the combined weight will bring the whole thing down. django
 
  • #9
This thing is only 12" tall and the only problem that you're liable to have is that the retaining wall will keep moving letting the slab tilt once the soil gets wet. Any thin items pounded into the hill under the slab won't do anything since they are too thin to provide resistance to soil moving past them. The fix is simple but will cost you some $$ in additional concrete. I've attached a sketch showing the fix.

Basically just leave your retaining wall in place, (add a few supports to keep it in place when you pour the concrete behind it). Under cut the slab by about 6" or so and fill the space behind the retaining wall with concrete. You can add some rebar for some assurance if you'd like, but at 12" tall you probably don't need it. Remember to vibrate the new concrete well to get it to "float" up under the slab since you're bound to have a hollow spot under it once you start undercutting. You really don't have to worry much about drainage with such a short wall.
 

Attachments

  • drawing1rev1.jpg
    drawing1rev1.jpg
    27.1 KB · Views: 510
  • #10
Michael_E said:
This thing is only 12" tall and the only problem that you're liable to have is that the retaining wall will keep moving letting the slab tilt once the soil gets wet. Any thin items pounded into the hill under the slab won't do anything since they are too thin to provide resistance to soil moving past them. The fix is simple but will cost you some $$ in additional concrete. I've attached a sketch showing the fix.

Basically just leave your retaining wall in place, (add a few supports to keep it in place when you pour the concrete behind it). Under cut the slab by about 6" or so and fill the space behind the retaining wall with concrete. You can add some rebar for some assurance if you'd like, but at 12" tall you probably don't need it. Remember to vibrate the new concrete well to get it to "float" up under the slab since you're bound to have a hollow spot under it once you start undercutting. You really don't have to worry much about drainage with such a short wall.


Thanks Michael - I appreciate the input. I've had that idea suggested to me also. A friend of mine (a commercial contractor) is coming over on Saturday, and we'll probably end up doing just that - in combination with drilling two holes in each slab - one at each end - and then running vertical rebar down into them so they won't move laterally. I like you're idea also, however - and we'll probably end up doing that as well...

Thanks again -
 
  • #11
Right! Michael I agree with Your reply.
 
  • #12
Your probably already done with this project. I have built miles and miles of MSE(material stabilizing excavation) walls at work, they are a bit larger than yours but some of the procedures may help you out if you haven't finished yet. We alway backfill the wall with 3/4 inch gravel, it will be at about 94% compaction just dumping it in the hole, and it won't settle like dirt grade will. The next thing is we always use tiebacks, that is strips of galvonized metal with cleats on it, they are laid back and covered with dirt that is compacted so that the weight of the dirt holds the wall back, we use some that are as long as 30 ft but our walls are about 50 feet high, I would think with a 1 foot tall wall you could probably get away with less than 5 ft depending on your soil(sandy longer, clayish shorter). Any larger builder supply shop should have some straps and you could probably attach them to your existing concrete by drilling some holes and using an epoxy. I wouldn't trust epoxy on a wall any higher than a couple feet but it would be cheaper and easier than forming and pouring more concrete,imo. Hope this helps.
 

1. What are the common causes of retaining wall issues?

There are several factors that can contribute to retaining wall issues, such as poor construction, inadequate drainage, and soil movement or erosion. Other factors may include heavy rainfall, improper maintenance, and inadequate design for the specific soil conditions.

2. How can I determine if my retaining wall needs to be repaired or replaced?

If you notice any signs of damage, such as cracks, bulging, or leaning, it is important to have your retaining wall inspected by a professional. They will be able to assess the severity of the issue and determine if repair or replacement is necessary.

3. Can I fix a retaining wall issue on my own?

It is not recommended to try and fix a retaining wall issue on your own, as it requires specialized knowledge and skills. It is best to consult with a professional engineer or contractor who has experience in dealing with retaining wall problems.

4. How much does it typically cost to resolve a retaining wall issue?

The cost of resolving a retaining wall issue can vary depending on the severity of the problem and the type of repair or replacement needed. It is best to get quotes from multiple professionals to get an accurate estimate for your specific situation.

5. Can retaining wall issues be prevented?

While some factors that contribute to retaining wall issues may be out of your control, there are steps you can take to prevent or minimize the chances of problems occurring. This includes proper construction and maintenance, as well as choosing the right materials and design for your specific location and soil conditions.

Similar threads

Replies
4
Views
17K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
15
Views
1K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • STEM Career Guidance
3
Replies
94
Views
109K
  • Sci-Fi Writing and World Building
Replies
22
Views
4K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
12
Views
3K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Back
Top