Exploring the Possibilities of Wood and Water

  • Thread starter Arsonade
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Water Wood
In summary, the conversation discusses the possibility of turning wood into liquid by heating it in a low oxygen environment and throwing a ball of water into the sun. It is noted that not all solids turn into liquids and there are various phase changes such as melting, evaporation, and sublimation. The conversation also mentions the complexity of wood as a composite material and how it may behave differently when pushed around a P-V diagram. It is suggested that wood would likely release gases before turning into liquid. As for the water falling into the sun, it is hypothesized that it would turn into a plasma and eventually fuse into helium. It is also noted that heating wood in an airtight container can lead to explosions and precautions should be taken. The conversation
  • #1
Arsonade
151
0
to start with i really know almost nothing about this, just curios. What if one took wood, put it into a vacuum and heated it up, a lot, since all solids turn to liquids (a fact I am sure is arguable), would the effect be liquid wood?

Also, what if a ball of water was hurled into the sun, assuming it makes it there, it turns into water vapor, but is still being draged in by the sun's gravity, what would happen to the mollocules?

Thanks
Adam
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Not all solids turn into liquids. Some solids turn to gas and some gases turn into solids (like snow).

The familiar phase changes are melting (solid to liquid), evaporation (liquid to gas), condensation (gas to liquid) and freezing (liquid to solid). But there is also sublimation (solid to gas) and deposition (gas to solid).

Water in solid, liquid or gas form will still be attracted by the gravity of the sun. If gases weren't effected by gravity then we would have no atmosphere.
 
  • #3
Burning wood in a low oxygen environment would give you charcoal.
 
  • #4
Wood is a composite. Those simplified phase diagrams are more representative of simple, elemental materials. For instance, water deviates from the simple phase diagram even at ordinary temperatures and pressures. Wood is way more complicated than water: you've got carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, various metals, all sorts of crap in there. When you start pushing a material around the P-V diagram, the different elements tend to demonstrate their different properties. For instance, when they make liquid nitrogen, they basically condense the air, which also, as it happens, contains oxygen. If I'm not mistaken, liquid oxygen condenses out of the air before the nitrogen, so that, by the time the nitrogen condenses, the gas is no longer air, but air minus nitrogen (whatever you would call that mixture). For wood, I would imagine that the first thing to go would be the loosely bound H2O molecules. From there, I have no idea.

As far as the "water falling into the sun" question:
The water vapor would change phase into a plasma, and then I reckon the hydrogen ions would eventually fuse to form helium.
 
Last edited:
  • #5
turin said:
Wood is a composite. Those simplified phase diagrams are more representative of simple, elemental materials. For instance, water deviates from the simple phase diagram even at ordinary temperatures and pressures. Wood is way more complicated than water: you've got carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, various metals, all sorts of crap in there. When you start pushing a material around the P-V diagram, the different elements tend to demonstrate their different properties. For instance, when they make liquid nitrogen, they basically condense the air, which also, as it happens, contains oxygen. If I'm not mistaken, liquid oxygen condenses out of the air before the nitrogen, so that, by the time the nitrogen condenses, the gas is no longer air, but air minus nitrogen (whatever you would call that mixture). For wood, I would imagine that the first thing to go would be the loosely bound H2O molecules. From there, I have no idea.

As far as the "water falling into the sun" question:
The water vapor would change phase into a plasma, and then I reckon the hydrogen ions would eventually fuse to form helium.

Cool, i think I am going to try it, (the wood melting thing not the sun thing lol) wish me luck

Adam
 
  • #6
Arsonade said:
Cool, i think I am going to try it, (the wood melting thing not the sun thing lol) wish me luck

Adam

Careful!

Wood tends to outgas a lot when heated. If you put it in an airtight container, and heat it to charring temperatures, you could get a small explosion. Generally, the "distillation of wood" experiment is done by placing wood in a test tube, put a stopper with a hole in the tube, and a glass pipette in the hole. The flammable gas is safely carried away from the heat this way.

Njorl
 
  • #7
Njorl said:
Careful!

Wood tends to outgas a lot when heated. If you put it in an airtight container, and heat it to charring temperatures, you could get a small explosion. Generally, the "distillation of wood" experiment is done by placing wood in a test tube, put a stopper with a hole in the tube, and a glass pipette in the hole. The flammable gas is safely carried away from the heat this way.

Njorl

Thanks for the warning lol, but, how can i take away the gas without letting any air in? the whole point is that it won't burn if there's no air.

Adam
 
  • #8
Arsonade said:
Thanks for the warning lol, but, how can i take away the gas without letting any air in? the whole point is that it won't burn if there's no air.

Adam

If you are heating the vessel with the wood in it, the expansion of the gasses the wood gives off will drive the oxygen out of the vessel. You could also put a bit of water in there. The production of water vapor will occur long before the wood begins to char. The water vapor will displace the oxygen.

Njorl
 
  • #10
I think you need a vacuum system, with a pump continuously evacuating the chamber.

Something like a thermal evaporator ?
 
  • #11
Gokul43201 said:
I think you need a vacuum system, with a pump continuously evacuating the chamber.

Something like a thermal evaporator ?

sounds like a plan huh, now all i need is a vacuum chamberr

Adam
 
  • #12
The "vacuum chamber" is built-in; air won't come in because there's so much stuff coming out.
 
  • #13
Hurkyl said:
The "vacuum chamber" is built-in; air won't come in because there's so much stuff coming out.

exactly, now i just got to get one lol
 
  • #14
lol, tell us how it turns out when u do it. :D
 
  • #15
ArmoSkater87 said:
lol, tell us how it turns out when u do it. :D

actually i don't think there's any way i can do that without a school science lab or somthing and i won't have time to, o well, ill leave this one to those who have not been blacklisted from the science labs in their town for varios danjourus experiments lol.

Adam
 
  • #16
Hypothetical

Here's a hypothetical situation: let's say you have one atom. Without other atoms around, how can yoyu determine it's state outside of plasma or not plasma? Because when something freezes, it forms a crystaline structure with the other atoms around it, so can it freeze? Can it be a liquid? or a gas? Obviously you could just say the termperature determines it, but that doesn't really describe a difference in the atom's behavior if no others are present.
 
  • #17
Funny you should ask because I questioned my chem lab teacher last semester on this same subject. Of course I just wanted to see what kind of answer he would give me because I figured any sort of heating under ordinary circumstances would just combust the dang log. He said pretty much along the lines of what has already been said: Since wood is a composite of many things (And therefore many different melting points) that it may be impossible to liquify entirely. There may exist no point where all the materials are liquid: one may be a solid and the rest may be all liquid, but if you decrease the pressure or increase the temperature just a little bit, one of those liquids could boil.
 
  • #18
You can do this at home on the stove, no special equipment is required. I did it when I was a kid. Of course back in those days we had coffee cans with metal lids the resealed pretty well. Not sure what to use now. You need something with a tight lid (Moms nice cook ware is NOT what you want!)
Put a small hole in the lid to let the gas escape. The trick was that the escaping gases could be burned as they exited. Charcoal remained inside after the more volatile elements vaporised.
 
  • #19
proteus said:
Here's a hypothetical situation: let's say you have one atom. Without other atoms around, how can yoyu determine it's state outside of plasma or not plasma?
Without other atoms around, an atom can't be a "solid" or "liquid." And that's not really relevant to the thread topic...
 
  • #20
russ_watters said:
Without other atoms around, an atom can't be a "solid" or "liquid." And that's not really relevant to the thread topic...

The subject is the same, the situation and specifics are different. I thought the wood thing was sort of exhausted too.

Sorry.
 

1. What makes wood and water a good combination for exploration?

Wood and water are two of the most abundant and versatile natural resources. Wood is a strong and durable material that can be easily shaped and manipulated, while water is a vital source of life and can be found in various forms such as rivers, lakes, and oceans. This combination offers endless possibilities for scientific research and discovery.

2. How does water affect the properties of wood?

Water can have a significant impact on the physical and mechanical properties of wood. When wood absorbs water, it can swell and change in dimension, leading to changes in strength, stiffness, and density. Water can also cause decay and degradation of wood, which can affect its durability and lifespan.

3. Can wood and water be used together in construction?

Yes, wood and water can be used together in construction, but it requires careful consideration and proper treatment. Wood that will be in constant contact with water, such as in marine environments, must be treated with preservatives to prevent decay. Additionally, the design and construction methods must account for the potential effects of water on the wood.

4. How can wood and water be used for sustainable solutions?

Wood and water can be used in various sustainable solutions, such as using wood as a renewable building material and using water as a source of renewable energy. Wood can also be used in water filtration and purification systems, while water can be used to power mills and other machinery in the wood industry.

5. What are the potential drawbacks of using wood and water together?

One potential drawback of using wood and water together is the risk of degradation and damage to the wood over time. This can be mitigated through proper treatment and maintenance, but it is still a factor to consider. Additionally, the use of water in wood-related industries can also have environmental impacts, such as water pollution and the depletion of freshwater sources.

Similar threads

Replies
32
Views
1K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
28
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
951
Replies
25
Views
2K
Replies
23
Views
1K
Replies
49
Views
12K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
3
Views
5K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
5K
Replies
7
Views
759
Back
Top