Reasonable approach to learning mathematics? (Starting with logic.)

In summary: As for Hilbert's book, even if it may be challenging, any effort put into reading it will still be valuable and help improve your understanding and abilities.
  • #1
singleton
121
0
Good evening,

I'd like some advice on my approach to learning mathematics (e.g. is this reasonable).

Right now I'm interested in computing. I understand basic algorithms such as how quick, heap, merge, insertion and bubble sort work. But that is the extent--I'd love to learn more about algorithms, computability and complexity topics.

My immediate interests are centered around learning Mathematical Logic for the Prolog programming language (which, from what I understand, is based on first-order predicate calculus). I'd like to work on some *very* minimal AI systems and other things that build directly on top of Mathematical Logic.

In 2-3 years time, I plan to pursue my interests in science. At that time I will focus on other areas such as calculus, algebra, differential equations, differential geometry, topology... (this is according to the curriculum for the programme I wish to enter).

Recalling that some great mathematicians attempted to axiomize the logic and suggest that everything comes from the foundations--mathematical logic and set theory--I wondered if it would be wise to start off with logic? Would it benefit me for my later studies (re: science). More importantly, would it make me much stronger with the math?

About me:
I have a background in programming. Not computer science. I have minimal exposure to algorithms and my bachelors program did not contain any math offerings. My math abilities end at the high school level.

So I would like to know whether or not it is a good idea to dabble with logic, algorithms, (and time permitting) computability and complexity theory and then to later (~2-3 years) try my hand at the other topics listed.

Is this a "sound" approach, or should I be doing it another way? I really have no concept of how difficult these topics are, so please enlighten me :biggrin:

Best regards and thanks for your thoughts.

P.S. How deep does the rabbit hole go with regard to the topic of Mathematical Logic?

(Can anyone recommend David Hilbert's Principles of Mathematical Logic ? I've managed to read the first 6 pages (of ~170) on Amazon and they are quite accessible--would it get very difficult after that? The TOC reads: I. The Sentential Calculus, II. The Calculus of Classes (Monadic Predicate Calculus), III. The Restricted Predicate Calculus, IV. The Extended Predicate Calculus.)
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
  • #2
mathematical logic is probably of no help in learning math at all, although basic understanding of principles of reasoning is essential.

for math about all the logic you need is when syllogisms are true, when false, what it means to combine statements by "and", "or", "implies", and what applying "not" does.

e.g. it is not true that A implies B, if and only if A is true and B is false.It is not true that "A and B", if and only if one or both of A,B is false. That kind of trivial thing. Math is mostly about imagination, analogy, generalization, specialization, ability to visualize, and computing power, not formal logic at all.But some people are very good at math and very interested in logic too. in fact people who liked logic tend to be among the smarter people i have known, and they were all very good at math.
 
  • #3
Thanks, Mathwonk.

Even though it may be of no direct benefit to my later studies, I think I should enjoy this for my programming pursuits (re: prolog).

I'm just not confident on whether or not I am 'capable' of learning logic from Hilbert's book. The first six pages are quite accessible but whether or not it builds on other mathematical knowledge and expects the reader to be experienced... I do not know! :frown:
 
  • #4
from my limited experience, whenever you try hard to read a master like hilbert, you always get something from it. even if you only make it through a few pages, you find out later that you understand more than other people who have studied writings of lesser mortals.

i remmber one day in grad school i went to the librarry to read zariski's paper on non singular points. it took me three hours or so to get through a page or two. i felt discouraged. but when i returned to class, i knew the answer to every question the lecturer posed, until he told me to stop answering as it was "obvious i knew the subject well".
 

1. What is the role of logic in learning mathematics?

The role of logic in learning mathematics is to provide a systematic and organized approach to problem-solving. It helps in identifying patterns, making connections, and drawing conclusions based on logical reasoning.

2. How can one develop a reasonable approach to learning mathematics?

A reasonable approach to learning mathematics can be developed by understanding the underlying concepts and principles, practicing regularly, breaking down complex problems into smaller parts, and seeking help from teachers or peers when needed.

3. Is it important to have a logical mindset for learning mathematics?

Yes, having a logical mindset is crucial for learning mathematics as it enables one to think critically, analyze information, and come up with logical solutions to problems.

4. How can one overcome challenges in learning mathematics using a reasonable approach?

Overcoming challenges in learning mathematics using a reasonable approach involves being patient, persistent, and open to learning from mistakes. It also helps to break down problems into smaller, more manageable steps and seeking support from teachers or tutors.

5. Can a reasonable approach to learning mathematics help in other areas of study or life?

Yes, a reasonable approach to learning mathematics can be beneficial in other areas of study and life. It develops critical thinking skills, problem-solving abilities, and enhances logical reasoning, which are valuable skills in various fields and everyday life.

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
708
Replies
8
Views
445
  • General Math
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
9
Views
900
Replies
10
Views
957
  • General Math
Replies
13
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
709
  • Programming and Computer Science
Replies
15
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
7
Views
846
Back
Top