Urban Legend- Breaking tempered glass with Aluminum Oxide

In summary, there are speculations and videos suggesting that tossing a disassembled spark plug at a car window can cause it to spontaneously shatter. This is due to the hardness of aluminum oxide in the spark plug and the internal stresses of tempered glass. However, the validity of this claim is still questionable and could potentially be a myth perpetuated by the internet. Further research and experimentation is needed to determine the truth behind this phenomenon.
  • #1
wil3
179
1
There are a lot of youtube videos and online forum speculations that suggest that tossing a disassembled spark plug at a car window will cause the window to spontaneously shatter. The supposed justification is that tempered glass can easily withstand from softer materials than it (such as the iron of a hammer), but even a light brush with a material of higher Mohs scale strength (such as the Aluminum Oxide within the spark plug) causes it to spontaneously shatter in a manner similar to Prince Rupert's drops.

Is this rumor true? If so, does someone have a more detailed explanation of the physics behind this effect. Sources would be excellent- google is not turning up any credible information.

Also, what specific properties of car door glass make it susceptible to this effect?

Thank you in advance.
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
  • #2
I have no idea if it is true but if it was then I might have a guess why. Aluminum oxide (in some forms) is one of the hardest materials known to man. Glass shatters because it has very low ductility. Ductility is how much a material can undergo mechanical stress (bending, twisting, etc.) without fracturing.
 
  • #3
Tempered glass is made by a process that generates internal stresses within the glass.

The surface of the material is under compression, while the interior is under tension. In order to shatter the glass, you need to produce a crack or scratch that goes deep enough to reach the part of the material under tension.
 
  • #4
I think I think an experiment is in order. Who's the first volunteer to who will throw chunks of disassembled sparkplugs at his wind shield?

Somehow I think this mythology is perpetuated by a desire not to trash ones car to dispel it.

Neighbor: Why are you out at midnight throwing things at my car?
Self: I didn't find it justifiable to destroy my own, but there's this this really weird thing I heard on the internet I needed to test...

And, um, what aluminum oxide? Spark plugs are made of metals and fired clay.
 
Last edited:
  • #5
It's not the hardness, Moh's scale and scratches only apply at small forces and low speeds.

Breaking a window is all about force applied at a point, wood is a lot softer than glass but you would have no problem breaking a window with a baseball bat.
The reason a sparkplug breaks a window is that it's pointed.
 
  • #6
mgb_phys said:
It's not the hardness, Moh's scale and scratches only apply at small forces and low speeds.

Breaking a window is all about force applied at a point, wood is a lot softer than glass but you would have no problem breaking a window with a baseball bat.
The reason a sparkplug breaks a window is that it's pointed.
You're not getting the point of tempered glass, apparently.

It's not about supplying sufficient force to snap the window in two, it's about getting a crack down to the material that's under tension so the internal stresses can propagate the crack further.
 
  • #7
It's not about supplying sufficient force to snap the window in two, it's about getting a crack down to the material that's under tension so the internal stresses can propagate the crack further.

Agreed, that's why I mentioned Prince Rupert's drops as an example of tempered glass. Do you think that the hardness of Aluminum oxide makes it more susceptible to creating a deep scratch, even when it is tossed at a low speed? I know that a car window can withstand a decent hit from a hammer, but these guys literally just toss a tiny bit of Aluminum Oxide at the window.

Here is a supposed video of the effect:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=khayfayzXK8&feature=related


And, um, what aluminum oxide? Spark plugs are made of metals and fired clay.

Spark plugs do contain aluminum oxide. It acts as a replacement for the "clay" (porcelain) insulator near the pointed ends, as Aluminum Oxide can withstand the high temperature of the plasma arc a bit better than clay can.

Thank you for all your replies!
 
  • #8
PhaseShifter said:
You're not getting the point of tempered glass, apparently.
It's not about supplying sufficient force to snap the window in two, it's about getting a crack down to the material that's under tension so the internal stresses can propagate the crack further.

It's not about supplying sufficient force to snap the window in two, it's about getting a crack down to the material that's under tension so the internal stresses can propagate the crack further.
Do you really believe a spark plug could made such a deep crack? It seems excessively optimistic to me. This urban legend is what its name suggests: a legend.
 
  • #9
lightarrow said:
Do you really believe a spark plug could made such a deep crack? It seems excessively optimistic to me. This urban legend is what its name suggests: a legend.

I'm not saying I believe it, but I'm not ready to dismiss it out of hand either.

What do you mean by "such a deep crack?"
It doesn't have to go all the way through the glass.

Small pebbles made of softer material frequently chip windshields, and pebbles tend to be rounded rather than having sharp edges to concentrate the force of the impact.

There are also known cases of tempered glass shattering spontaneously, without any outwardly observable cause.

I don't think it's inconceivable that the sharp edge on a small chip of ceramic might be enough to trigger shattering in an inferior quality piece of tempered glass.

I've seen a tool for EMTs to get through tempered glass--it's basically a spring-loaded punch that can be operated with just the strength in your thumb. On the other hand, if you try to punch through a windshield with your fist, you're more likely to break your hand than the glass.
 
  • #10
PhaseShifter said:
I'm not saying I believe it, but I'm not ready to dismiss it out of hand either.
What has a piece of porcelain from a disassembled spark plug more than other pieces of rock? A windscreen have to resist pieces of rock coming out from other veichles, for example. That effect on youtube could be true for *some* bad constructed windows, certainly not for all, as they wanted to make us believe.
What do you mean by "such a deep crack?"
It doesn't have to go all the way through the glass.
Yes but glass windows are continuously scratched in their surface from little pieces of solid material, even from dust. Why they don't break?
 
Last edited:
  • #11
What has a piece of porcelain from a disassembled spark plug more than other pieces of rock? A windscreen have to resist pieces of rock coming out from other veichles, for example. That effect on youtube could be true for *some* bad constructed windows, certainly not for all, as they wanted to make us believe.


We've already established that the difference is hardness; most general rocks are not higher in terms of the Mohs scale than the galss is, but Aluminum Oxide is.
Yes but glass windows are continuously scratched in their surface from little pieces of solid material, even from dust. Why they don't break?

That's what we are trying to figure out. Maybe the smaller scratches are just in hte UV protective finish, and not the actual pane?
 

What is the urban legend about breaking tempered glass with Aluminum Oxide?

The urban legend claims that if you rub a piece of Aluminum Oxide (also known as sandpaper) against a tempered glass surface, it will shatter into tiny pieces.

Is this urban legend true?

No, this urban legend is not true. It is physically impossible to break tempered glass with Aluminum Oxide alone.

Why do people believe this urban legend?

People may believe this urban legend because they have seen videos or heard stories of others attempting to break tempered glass with Aluminum Oxide. However, these videos are often staged or use other methods to create the appearance of shattered glass.

Can tempered glass be broken at all?

Yes, tempered glass can be broken but it requires a significant amount of force or impact. Tempered glass is designed to be stronger and more resistant to breaking than regular glass, but it is not indestructible.

How should I handle tempered glass to avoid injury?

To avoid injury, always handle tempered glass with care and avoid applying excessive force or pressure to the surface. In the event that tempered glass does break, it will shatter into small, rounded pieces rather than sharp, jagged shards like regular glass.

Similar threads

  • General Discussion
Replies
1
Views
8K
Back
Top