Solving Projectile w/ Initial Height, Height Max, Horiz Dist.

[Matthew_S]

Hi everyone,

I'm trying to design a formula that determines the launch velocity, launch angle, and time spent in the air for a projectile if only the initial launch height, maximum height reached, and total horizontal distance traveled before the projectile hits the ground are known. It's not too hard to design a formula if the initial height is the ground (since the parabolic path taken by the projectile is symmetrical), but once the initial height and ground level are different, things get a lot harder. I tried looking everywhere online and deriving my own formula, without success. Does anyone know of such a formula?

Thanks,
Matt

 

[Nessdude14]

You can work through it with a system of equations but it gets a bit convoluted. I'll explain the process that you'd go through to solve it, but I won't bother writing out the equations as they get quite long and ugly. Let me know if further explanation is needed.

The ball reaches the max height when the vertical velocity is 0, so make an equation for the y-component of initial velocity (I called initial velocity v_i, and the y-component is v_iy), and set v_iy to 0. Solve this for t; I called it t_max, for the time that the projectile reaches the max height.

Next, make an equation for the height of the projectile as a function of time. In this equation, substitute t_max for t. The height can be called h_max, this is one of your known parameters. Solve this equation for v_i.

Then, you want to make an equation for the final x-distance (I called this x_f). The projectile will reach this final x-distance at the moment the height of the projectile reaches 0, and it hits the ground. Using your height equation and setting height to 0, you can solve for t, to find the time that the ball contacts the ground (t_f).

Make an equation for the x-displacement using the x-component of velocity (v_ix=v_icos(θ)). Replacing t with t_f and x with x_f, this allows you to use another known parameter. Substitute in the v_i and t_f found earlier, and you can solve for theta.

After you have theta, you can plug it into your v_i equation to find the numerical value for v_i. Hope this helps.

 

[Matthew_S]

Thank you so much! I don't think you solve for the velocity in the height equation, only the vertical component. But using your steps, I was able to get the angle to cancel out and get only the velocity. The ugliest kinematics equation I've ever seen, but it gets the job done.

 

[Nessdude14]

Thank you so much! I don't think you solve for the velocity in the height equation, only the vertical component. But using your steps, I was able to get the angle to cancel out and get only the velocity. The ugliest kinematics equation I've ever seen, but it gets the job done.

If you cancel out the angle, it won't do you any good because your answer is dependent on the angle.
In the height equation, you use v_iy=v_isinθ to solve for v_i.

 

[voko]

From the launch height h and max height H, using the potential/kinetic energy equation, you get $Y = \sqrt {2g(H - h)}$, where $Y$ is the vertical component of the velocity. You also get $T_1 = \frac Y g = \sqrt { \frac { 2(H - h) } g }$ for the time of ascent, and, similarly, $T_2 = \sqrt { \frac { 2H } g }$ for the time of descent. Then, $X = \frac D {T_1 + T_2}$, for the horizontal velocity component, and $\theta = \arctan \frac Y X$. You could probably simplify things somewhat.

 

[Matthew_S]

When the angle canceled out, I was left with an equation whose only unknowns were the total time and velocity. I managed to express t in terms of h_max, h_0, and fundamental constants and solved for v, which could then be used for theta. In response to voko, I didn't see that approach until now but it looks a lot more efficient than what I did before.

I'm now working on solving a projectile problem knowing only the initial launch height, the maximum launch height, and the time the projectile was in the air. I'm trying to find the distance by working backwards, but it's not working so far.

 

[voko]

For the sake of completeness: $V = \sqrt {X^2 + Y^2}$ - that's the magnitude of the launch velocity.

 

[Nessdude14]

When the angle canceled out, I was left with an equation whose only unknowns were the total time and velocity. I managed to express t in terms of h_max, h_0, and fundamental constants and solved for v, which could then be used for theta. In response to voko, I didn't see that approach until now but it looks a lot more efficient than what I did before.

The angle can cancel out of the max height equation because with the right velocity, you can reach a given max height from any launch angle. However, the x_f location is different for each launch angle in this case. There's only one angle that will make a trajectory that goes through both points (h_max and x_f), so although it may seem like the angle can cancel from the height equation, it's necessary to keep it in.

 

[voko]

I'm now working on solving a projectile problem knowing only the initial launch height, the maximum launch height, and the time the projectile was in the air. I'm trying to find the distance by working backwards, but it's not working so far.

There is no solution for this. The total flight time is a condition only on the vertical velocity component. The horizontal component may be any, and you can get arbitrary distance for any flight time.

 

[Matthew_S]

That's true, thanks again - you saved me a lot of time