New Reply

Particles as Force Carriers - How Does It Work?

 
Share Thread Thread Tools
Jun22-12, 05:09 PM   #18
K^2
 
Recognitions:
Science Advisor Science Advisor

Particles as Force Carriers - How Does It Work?


Dirac is RQFT, of course. And it's all 4-momentum. Where did you see any 3-momentum operators in that theory?

Where non-relativistic QFT shows up is condensed matter. There, you would often just use Shroedinger equation, but with second-quantized fields. I don't deal with these, though. So I'm a bad person to ask about any details.
 
Jun22-12, 06:07 PM   #19
 
Blog Entries: 27
Recognitions:
Gold Membership Gold Member
Homework Helper Homework Help
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Quote by K^2 View Post
Dirac is RQFT, of course. And it's all 4-momentum.
ah, weinberg just calls it QFT

(i suspect it's generally assumed that everything is "R", so there's no need to say it)
Where did you see any 3-momentum operators in that theory?
i don't

i see creation and annihilation operators which are functions of the 3-momentum p

i see them, for example, as a(p,σ,n) throughout §6.1 of weinberg (pp.259-274)

i do not see any creation and annihilation operators in the form a(q,σ,n), as functions of the 4-momentum q

nor do i see any creation and annihilation operators at all in §6.3

(which is why i say there are no creation or annihilation operators for off-mass-shell virtual particles in the maths)

§6.1 deals with the coordinate-space representation of the S-matrix, in which only 3-momentum is conserved at each vertex …
by the end of §6.1, the creation and annihilation operators have been eliminated, resulting in a non-operator formula which, however, is a function of ps, and is not lorentz invariant
§6.3 deals with the momentum-space representation of the S-matrix, in which 4-momentum is conserved at each vertex …
by defining an extra variable, the non-operator formula from §6.1 is made lorentz invariant, resulting in a non-operator formula which is a function of qs, and is lorentz invariant
so i say that coordinate-space (ie feynman diagrams of the 1st type) has on-mass-shell 4-momentums, and creation and annihilation operators for (on-mass-shell virtual) particles with those 4-momentums,

but momentum-space (ie feynman diagrams of the 2nd type) has off-mass-shell 4-momentums, but no creation or annihilation operators at all
ie off-mass-shell virtual particles don't even exist in the maths, because the maths doesn't include any creation or annihilation operators for them
 
New Reply

Tags
virtual particles
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: Particles as Force Carriers - How Does It Work?
Thread Forum Replies
fermionic force carriers? Beyond the Standard Model 1
Force Carriers - How do they work? Quantum Physics 3
Force carriers Quantum Physics 2
force carriers High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics 12
Force Carriers High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics 14