## Third movement of Copernicus

Astronomy considers only two main movements of Earth, rotation around its axis in a day and the revolution around the Sun in one year;
because astronomers do not consider the rotation of the earth's axis around itself in a year?

 PhysOrg.com astronomy news on PhysOrg.com >> NASA builds unusual testbed for analyzing X-ray navigation technologies>> Subaru Telescope observations and CoRoT mission unveil future of the Sun>> Galaxy's Ring of Fire

Blog Entries: 27
Recognitions:
Gold Member
Homework Help
Hi Franco! Welcome to PF!
 Quote by Franco Malgari Astronomy considers only two main movements of Earth, rotation around its axis in a day and the revolution around the Sun in one year; because astronomers do not consider the rotation of the earth's axis around itself in a year?
I'm not really following you …

the Earth's axis rotates once every 25,772 years, not once a year … see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Precess..._the_equinoxes

(or do you mean the extra day … the Earth rotating 366 1/4 times in a year of 365 1/4 days?)

 Te earth's axis remains in the same position throughout the revolution around the Sun, turning always to the stars. If I made a model of planet earth-sun I forced to use a motor to spin the globe in 365 days just to keep the earth's axis always stationary relative to the revolution around the Sun .. It's not precession..

Mentor
Blog Entries: 9

## Third movement of Copernicus

What is the effect of this "third motion"? It does not seem to show up in the many long term photographs which are taken by the earths telescope.

Perhaps we are still not understanding you.

 This is the question: Attached Thumbnails
 Admin If I understand the situation correctly there is no third movement, so there is no need to consider it. It was just an artifact of older models. If you put a small globe on the turntable, axis will change its direction in the space, and it was already obvious in precopernican times that it is not happening - Earth axis always points in the same direction. To explain the difference between this type of the model and reality third movement was introduced. But Earth is not revolving around the Sun as if rigidly attached to some disc, it is more like a gyroscope.

Mentor
Copernicus' third movement was a completely unnecessary and useless encumbrance. Copernicus envisioned that the natural motion of the Earth would be to have the Earth's axis always tilted toward the Sun. Since this natural motion wasn't what was observed, the axis must have been rotating so as to keep it aligned with the fixed stars.

A better model of the natural motion of the Earth's rotation is that the Earth's rotation axis would remain fixed with respect to inertial space unless torques act to change the Earth's angular momentum.

 Quote by Franco Malgari Astronomy considers only two main movements of Earth, rotation around its axis in a day and the revolution around the Sun in one year; because astronomers do not consider the rotation of the earth's axis around itself in a year?
That is good enough for most amateur astronomers, but not for professional ones. Neither the Earth's angular momentum nor its angular velocity are constant. Astronomers worry about precession, nutation, polar motion, changes in the Earth's rotation rate, etc. There are thousands of terms to the IAU 2006 rotation-nutation-precession model, and even that doesn't capture all of the motion. There are variations that can't be modeled (yet). If you need extreme precision in the Earth's orientation (e.g., microarcsecond pointing) you have but no choice to use the polar motion and ΔUT1 values which are updated daily by the IERS.

Blog Entries: 27
Recognitions:
Gold Member
Homework Help
Franco, this is ridiculous …

all the references seem to be to forum threads such as this.

If you have an proper reference, please specify it in future instead of making us hunt for it.

There is no third movement of Copernicus (other than a historical mistake).

Mentor
 Quote by tiny-tim Franco, this is ridiculous …
Wikipedia article on Copernican heliocentricism, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copernican_heliocentrism
Earth has three motions: daily rotation, annual revolution, and annual tilting of its axis.

J.H.Bridges, Tycho Brahe, in Contemporary Review, February 1902
The third was a movement by which, in revolving around the Sun, the Earth maintained its axis in a direction parallel with itself during the whole circuit. Without this third movement Copernicus imagined that the Earth's axis would always be inclined toward the Sun (or rather toward the axis of the ecliptic) at the same angle ...

Hilary Gatti, Giordano Bruno and Renaissance Science,