Experiment not working...


by Einshteinlover
Tags: experiment, working
Einshteinlover
Einshteinlover is offline
#1
Feb1-14, 09:21 PM
P: 4
Hey Everybody,

I have only posted here a few times before, so if you need some context, please look at my past posts. Basically, I don't have access to a lab right now (long story there) and I have a thesis which depends on empirical results. Normally I would have thrown in the towel, but graduating is really important to me and so I thought I would try my hand at obtaining my results through gedanken experiments. To start simple I tried to measure the value of g. I imagined dropping a lead ball from a height of 1 meter to the ground (in a vacuum of course) and timing the fall using the formula \begin{equation}g=\frac{2h}{t^{2}}\end{equation}. So far so good, but I am not obtaining results consistent with other experiments. I ran 3 trials and obtained times of .567 seconds .217 seconds and 1.21 seconds (all results to within .001s). Neglecting the lack of precision, my results are hardly accurate :( and I'm at a loss as to what could be happening. RIght now I am using a stopwatch timer (which I admit is not very accurate), but I don't see where the error comes from! Please help, I can answer any questions about my experiments!
Phys.Org News Partner Physics news on Phys.org
The hemihelix: Scientists discover a new shape using rubber bands (w/ video)
Mapping the road to quantum gravity
Chameleon crystals could enable active camouflage (w/ video)
DaleSpam
DaleSpam is online now
#2
Feb1-14, 09:47 PM
Mentor
P: 16,488
How can you have experimental results in a thought experiment?
tfr000
tfr000 is offline
#3
Feb1-14, 09:49 PM
tfr000's Avatar
P: 116
How are you starting and stopping the timing? You really need an electronic stop and start if you don't already have them. You can't expect any useful results timing by eye.

Edit... oh, it's a thought experiment. In that case, I don't understand any of this.

jtbell
jtbell is offline
#4
Feb1-14, 11:56 PM
Mentor
jtbell's Avatar
P: 11,255

Experiment not working...


Quote Quote by Einshteinlover View Post
if you need some context, please look at my past posts.
According to one of those posts, you're a third-year Ph.D. student, at least of last August, which makes the purpose of the experiment you described rather puzzling, especially if you need it in order to "graduate."
dipole
dipole is offline
#5
Feb2-14, 12:50 AM
P: 419
This is a kind of question I'd expect from a high school student, not a third year PhD.... something is seriously out of place here.

Do you have a (bachelors) degree in Physics already?
Dadface
Dadface is offline
#6
Feb2-14, 03:22 AM
PF Gold
Dadface's Avatar
P: 2,004
High school students measure g by free fall methods using timing methods described by tfr000 in post three. If all you have is a stop watch you can get reasonble results from pendulum type experiments.
Borek
Borek is offline
#7
Feb2-14, 03:27 AM
Admin
Borek's Avatar
P: 22,712
Why don't you just think about better results?

I would think of getting 1.11 s - that would mean I am on the Moon, which would nicely coincide with the vacuum.
xAxis
xAxis is offline
#8
Feb2-14, 03:36 AM
P: 197
Maybe your gedank stopwatch is broke
mfb
mfb is offline
#9
Feb2-14, 02:43 PM
Mentor
P: 10,864
If there is a real experiment behind this problem, we'll need more information to be able to say anything.
In the gedankenexperiment, if your timing is so wrong the method (here: manual operation of a stopwatch) simply does not work.
Khashishi
Khashishi is offline
#10
Feb4-14, 11:02 AM
P: 836
You said you imagined dropping the lead ball. How do you get actual numbers from an imagination?


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Maximum working shear stress and working force? Introductory Physics Homework 13
A Possible thought experiment/actual experiment for test of Many World Interpretation Quantum Physics 14
Working on a movie and have a question on observer and double slit experiment Quantum Physics 3
What is the scale or density when the double slit experiment stops working? Quantum Physics 15
Atlas Experiment: CERN Video, link: All LHC Experiment docs High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics 2