Register to reply

Does air in an open bag add weight?

by fcacciola
Tags: weight
Share this thread:
Aug21-13, 12:10 PM
P: 6
This is a dumb question but I can't find a definite answer.

If I have, say, a nylon groserry bag and I weigh it *when is open*, then I close it, then weigh again.
It's quite clear that, depending on how I close it, different amounts of air will be locked in the bag so it will weigh differently, but, when it is open, can I account for *any* of the air that is "inside" the bag?

In a conversation I had, I argued that when the bag is open, none of the air "inside" it counts, at all, so when you close it, it always, neccesarily, weighs more.

How is it?
Phys.Org News Partner Physics news on
How did evolution optimize circadian clocks?
New webcast series brings cutting-edge physics talks to the world
High Flux Isotope Reactor named Nuclear Historic Landmark
Aug21-13, 12:33 PM
P: 991
The air in the bag has weight. But it also has buoyancy. If you are weighing this bag in air then the net is zero -- the buoyancy matches the weight. The downforce on the scale will be unaffected by any air that is considered to be inside the closed bag or outside the open bag.

If the air inside the bag were for some reason lighter than the air outside the bag then this could affect the scale reading -- think hot air baloon for instance.
Aug21-13, 12:45 PM
P: 6
Ahhh, interesting, I was thinking that the weight of the air is actually based (IIUC) on its pressue but then there is pressure on the outside as well, so, I was sort of coming to the conclusion that the "sideness" of the air might not affect at all, "solving" the apparent dicotomy.

So, in efect the air within and around the bug just doesn't count at all, right?
And even if the bag is closed at different positions, with different amouts of air, it would still all scale exactly the same (assuming like you said uniform conditions of pressure and temperture), correct?

Aug21-13, 01:01 PM
P: 3,903
Does air in an open bag add weight?

Quote Quote by fcacciola View Post

So, in effect the air within and around the bug just doesn't count at all, right?
As long as it's all the same kind of air, yes. Take your sealed bag full of air into a vacuum chamber and put it on a scale, and it will have a certain weight; poke a hole in the bag and the weight the scale reads will go down as the air escapes. Fill the bag with carbon dioxide ("heavier than usual air") and it will weigh more than if you fill it with hydrogen ("lighter than usual air").
Aug22-13, 04:16 AM
P: 3,216
At the risk of complicating things... a bag full of air has greater mass. So if you were to spin round like a Top the one full of air would pull on your arms slightly more because there is a greater rotating mass. (Obviously you couldn't actually do that experiment easily because the bag full of air is larger and has higher drag). Stop spinning and they both appear to pull on your arms equally for the reason others have given.
Aug22-13, 07:32 AM
P: 6
Now speaking of mass vs weigh, if the bag is open, can you consider that there is any amount of air mass "within" the bag.. if yes, how would you measure it?
My initial intuiton was that, not being any clear boundary between air inside vs outside, then none of the air would have to be considered as being on the inside unless the bag is closed (which is why I argued that being closed it weighs more since it "contains" air.. now I see that I was actually thinking in terms of mass, not weigh).

If I replace air by water then clearly there is water "inside" regardless of how open the bag is, or how the water would end up spilling off the bag... unless, the open bag is fully summerged into a water tank... so, how is it?

IOW, what exacty draws the disctinction between being inside or not of an open container? A glass with half water also contains half of air, or just half of water??
Aug22-13, 08:02 AM
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 39,682
First, when you set up a scale, you have to "zero" it which means that the weight of the air sitting on it is discounted. If you put a bag on the scale, to weigh it, the air in the bag, whether the bag is closed or open, just displaces the air that was already there and so does NOT add anything to the weight of the bag.

Register to reply

Related Discussions
Determining the speed of sound from a half-open open pipe Introductory Physics Homework 14
Open subset of R written as a countable union of pairwise disjoint open intervals? Topology and Analysis 3
Can all open sets in R^n be expressed as countable union of open cubes? Set Theory, Logic, Probability, Statistics 5
Every open set in R is a countable union of open intervals. Prove. Set Theory, Logic, Probability, Statistics 1
Is the uncountably infinite union of open sets is open? Calculus & Beyond Homework 8