Aluminium has no negatively charged particles?


by FoundAlaska
Tags: aluminium, charge, electrons, schottky
FoundAlaska
FoundAlaska is offline
#1
Jul26-13, 04:21 AM
P: 1
Q: "A graduate student tells you that he has observed a Schottky defect in a sample of pure aluminium. Explain why it may take a long time for this graduate student to get his Ph.D"

A: "Pure aluminium has no negatively charged particles, so a Schottky effect can not occur."

So I know a Schottky effect is when both an anion (-) and a cation (+) dissappear together out of a material (both because it has to remain neutral). What I don't understand is why aluminium does not have negatively charged particles. It does have electrons so no I'm just not following here.. Can anyone explain this to me?
Phys.Org News Partner Physics news on Phys.org
How do liquid foams block sound?
When things get glassy, molecules go fractal
Chameleon crystals could enable active camouflage (w/ video)
mfb
mfb is offline
#2
Jul26-13, 05:57 AM
Mentor
P: 10,864
Quote Quote by FoundAlaska View Post
Q: "A graduate student tells you that he has observed a Schottky defect in a sample of pure aluminium. Explain why it may take a long time for this graduate student to get his Ph.D"

A: "Pure aluminium has no negatively charged particles, so a Schottky effect can not occur."

So I know a Schottky effect is when both an anion (-) and a cation (+) dissappear together out of a material (both because it has to remain neutral). What I don't understand is why aluminium does not have negatively charged particles. It does have electrons so no I'm just not following here.. Can anyone explain this to me?
Schottky defect or Schottky effect?
Based on your question, probably the defect.

Where do you expect anions or cations in a sample of pure Al, where all atoms are the same?

Aluminium has electrons, of course, but does it have many free electrons moving around?
Hint: What do you see as hall effect?


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Two negatively charged balloons on strings. Find tensions? Introductory Physics Homework 1
Electrostatic containment of negatively charged gas Classical Physics 7
Charged pen and aluminium foil Advanced Physics Homework 2
Very Simple = a negatively charged rod will only attract what? Introductory Physics Homework 5
Why don't electrons leave a negatively charged metal in air? Quantum Physics 102