Brain games don't boost your brain power.

In summary: There is also one other element: FUN. :smile: Who knows how much of this is just the result of us...enjoying the ride? ;)
  • #1
Kerrie
Staff Emeritus
Gold Member
844
15
Last edited by a moderator:
Biology news on Phys.org
  • #2
what I've found is that games that tell you that you are gradually improving do actually help your brainpower in a psychosomatic way.
bless the human mind, for convincing its better makes it better haha
 
  • #3
So it doesn't boost IQ, but does it still reduce Dementia and Alzheimer's?
http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1147142-3,00.html
 
  • #4
If it does reduce Dementia/Alzheimer's, I certainly won't stop playing Sudoku. I guess what you are born with is what you get, but you can do a lot to prevent your brain from idling away!
 
  • #5
Kerrie said:
If it does reduce Dementia/Alzheimer's, I certainly won't stop playing Sudoku. I guess what you are born with is what you get, but you can do a lot to prevent your brain from idling away!

Good point. Even if "brain calisthenics" won't increase your brain power, they have to be better than doing nothing. And I bet doing nothing has to be better than watching daytime TV :tongue2:.
 
  • #6
Greg Bernhardt said:
So it doesn't boost IQ, but does it still reduce Dementia and Alzheimer's?
http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1147142-3,00.html

Not only that, but video-games of ALL types have been shown (in a study which I will find tomorrow morning and cite here) to increase scoring on tests to measure multitasking, concentration, etc. The theory put forward is that, for instance, even a game such as the Splinter Cell games, require that you be aware of:

1.) Your in-game surroundings
2.) Sound, Video, etc.
3.) Your inventory, and an "internal map" to navigate.
4.) Raw reaction speed.

It's no wonder in my mind that this is the case, but the study in question was about increasing INTELLIGENCE. I can't think of any study which has shown an activity or regime which increases one's overall intelligence. You can become more facile with what you have, and keep the wheels greased, so to speak... but making you SMARTER? Naaah.
 
  • #7
Here's a http://www.nature.com/news/2010/100420/full/4641111a.html".

I think I agree with some of the reservations here. You have to be careful about what exactly you're claiming, e.g.:
- That 'brain games' make your brain apt at other tasks or improve your overall intelligence
- That they do this more effectively than other mental tasks.
- That they are better than being more passive mentally, or idle.
Etc..

I'm no neurologist but as lisab said; you'd think that something would always be better than nothing.

One thing I kind of wonder about is variation, though. A seasoned Sudoko player (or player of many types of games) is more or less following the same patterns of thought the whole time (or algorithm if you will). I wonder how that constrasts against activities that force you to constantly think in new ways (i.e. learning)?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #8
alxm said:
Here's a http://www.nature.com/news/2010/100420/full/4641111a.html".

I think I agree with some of the reservations here. You have to be careful about what exactly you're claiming, e.g.:
- That 'brain games' make your brain apt at other tasks or improve your overall intelligence
- That they do this more effectively than other mental tasks.
- That they are better than being more passive mentally, or idle.
Etc..

I'm no neurologist but as lisab said; you'd think that something would always be better than nothing.

One thing I kind of wonder about is variation, though. A seasoned Sudoko player (or player of many types of games) is more or less following the same patterns of thought the whole time (or algorithm if you will). I wonder how that constrasts against activities that force you to constantly think in new ways (i.e. learning)?

Hmmmm, maybe contrast with crossword puzzles... you might get used to clues, but it's always a novel exercise and has been studied more than Sudoku.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #9
A variation of brain games couldn't hurt. Mahjongg, word search, solitaire, & knitting-that's my variety :)
 
  • #10
Kerrie said:
A variation of brain games couldn't hurt. Mahjongg, word search, solitaire, & knitting-that's my variety :)

I love scrabble, I would think that is also a good mind game.
 
  • #11
Greg Bernhardt said:
I love scrabble, I would think that is also a good mind game.

As with crossword puzzles, there are a number of studies which show benefits in overall cognition (not overall, but day to day intelligence basically) from Scrabble, and similar games. Any game that makes you associate immidiate stimuli with thoughtful recall of memory, and then synthesis to make it work, seems to confer a similar benefit.

The study I mentioned about video games showed that even "non-gamers" improved ~15% on the tests given after a series of brief gaming sessions. "Gamers" seemed to score ~33% (this is from semi-dim memory, hence the prox) on those same tests. Now, one might argue those tests don't actually measure a real improvement, but it seems to be a logical extension of gaming overall.

There is also one other element: FUN. :smile: Who knows how much of this is just the result of us being deeply engaged in a mentally taxing AND fun activity? We're animals with a long history of needing to play games, to learn, and to reinforce lessons. I'm not surprised that play needs to be a constant part of our lives.

EDIT: Here are a couple of studies/letters/articles which are not hyping anything, but exploring aspects of HOW games modify attention, improve some elements of cognition, etc:

Also, the recent study checked IQ, and other Intelligence tests... and I don't think reasonable people believe that overall intelligence as measured is likely to improve OR decline in the absence of disease or some radical new drug. Improving memory, vocuabulary, recall... these were not measured.

http://www.bcs.rochester.edu/people/Daphne/GreenandBavelier.pdf [Broken]

http://www.springerlink.com/content/j7526154022g3532/
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #12
I've always wondered about chess, and even more complex strategy games.
 
  • #13
Pythagorean said:
I've always wondered about chess, and even more complex strategy games.

Chess, Go, Othello, etc... seem to be a better reflection of intelligence, and may improve attentional/executive (frontal/prefrontal lobe) function. Those are games about planning and anticipation, math, and empathy (what will your opponent do?). It doesn't seem to engage the brain as widely as crosswords, which require that you recall many disparate elements, interpret clues, and anticipate the overall structure of the puzzle as you fill it out.
 
  • #14
Greg Bernhardt said:
I love scrabble, I would think that is also a good mind game.

You posted something about a month ago regarding the number of people playing "games" on the internet. I thought it was funny, because you're an associate farmviller.

About 3 weeks ago, I decided that it would be really fun if you could create at PF version: A world where you can have all the tools at your disposal to create flying vehicles, design eco-smart homes, fabricate land vehicles that allow you get back and forth to work more efficiently...

But that's just me.
 
  • #15
Pythagorean said:
I've always wondered about chess, and even more complex strategy games.

I've played quite a lot of chess in my lifetime. The longest game was 7 hours. Chess is not only watching the board but also the other player. Face to face, eye to eye, sharing a bottle or two of wine is nice. Woman and man silent with a small grin or nod here and there along with some stare downs. You hear the breathing and notice the slightest body movements. It’s intense, yet relaxing. It's a slow dance of sorts with a high level of mental stimuli that keeps you focused. The last gentleman I played with was a champion, but I won. It was a fair game. No crying "wolf":smile: The main thing is you learn not to be in such a rush and to observe, the little important details prior to making your final move. There seems to be levels of thinking. Different states of mind that can be activated easier over time.

P.s.I'm eating a fresh made peanut butter cookie. The texture and taste is especially good right now as I examine it. Oh, let's not forget Hubble Space Telescope 20th Anniversary is today! Nature is celebrating good stuff on their website. Yummy. Image the brain power that went into this project:
http://www.nature.com/news/specials/hubble/index.html
 
Last edited:
  • #16
ViewsofMars said:
I've played quite a lot of chess in my lifetime. The longest game was 7 hours. Chess is not only watching the board but also the other player. Face to face, eye to eye, sharing a bottle or two of wine is nice. Woman and man silent with a small grin or nod here and there along with some stare downs. You hear the breathing and notice the slightest body movements. It’s intense, yet relaxing. It's a slow dance of sorts with a high level of mental stimuli that keeps you focused. The last gentleman I played with was a champion, but I won. It was a fair game. No crying "wolf":smile: The main thing is you learn not to be in such a rush and to observe, the little important details prior to making your final move. There seems to be levels of thinking. Different states of mind that can be activated easier over time.

P.s.I'm eating a fresh made peanut butter cookie. The texture and taste is especially good right now as I examine it. Oh, let's not forget Hubble Space Telescope 20th Anniversary is today! Nature is celebrating good stuff on their website. Yummy. Image the brain power that went into this project:
http://www.nature.com/news/specials/hubble/index.html

I think you just described the "empathy" portion of Chess as well as I've ever heard.
 
  • #17
Frame Dragger said:
The theory put forward is that, for instance, even a game such as the Splinter Cell games, require that you be aware of:

1.) Your in-game surroundings
2.) Sound, Video, etc.
3.) Your inventory, and an "internal map" to navigate.
4.) Raw reaction speed.

You'll get better at whatever skill the game requires you to have. For first person games like Quake, understanding 3D space was a major part of the game. You see some special item in an area that you can't get to and you try to figure out how to get to it. It might involve going up a floor, zig zagging around until you are over that location, then looking to see if there's a way down. Those old shooter games also had a lot of maps in them, so you'd get good at reading maps.

Probably one of the most interesting mathematical lessons learned from a game is when dealing with X + Y = 1. A good example of this is the dodge rate in world of warcraft. Either you get hit or you dodge, so (hit + dodge) = 1. This can be written as hit = (1 - dodge). If you take the derivative of this with respect to a dodge rate, you get:
d_hit/d_dodge = -1, so then
d_hit = (-1)d_dodge
Then put on this on a scale relative to where you started:
d_hit/hit = (-1)d_dodge / (1 - dodge)
or simplify it as:
relative change = -1dX / (1 - X)

This is a very common expression and you'll see it a lot in the future. When my class started dealing with the theory behind induction motors, I had a better understanding of the numbers because I had already seen those equations back when I played world of warcraft (a dev on the forum was explaining that they used "diminishing returns" to keep dX / [1 -X] constant). Recently I had to use this expression when talking about unemployment rates; see picture below:
http://img51.imageshack.us/img51/6111/employment.png [Broken]
 
Last edited by a moderator:

1. What are brain games?

Brain games are activities or exercises that are designed to stimulate and challenge the brain, often through puzzles, memory tasks, or strategy games.

2. Do brain games really work?

There is currently no scientific evidence to support the claim that brain games can boost overall brain power or intelligence. While brain games may help improve specific cognitive skills, such as memory or problem-solving, they do not have a significant impact on overall brain function.

3. Can playing brain games prevent cognitive decline?

There is no evidence that playing brain games can prevent or delay cognitive decline, which is a natural part of aging. Engaging in mentally stimulating activities, such as learning new skills or socializing, may have a more significant impact on brain health.

4. Are there any benefits to playing brain games?

While brain games may not boost brain power, they can still be a fun and engaging way to challenge your mind and improve specific cognitive skills. Additionally, participating in these activities may have a positive impact on mood and overall well-being.

5. What are some other ways to keep my brain healthy and sharp?

In addition to brain games, there are several other ways to maintain brain health and function. These include regular physical exercise, a healthy diet, getting enough sleep, managing stress, and engaging in mentally stimulating activities such as learning a new language or musical instrument.

Similar threads

Replies
26
Views
3K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
20
Views
10K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Computing and Technology
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
2
Views
4K
Back
Top