How can a hydraulic steering be replaces the modern power steering system

In summary, the conversation discussed the use of hydraulic steering systems in various vehicles. The original poster, a mechanical engineer, was interested in creating a pure hydraulic steering system for a project and asked for advice on modifications and potential issues with the system. Other contributors mentioned the history of power steering in cars, the use of hydraulic steering in tractors, and the potential drawbacks of a purely hydraulic system in a car. The conversation also discussed the safety features and regulations surrounding steering systems in vehicles.
  • #1
varun atri
11
0
Hi every one,
i am a mechanical engineer working on a project hydraulic steering :smile:. i want to know that in power steering systems it has been used. but the thing is as far i know that the modern power steering system uses a hydraulic cylinder in addition to the rack and pinion arrangement.o:)

i want to know that i am removing that pinion and rack system and want to make the steering system completely working on hydraulics o:) . could it be possible and what will be the modifications i have to make it to the system to make it working. Also does the load will affect the hydraulic system more as i have considered the frictional losses and many other power losses.

A +VE CRITISM IS ACCEPTED FROM THE EXPERTS OF THE FIELD AND ANY OTHER IDEAS AND MODIFICATION IS WELCOMED. :approve:

"ONLY ENGINEERS KNOWS HOW THINGS CAN BE CREATED AND DESTROYED"
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
May I ask why you're set on having a pure hydraulic steering system?
 
  • #3
varun atri said:
Hi every one,
i am a mechanical engineer working on a project hydraulic steering :smile:. i want to know that in power steering systems it has been used. but the thing is as far i know that the modern power steering system uses a hydraulic cylinder in addition to the rack and pinion arrangement.o:)

i want to know that i am removing that pinion and rack system and want to make the steering system completely working on hydraulics o:) . could it be possible and what will be the modifications i have to make it to the system to make it working. Also does the load will affect the hydraulic system more as i have considered the frictional losses and many other power losses.

A +VE CRITISM IS ACCEPTED FROM THE EXPERTS OF THE FIELD AND ANY OTHER IDEAS AND MODIFICATION IS WELCOMED. :approve:

"ONLY ENGINEERS KNOWS HOW THINGS CAN BE CREATED AND DESTROYED"

Hi,

a pure hydraulic steering system already exists since 70s. It is used on tractors.
Search on google hydrostatic steering system or hydroguide, you would find a lot of information
 
  • #4
A bit of history is in order. Automobile and truck steering was strictly mechanical for years. The hydraulic assisted power steering was an expensive Option. As more woman began driving in the 1950s and 60s ( originally the task was solely male dominated ( early 1900s) and more and more of the purchasing public began selecting the automatic transmission and air conditioning, the auto manufacturers began packaging the more popular car models with “ standard options” a true oxymoron. Certain features were sold at attractive prices to give the purchasing public incentive to buy the car off the lot and avoid custom manufacturing of each automobile. This reduced delivery time and even more importantly, decreased time of customer order to payment. Cheap credit and option to finance the car purchase were also refined by the automobile manufacturers.
Anyway, it is pretty common to buy a car with automatic transmission, power steering and air conditioning now.
Todays power steering is not pure hydraulic but a hybrid with electric power steering pump and slave cylinder rack and pinion.
Why electric..ease of installation during assembly..no long drive belts, pulleys, tensioners, to install, reduced warranty as you eliminate squeaky belts, parasitic drag on the power plant, It pretty much goes back to lowest cost to install AND Maintain over the warrant period.
 
  • #5
You wouldn't want to eliminate the rack and pinion completely because it serves as a back-up system in case of power (engine) failure.
 
  • #6
as usual Russ..most excellent point...as a safety feature all automoblies have steering ability even when engine is turned off..
 
  • #7
russ_watters said:
You wouldn't want to eliminate the rack and pinion completely because it serves as a back-up system in case of power (engine) failure.


that's wrong. On farm tractors it's used a pure hydrostatic system and in this case, the rotating valve is used as a pump. To reduce the steering wheel effort, it is used systems with two gerotor,i.e. valves: a big valve and a small ones.

here it is explained a bit.

http://www.pirate4x4.com/tech/billavista/PR-Hydro_Steering/index2.html
 
  • #8
A farm tractor is not a car. Farm tractors spend most of their lives going perfectly straight at 1mph (so no risk of a crash) and often (big ones) have wheels too large and buried in dirt to turn easily by hand.
 
  • #9
russ_watters said:
A farm tractor is not a car. Farm tractors spend most of their lives going perfectly straight at 1mph (so no risk of a crash) and often (big ones) have wheels too large and buried in dirt to turn easily by hand.

Unfortunately the tractor usage in completely changed in the last 20 years. Tractors with more than 100 kW are used for more than 50% of their life on road and they run 65km/h.
Anyway the EU regulation doesn't permit to install pure hydraulic steering systems on cars.
 
  • #10
I imagine it would be a terrible experience driving a car with purely hydraulic steering, as it would remove most of the feedback the driver gets and further disconnect him from the machine.
 
  • #11
Lsos said:
I imagine it would be a terrible experience driving a car with purely hydraulic steering, as it would remove most of the feedback the driver gets and further disconnect him from the machine.
The feeling while tractor driving is completely different than while car driving. In fact a high speed tractor has a mechnical steering with hydraulic assistance. As example there are hydrostatic steering system that you have to rotate the steering wheel after having run a curve because it doesn't allineate by itself.

If you are interested in, take a look at the following paper, it is well explained it.
http://elibrary.asabe.org/azdez.asp?JID=3&AID=36248&CID=t2011&v=54&i=1&T=1&redirType=
 
Last edited:
  • #12
Full hydraulic steering conversions are already available for 4x4's, take for example here here:

1002_4wd_03+1991_jeep_wrangler_yj+PSC_hydraulic_steering_system.jpg

http://www.pscmotorsports.com/motorsport-specific-products/offroad/full-hydraulic-steering

Hydraulic steering has the advantage of being very strong, which is a big plus on off-road vehicles with big tires driving on big rocks, but they have drawbacks too. They don't have any "on-center feel", little road feeback, are difficult or impossible to use without the engine running, require complex hydraulic setups including fluid coolers, etc etc.

As it is modern cars are going away from hydraulic altogether in favor of straight electric for power steering assist. A full hydraulic setup is a step backwards in terms of road manners rather than a step forward.
 

1. What is the difference between hydraulic steering and modern power steering?

Hydraulic steering uses pressurized fluid to assist in steering, while modern power steering uses an electric motor. This results in a more efficient and responsive steering system.

2. Why would someone want to replace their hydraulic steering with a modern power steering system?

Replacing hydraulic steering with modern power steering can provide a smoother and more precise steering experience. It can also improve fuel efficiency and reduce maintenance costs.

3. Can any car be converted from hydraulic steering to modern power steering?

In most cases, yes. However, it depends on the specific make and model of the car. It is best to consult a professional mechanic to determine if your car is compatible for the conversion.

4. How much does it cost to replace hydraulic steering with modern power steering?

The cost can vary depending on the car and the specific components needed for the conversion. On average, it can range from $500 to $1500. It is important to get quotes from different mechanics to find the best price.

5. Is it worth it to replace hydraulic steering with modern power steering?

It depends on your personal preference and the condition of your current steering system. If you are looking for a more efficient and responsive steering experience, then it may be worth the investment. However, if your hydraulic steering is working well, it may not be necessary to replace it.

Similar threads

  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
19
Views
669
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
15
Views
2K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
2
Views
907
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • Engineering and Comp Sci Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
35
Views
5K
Back
Top