Astronaut Chris Hadfield interview

In summary: I think he is describing the effect that a bright object has on someone's view of the night sky, in which case it would make sense that it would take a few seconds for the stars to become visible again. However, he does not mention anything about not being able to see stars from Earth, which suggests that this could be due to a variety of reasons.
  • #1
Solon
32
0
I was reading an interview on NPR with Cris Hadfield, recently retired Canadian astronaut, who has performed EVAs from both a shuttle and from the ISS. His words seem quite unequivocal, that space is an endless blackness in all directions. Am I to take his words at face value?

The contrast of your body and your mind inside ... essentially a one-person spaceship, which is your spacesuit, where you're holding on for dear life to the shuttle or the station with one hand, and you are inexplicably in between what is just a pouring glory of the world roaring by, silently next to you — just the kaleidoscope of it, it takes up your whole mind. It's like the most beautiful thing you've ever seen just screaming at you on the right side, and when you look left, it's the whole bottomless black of the universe and it goes in all directions. It's like a huge yawning endlessness on your left side and you're in between those two things and trying to rationalize it to yourself and trying to get some work done.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
He doesn't say blackness in all directions. What he says is that when you have a very bright object on your right, the sky on the left looks extra black.
 
  • #4
He doesn't say blackness in all directions.

He doesn't?

"it's the whole bottomless black of the universe and it goes in all directions"

What he says is that when you have a very bright object on your right, the sky on the left looks extra black

I think you are putting words in his mouth that don't belong. Astronauts have probably the best vision of anyone, yet from my own experiments, it takes less than 5 seconds after blinding myself with a flashlight for the stars to be visible again, and I'm in an area of poor star visibility due to prevailing marine air conditions, and even without my glasses on. For a person person with normal eyesight, the pupillary light reflex speed is initially pretty fast, both for constriction and dilation, so long dark adaptation time is only required to see REALLY dim objects. I think Mr Hadfield would have mentioned if he had any circumstances that prevented him seeing the satrs, a dark visor, sun in his eyes, dark adaptation time.
He also wonders about "our planet and how it reacts with the energy from the sun and how our magnetic field works and how the upper atmosphere works", so he has given this some serious consideration. If he can not see stars within a few seconds while looking away from a bright Earth, and does not state that this was due to a specific reason, then I am puzzled, and would really like him to clarify his statement. If the stars are not easily visible from orbit, but are from Earth, then there is something very much amiss with our models of how light works, which has some very serious implications indeed.
 
  • #5
Solon said:
He doesn't?
He doesn't.

"it's the whole bottomless black of the universe and it goes in all directions"
You intentionally left out a key part of that quote. He said "when you look left, it's the whole bottomless black of the universe and it goes in all directions."

What's to the right? The Earth. It fills almost half the sky at the altitude of the ISS.

I think you are putting words in his mouth that don't belong. Astronauts have probably the best vision of anyone, yet from my own experiments, it takes less than 5 seconds after blinding myself with a flashlight for the stars to be visible again, and I'm in an area of poor star visibility due to prevailing marine air conditions, and even without my glasses on. For a person person with normal eyesight, the pupillary light reflex speed is initially pretty fast, both for constriction and dilation, so long dark adaptation time is only required to see REALLY dim objects. I think Mr Hadfield would have mentioned if he had any circumstances that prevented him seeing the satrs, a dark visor, sun in his eyes, dark adaptation time.
He also wonders about "our planet and how it reacts with the energy from the sun and how our magnetic field works and how the upper atmosphere works", so he has given this some serious consideration. If he can not see stars within a few seconds while looking away from a bright Earth, and does not state that this was due to a specific reason, then I am puzzled, and would really like him to clarify his statement. If the stars are not easily visible from orbit, but are from Earth, then there is something very much amiss with our models of how light works, which has some very serious implications indeed.
You are the one putting words in his mouth and you are speculating about those words you put in his mouth. Stop that.

The astronauts see the stars from the ISS.
 

1. How did Chris Hadfield become an astronaut?

Chris Hadfield became an astronaut after being selected by the Canadian Space Agency as one of four astronauts from a pool of 5330 applicants in 1992. He then went through extensive training and completed multiple missions to become a seasoned astronaut.

2. What was Chris Hadfield's most memorable moment in space?

According to Chris Hadfield himself, his most memorable moment in space was when he performed a spacewalk and looked below to see the entire Earth beneath him. He describes it as a moment of pure awe and wonder.

3. How did Chris Hadfield prepare for his time in space?

Chris Hadfield underwent rigorous physical and psychological training as well as extensive simulations to prepare for his time in space. He also studied Russian and learned how to operate the Soyuz spacecraft, which was the vehicle that took him to and from the International Space Station.

4. How did Chris Hadfield maintain his physical and mental health in space?

To maintain his physical health, Chris Hadfield followed a strict exercise regimen and had a specially designed diet plan. To maintain his mental health, he utilized techniques such as mindfulness and meditation, as well as staying in close contact with his family and friends on Earth.

5. What advice does Chris Hadfield have for aspiring astronauts?

Chris Hadfield's advice for aspiring astronauts is to find something that they are passionate about and excel at it, whether it be science, engineering, or any other field. He also emphasizes the importance of being persistent and never giving up on your dreams, even if it takes a long time to achieve them.

Similar threads

  • Sci-Fi Writing and World Building
Replies
23
Views
8K
  • Sci-Fi Writing and World Building
Replies
15
Views
3K
  • General Discussion
Replies
4
Views
7K
  • General Discussion
Replies
1
Views
8K
  • MATLAB, Maple, Mathematica, LaTeX
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
5K
Back
Top