Fish in Aquarium: Environmental Awareness and Perception

  • Thread starter Rothiemurchus
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Aquarium
In summary: As Dave points out, fish do have a memory. You can train them if you really want to, and they certainly do learn where to look for the food at feeding time. As for if they care about the aesthetics of their surroundings... I don't think we know that. Maybe research should be done in animals to see if they have a sense of "beauty." ... scan their brains in different-looking environments and see if they feel more pleasure around certain colors or shapes (if they find them beautiful).I think this is an example of people believing what they want to believe to salve their consciences. It's okay to confine a fish to a bowl if it has no awareness that
  • #1
Rothiemurchus
203
1
Do fish care about what the environment outside the tank they are in looks and sounds like? Do they know they are in a tank?
 
Biology news on Phys.org
  • #2
Feel free to correct this anyone:
I have read that a goldfish's memory is such that when it swims completely around the bowl back to the starting point, it cannot remember ever having been there before. If this is so, then I would think they are unaware that they are in a tank.

I don't know if they care about the external environment.
 
  • #3
Fish do have a long term memory of sorts and can remember things if the same thing occurs repeatedly but as Type 7 says i doubt they care what their view is like
 
  • #4
ukmicky said:
Fish do have a long term memory of sorts and can remember things if the same thing occurs repeatedly but as Type 7 says i doubt they care what their view is like

I'm glad you said 'occurs repeatedly' because I remember when I was a child I lived near a lake and an old man (probably old as I am now) used to feed the fish from his dock every day at the same time. The fish would gather together in the same spot at the correct time each day. Maybe that's memory.
 
  • #5
The short term memory thing is a myth. While gold fish don't have as good a memory as, say, a dog, they are not are not in a state of "dementia" either. An animal that can't remember ANYTHING is a dead animal.

Fish can be taught patterns (like where food is placed) and remember them for days. They have even been reported to be able to recognize their owner.As for if they care about the aesthetics of their surroundings... I don't think we know that. Maybe research should be done in animals to see if they have a sense of "beauty." ... scan their brains in different-looking environments and see if they feel more pleasure around certain colors or shapes (if they find them beautiful).

That should be interesting research.
 
Last edited:
  • #6
I've never understood why anyone gives the slightest thought to trhis silly myth that fish have no memory. Is there anyone of us who hasn't seen fish all congregate looking for food when someone approaches the tank? Of COURSE they have a memory!



As far as the tank's outside goes, fish that are not happy will be stressed by lots of movement too near the tank.
 
  • #7
You can tell they know what the outside environment is if you watch how they react to what's outside the tank. If there is a sudden movement near the outside, they will all swim away from it. If you have a male betta, and put a mirror outside the tank, it will try to fight with itself (not recommended to try it and stress the fish).

As Dave points out, yes, fish also have memories. You can train them if you really want to, and they certainly do learn where to look for the food at feeding time.

Do they know they are in a tank? Well, they probably do know that they bump their nose into a solid wall every time they try to swim past a certain point. I don't know if that matters in any way to them, or if they just turn around and go another way.

With any captive or domestic animal, the more you enrich their environment with things that make it more like their natural environment, or more interesting, the healthier and less stressed they are. A goldfish swimming around a barren bowl is probably pretty stressed. If you instead give it places to hide and swim through, and plants, companions, etc., then it can express more of its normal behaviors and be less stressed.
 
  • #8
I think this is an example of people believing what they want to believe to salve their consciences. It's okay to confine a fish to a bowl if it has no awareness that it is so confined. Here's another one I've heard: It's okay to hook fish because they do not feel pain. And as for mammals, it's okay to do whatever the hell we want to them, because they have no emotional sensitivity.

As for awareness of the evironment outside the tank, now you have me thinking in terms of prey instincts. Fish near the edge of a lake will scatter at your approach or if any shadow falls over them. Aquarium fish should have the same instinct, although some either have it to a lesser degree or have become inured to sudden movement nearby (koi seem awfully calm). Fish in a lake will stay in an area that has tree branches overhead. This protects them from hawks, etc. and maybe the shady area is cooler. But I've seen them spread out more when a rain cloud obscures the sun. I'm thinking that their awareness might be limited to a perception of light (and shade) and to movement. I'm just speculating.
 
  • #9
I've heard that fish are sensitive to gravity and don't know which way up to swim in zero gravity environment.I wonder if fish like oxygen bubbles just for breathing - perhaps they like being massaged by the moving bubbles!
What is the ideal fish size to tank size ratio - do fish get stressed out and "lonely" in tanks that are too big?
 
Last edited:
  • #10
For an experiment to disprove the goldfish memory myth

http://dsc.discovery.com/fansites/mythbusters/episode/episode_09.html (episode 11)

You can watch the episode online to examine their method

http://www.tv-links.co.uk/link.do/1/61/133/1866/3215 [Broken]
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #11
Erm I'm not quite sure how to answer the *original* question, I'm not going to make up anything that sounds scientific because I really don't know ...
but to answer Rothiemurchus' question "What is the ideal fish size to tank size ratio - do fish get stressed out and "lonely" in tanks that are too big?" , then I can say ...
the bigger the tank the better. For more than one reason.
First of all - I'm not quite sure why , but in a bigger tank, fish are less likely to catch diseases and consequently, die.
If I were a fish, alone in a tank i'd feel just as lonely in a small tank or a big one. Just in a big one I'd have more territory. To stop fish being lonely I guess the best thing is have more than one together . But, be careful when choosing , as some types of fish "don't get on well with others" and might start attacking some ; I've read about it and seen it happen, unfortunately ...
I hope my answer was helpful to you. Sorry I can't work out the answer for if fish care about their environment...
 
  • #12
hi
This year I did my year 10 science project on fish and their memory. I can definitely tell you that fish have a working memory and they can go 3 months without triggering their memory and remember certain sounds and signs. [ I did this by playing classical music and heavy metal music in their tank and then feeding them at different parts of the tank, it took my angel fish 5 "lessons" to figure out the music and it took my gold fish 14 "lessons" to figure out the music. So gold fish arent completely simple but there just no too smart.

To answer the question on what is a safe fishtank size to keep a certain amount of fish in:
you must find the length of the tank. Using the measurement of the tanks length then find the approxiamate length of all the fish in your tank, if the length of all the fish exceeds the length of the tank then there could be problems with over crowding, but if you give the fish proper places to hide and proper vegetation then they should be fine if there are a few more centiemtres of fish then tank.

Also to answer the actual question if the fish care about their environment out side the tank, i believe that they do. The fish seem to be timid when there is lots of movement out side the tank and they seem to get stressed by lots of loud sounds.
 
Last edited:
  • #13
I don't know if this applies to other than carp (including goldfish), but they will cease growing when they reach the size that is suitable for the tank. Can't say as I've ever heard of one shrinking to fit a tank that's already too small, though.
Neat information about measuring them, Tommy. I never heard of that before.
 
  • #14
I've never heard of length being used. The usual method is one inch of fish per gallon.
 
  • #15
Danger said:
I don't know if this applies to other than carp (including goldfish), but they will cease growing when they reach the size that is suitable for the tank. Can't say as I've ever heard of one shrinking to fit a tank that's already too small, though.
Neat information about measuring them, Tommy. I never heard of that before.

That's interesting. Ceteceans (whales) evolved from 15 foot long dog-like mammals. The length of their body was so great that they continually sought out food in swamps and shallow water to support its weight and awkwardness. Continually dunking their heads in water over a few million years (from 25 million years ago) slowly saw natural selection select the animals with nostrils that were higher up the skull than the others. Slowly, (again) the mammal ended up in open water, swimming more and rarely making land fall.

At some point (maybe a few million years of this) they detached as land mammals and the nostrils ended up on the top of the head (through natural selection)... eventually, as a fully fledged marine mammal the early whales began to grow to enormous sizes simply because there were no restrictions... (water displacement, gravity etc...) in their environment. Then we get examples like the Blue Whale (redonculously humungous). (Very distant relation to the Blue Heeler breed of dog:rolleyes:)
 
  • #16
baywax said:
The length of their body was so great that they continually sought out food in swamps and shallow water to support its weight and awkwardness.
Which makes one wonder why there were much, MUCH larger animals roaming about that didn't have this happen.

If 'bodies of a certain size need water to support them' is a strong evolutionary driver, then how did apatosaurs, seismosaurs and their ilk manage just fine?
 
  • #17
DaveC426913 said:
Which makes one wonder why there were much, MUCH larger animals roaming about that didn't have this happen.

If 'bodies of a certain size need water to support them' is a strong evolutionary driver, then how did apatosaurs, seismosaurs and their ilk manage just fine?

A monstrously large tail was selected as an offset to their enormous structure... ?... just a guess. This was accompanied by a ganglion bundle of nerves in the CNS near the "lower" spinal area that acted as a controller for the tail. Much like a train with a long payload has secondary engines.

The apatos and others had a long time to evolve in any direction to suit their size. I wouldn't be surprised if the mososaurs and elasmosaurs were perhaps evolved from land based dinosaurids.

After 40 million years of mammalian evolution... perhaps this was how it turned out. The long almost 400 million years of dinosaurid evolution had its mechanisms of selection and then there was a (reportedly) 99% extinction rate that included plants etc as well (bolide interuptus) From there we had 40 million years of evolution before the dog-like cetecean arose. Each case of natural selection has its own distinct fingerprint and logic, if you can call it that... is my guess.
 
Last edited:

1. What are the potential environmental impacts of keeping fish in an aquarium?

Keeping fish in an aquarium can have both positive and negative environmental impacts. On the positive side, aquariums can provide a safe and controlled environment for fish to thrive in. However, some potential negative impacts include the use of energy and resources to maintain the aquarium, the potential release of harmful chemicals into the environment if not properly maintained, and the potential for fish to be taken from the wild and sold for the aquarium trade.

2. How can aquarium owners promote environmental awareness and sustainability?

Aquarium owners can promote environmental awareness and sustainability by using eco-friendly and sustainable practices in maintaining their aquarium. This includes using energy-efficient equipment, using natural or organic materials in the tank, properly disposing of waste and chemicals, and supporting conservation efforts and sustainable fish breeding practices.

3. What are some common misconceptions about keeping fish in an aquarium?

One common misconception is that fish do not require much care or attention. In reality, fish require a proper and consistent environment, regular maintenance, and a balanced diet to thrive. Another misconception is that all fish are suitable for aquariums, when in fact some species may require specific conditions or may be harmful to other fish in the tank.

4. How can aquariums contribute to conservation efforts?

Aquariums can contribute to conservation efforts by raising awareness about endangered fish species and their natural habitats, supporting conservation organizations and initiatives, and participating in breeding programs to help replenish and preserve fish populations.

5. What are some ways to make an aquarium more environmentally friendly?

To make an aquarium more environmentally friendly, owners can use a natural filtration system, such as live plants or a refugium, to reduce the need for chemical filtration. They can also use energy-efficient equipment, such as LED lights, and reduce the use of plastic and disposable products in the tank. Additionally, selecting fish species that are suitable for a smaller tank and avoiding overstocking can help reduce the environmental impact of an aquarium.

Similar threads

  • Materials and Chemical Engineering
Replies
7
Views
4K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
992
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
5
Views
8K
Back
Top