Safety regulations for motorcycle frames

In summary, the conversation discusses the possibility of using Autodesk Inventor for a motorcycle frame project and the search for government regulations or engineering specifications for building such frames. The conversation also touches upon the use of AutoCAD for designing systems and the potential dangers of poorly-designed bikes. Helpful resources for designing motorcycle frames are shared.
  • #1
jamesson
59
3
Howdy folks

Pardon any implicit or explicit stupidity in advance.

I'm an EE major taking a class in Autodesk Inventor, and I'm probably going to do a motorcycle frame for a midterm project. While it will not be required, I'm curious to see if I can make something roadworthy. Does any government body and/or engineering association publish specifications for this particular thing? I found something by NHTSA about _imported_ motorcycles, but nothing yet about manufacture.

Thanks much in advance

<< Personal information deleted by Moderators >>

PS - what is the general take on Inventor? I have to say, after hating Autocad with the burning passion of a thousand suns I find it to be a very welcome alternative. I only wish it did thermodynamic simulations, but I guess that's what multiphysics is for.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
You should start Googling right now on motorcycle frames. Custom-builders like Jesse James can start from the ground up, but often buy pre-built motors and power-trains. There might be stricter regulations where you live, so don't generalize. Good luck, and have fun.
 
  • #3
Well, that's how I found the nhtsa stuff. But nothing looked useful yet.

Gonna repost this in auto engineering, seems like a better fit.
 
  • #4
Good luck! Remember to check engineering threads about rake/neck-angle, too. Some scary things can happen when you try to drive a bike that has been built to "look good"
 
  • #5
Wow - wikipedia has a practical use - shocking!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicycle_and_motorcycle_geometry
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicycle_and_motorcycle_dynamics
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motorcycle_fork

Additionally

http://www.motorcycle.com/how-to/chassis-alignment-basics-3444.html
http://www.knucklebusterinc.com/tech/FrameFabrication.pdf
http://www.eng-tips.com/viewthread.cfm?qid=62470

Thanks for the rake angle tip - a big help! Still, would be nice to have something a bit more official. Surely enough rich lawyers buy bikes at this point that somebody may have demanded a formal spec by now?
 
  • #6
You're welcome. A lot of backyard "customizers" have built tank-slappers that would kill all but the most experienced riders.
 
  • #7
jamesson said:
PS - what is the general take on Inventor? I have to say, after hating Autocad with the burning passion of a thousand suns I find it to be a very welcome alternative.

As much as I used to say I hate it. AutoCAD is amazing. It just requires a different thought pattern to parametric modelling.

The reason why you think it's no good is because you've never done a proper design scheme of a system yet. One day you'll be forced to use AutoCAD for 2d scheming, and you'll get what I mean.I have a pdf copy book somewhere on motorcycle dynamics.
I'll have a look.

You don't have to read it all, but it'll be a good reference.You'll never find a 'spec' for a bike, just like you won't have a spec for a custom built road car chassis.
There will be minimum external regulations to meet, ie basic road worthiness. But that's the fun of design, there isn't a step by step manual.
 
Last edited:
  • #8
Googling "tank-slapper" yields... even more amazingly useful stuff! Thanks Turbo, you now have a new fan!
 
  • #9
jamesson said:
Surely enough rich lawyers buy bikes at this point that somebody may have demanded a formal spec by now?

In the UK the the legal requirements are the "Road Vehicles (Construction and Use) regulations". Curiously there is a separate "construction and use" law for pedal cycles in the UK, but apparently no document specific to motorcycles. Try searching for laws related to road traffic in your country.

However that may not help you much, because it will tell you what the regulations are and what test or inspection procedures are need to demonstrate compliance, but it won't tell you how to design something that meets the requirements. Actually that's how it should be - for example you demonstrate that a car design is crashworthy by doing a crash test, not be being forced to follow some prescribed design procedure which means you can't be innovative.
 
  • #10
jamesson said:
Googling "tank-slapper" yields... even more amazingly useful stuff! Thanks Turbo, you now have a new fan!
Thanks, again! I don't need a fan, but I'd love to save someone from a crash on a poorly-designed bike that only looks nice.
 
  • #11
Chris - just curious, what do you mean by system exactly?
 
  • #12
jamesson said:
Chris - just curious, what do you mean by system exactly?

A collection of parts and assemblies, to achieve a specific goal.
For example, a gearbox.

There whole concept will be done in 2D first, a basic outline of all components, shaft centres, ideas etc. It's just so much easier to scheme in a drafting package like AutoCAD.So for example with chassis design, I wouldn't start it Inventor. I'd scheme in AutoCAD first.
The idea of a chassis, is to just keep the cars components in the correct locations.

So you can plot the pickup points on your suspension (for example) in AutoCAD. Then you can draw lines representing the chassis members. this will give you an idea of how long each member is before you ever start modelling.
 
  • #13
Chris - how about this?

http://wikihelp.autodesk.com/Inventor/enu/2012/Help/0073-Autodesk73/0308-Parts308/0309-2D_sketc309/0320-Sketch_b320#GUID-C247DE64-FD88-435A-BA65-6A134B0EA511
 
  • #14
AutoCAD is still much, much better for a full system.

I've moaned about AutoCAD on here, but it's only now that I don't have it at work any more. I know how much I miss having that tool
 

1. What are the primary safety regulations for motorcycle frames?

The primary safety regulations for motorcycle frames vary by country and jurisdiction, but generally include requirements for frame strength, durability, and design. These regulations also often specify maximum load and weight limits for the frame, as well as standards for impact resistance and crashworthiness.

2. How are motorcycle frames tested for safety compliance?

Motorcycle frames are typically tested through a combination of computer simulations and physical crash tests. This allows engineers to evaluate the frame's performance under various conditions and identify any potential weaknesses or areas for improvement.

3. Are there any specific safety regulations for different types of motorcycle frames?

Yes, there are often specific regulations for different types of motorcycle frames, such as for sport bikes, touring bikes, or off-road bikes. These regulations may include different requirements for frame geometry, materials, and construction methods to ensure the frame is suitable for its intended use.

4. How do safety regulations for motorcycle frames differ from those for other vehicles?

While there may be some overlap in safety regulations for different types of vehicles, motorcycle frames are subject to their own specific regulations due to their unique design and function. For example, motorcycles have a higher center of gravity and are more susceptible to crashes and impacts, so their frames must be designed to withstand these forces.

5. Are there any safety regulations that are specific to electric motorcycle frames?

Currently, there are no specific safety regulations for electric motorcycle frames. However, as the use of electric motorcycles becomes more widespread, it is likely that there will be regulations put in place to address the unique safety considerations for these vehicles.

Similar threads

Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • Feedback and Announcements
Replies
21
Views
2K
  • General Discussion
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
13
Views
2K
Back
Top