Angular Velocity: spinning in chair, dropping weights with arms out

In summary: But if the car suddenly makes a sharp turn and comes back towards me, it will have more angular momentum than when it was just going straight. The car has taken some of its original angular momentum with it when it turned. Similarly, the weights take some of the angular momentum with them when they are dropped. However, the angular momentum of the system is still conserved.
  • #1
gauss44
49
0
Would someone be willing to explain this? Here: https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=487058

I read the entire thread and don't understand. I need one person to explain it step by step all in one place. In my case it's not a homework question. Please don't use the Socratic method! Just explain in plain English. Thank you!

(As an aside, I've never been able to learn from the Socratic method. It confuses me. With the Socratic method, I always remember the incorrect theories and never the correct ones. This question is a real doozy: http://forums.studentdoctor.net/threads/moment-of-inertia-problem.809233/ http://forums.studentdoctor.net/threads/tbr-physics-ch-4-passage-vii-45.975274/)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
It might help for you to explain what specific part of the the thread or statement within is bothering you.
Otherwise it could become an exercise of futility, discussing that which you already do understand, and then not discussing that which you do not. That would not be much help to you.

The other two links, by the way, seem to be an execise in how to promote confusion.
 
  • #3
256bits said:
It might help for you to explain what specific part of the the thread or statement within is bothering you.
Otherwise it could become an exercise of futility, discussing that which you already do understand, and then not discussing that which you do not. That would not be much help to you.

The other two links, by the way, seem to be an execise in how to promote confusion.

I have the same question as the OP. I quote, "can someone explain to me why "moment of inertia would not change for the system when the student drops the weight" since Inertia is proportional to mass x r^2 wouldn't a decrease in mass after the weight drop decrease the moment of inertia?"
 
  • #4
gauss44 said:
I have the same question as the OP. I quote, "can someone explain to me why "moment of inertia would not change for the system when the student drops the weight" since Inertia is proportional to mass x r^2 wouldn't a decrease in mass after the weight drop decrease the moment of inertia?"

Angular momentum is conserved if you are considering a closed system with no external torques. If you have 5 kg weights first considered as being inside the system and then considered as being outside, it's obviously no longer a closed system. Angular momentum need not be conserved. Removing those weights obviously results in a decrease in angular momentum.

So don't analyze the non-closed system consisting of the student plus weights. Analyze the closed system consisting of the student alone. When the student opens his or her hands, releasing the weights, does this involve an external torque on the student? Nope. So the angular momentum of the student alone does not change as a result. When the student opens his or her hands does this involve a change in moment of inertia of the student alone? Nope. So the angular velocity of the student alone does not change either.
 
  • #5
gauss44 said:
I have the same question as the OP. I quote, "can someone explain to me why "moment of inertia would not change for the system when the student drops the weight" since Inertia is proportional to mass x r^2 wouldn't a decrease in mass after the weight drop decrease the moment of inertia?"

Yes, the moment of inertia changes. But the angular velocity doesn't. The weights take some angular momentum with them, so you can't assume that angular momentum is conserved.
 
  • #6
Read below.
 
Last edited:
  • #7
dauto said:
Yes, the moment of inertia changes. But the angular velocity doesn't. The weights take some angular momentum with them, so you can't assume that angular momentum is conserved.

How do the released weights take any of the angular momentum?? The instant they are dropped, they begin traveling tangentially to the axis of rotation (.I.e. zero angular velocity, all translational velocity). Considering this, the spinning guy with a now reduce moment of inertia must speed up since the angular momentum of the system has stayed constant but its now "concentrated" on just the guy, not the weights. Where am I going wrong??
 
  • #8
the weights do take some angular momentum with them. Yes, they are moving tangentially to the axis of rotation, but this is not zero angular velocity. For example, if a car goes past me in a straight line, it will have angular momentum with respect to me.
 

1. What is angular velocity?

Angular velocity is a measure of how quickly an object is rotating around a fixed axis. It is typically measured in units of radians per second or degrees per second.

2. How is angular velocity calculated?

Angular velocity is calculated by dividing the change in angular displacement by the change in time. It can also be calculated by multiplying the rotational speed (in revolutions per second) by 2π.

3. What are some real-world examples of angular velocity?

Some examples of angular velocity in everyday life include the rotation of the Earth around its axis, the spinning of a top, and the movement of a Ferris wheel. It is also important in sports such as figure skating, gymnastics, and ice hockey.

4. How does angular velocity affect objects in motion?

Angular velocity determines the rate at which an object rotates, which in turn affects its centripetal acceleration and angular momentum. It also plays a role in determining the gyroscopic stability of objects in motion.

5. How can angular velocity be changed?

Angular velocity can be changed by applying a torque, which is a force that causes rotational motion. This can be done by changing the mass, shape, or distribution of mass of an object, or by applying a force at a distance from the axis of rotation.

Similar threads

Replies
26
Views
11K
Replies
7
Views
6K
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
16
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
14K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
6K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • General Engineering
Replies
27
Views
8K
Back
Top