Pumping Water from a deep mine

  • Thread starter TFM
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Water
In summary, the best location for the pump to pump water out of a very deep mine is at the bottom of the well, as it will push the water up instead of having to pull it up. This is supported by the use of equations such as F=ma, P=F/A, and Boyles Law, which show that atmospheric pressure and the height of the water column limit the effectiveness of a suction pump. Therefore, it is important to consider the limitations of a suction pump and place it at the optimal location in order to effectively pump water out of a deep mine.
  • #1
TFM
1,026
0

Homework Statement



You are required to pump water out of a very deep mine. Where should you put the pump? Explain your answer fully.

Homework Equations



Not sure

The Attempt at a Solution



See a similar question I did regarding beer in a can, I explained, but I needed formulas apparently, and didn't get marks for my 'waffle' (which is strange because in A level, waffle = good)

So for this question, i feel that equations are neede, but I am not sure what equations will be useful. This question I feel is a fluid dynamics question. So I first thought of Benouilles Equation, but I don't think this is useful, since we don't know the speed the water is travelling.

I also feel I need to use F = mg somewhere, but this doesn't help me.

Could anyone recommend some equations or laws that might be useful?

TFM
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Maybe you should read this first:
http://www.popularmechanics.com/home_journal/how_your_house_works/1275136.html?page=3" [Broken]
While a jet pump can reliably handle a well several hundred feet deep, a more effective solution is to move the pump down into the well ...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #3
Okay, reading from that implies that the pump should be at the bottom of the well, thus pushing the water up, not having to pull it up.

Thanks for the link.

So now, how do I prove this? What formulas/Laws are useful?

TFM
 
  • #4
Is this a fluid dynamics question, since I have a book on formula and I have looked through the Fluid Dynamics Section several times and can't seem to find any related fomrula?

TFM
 
  • #5
You can show that the water will only be sucked to a certain height using the formula for pressure.

How does a suction pump work?

By the way this question doesn't ask for you to prove anything (unlike the beer can one), so I think concise and true 'waffle' should suffice, although equations and math arguments are always better (in general-less chance of ambiguity).
 
  • #6
Vuldoraq said:
How does a suction pump work?

It sucks :wink: (Sorry, couldn't help my self. :biggrin:)

Seriously, though.

The manual water pump draws water up from a well by creating a vacuum that water rushes into fill. In a sense, it acts to evacuate the well, although the high leakage rate of dirt prevents a high quality vacuum from being maintained for any length of time.
- Wikipedia

So basically, a pump creates a vacuum at the top, and the wtare is sucked up to fill the vacuum

The formula for pressure is:

[tex] P = \frac{F}{A} [/tex]


And Boyles KLaw:

pV = Constant, could be useful

(I am sure there is another pressure law with rho in it, but cannot currently find it.)

TFM
 
  • #7
True, but more importantly how does it suck up the water up? In space there is a perfect vacuum, but if you put a straw in a glass of water it wouldn't magically move up the straw (it would probably float off and freeze, but you see my point?).

So the pump creates a vacuum but something else pushes the water up the pipe. What is it?

You can get rho into your pressure expression by saying F=mg with m=?
 
Last edited:
  • #8
well F = ma

m = rho * Volume

also, a = g?

thus:

[tex] P = \frac{\rho v g}{A} [/tex]

would it be the decreas in pressure, because the water is in equilibrium at 1 atms, so if a pump reduces the pressure, the water will increase in volume to make up for it, as in Boyles Law:

pV = Constant

?

TFM
 
  • #9
TFM said:
well F = ma

m = rho * Volume

also, a = g?

thus:

[tex] P = \frac{\rho v g}{A} [/tex]

TFM

Exactly. You can take this further by saying [tex]V=A*L[/tex]
where V is he volume, A is the cross sectional area and L is the height of fluid.

TFM said:
would it be the decreas in pressure, because the water is in equilibrium at 1 atms, so if a pump reduces the pressure, the water will increase in volume to make up for it, as in Boyles Law:

pV = Constant

?

TFM

Yes, in other words atmospheric pressure is pushing the water up the pipe and will do so until the pressure at the bottom of the pipe is equal to atmospheric pressure.

Will the pump be able to continue sucking the water when this equilibrium is acheived? Why?
 
  • #10
okay so:

[tex] P = \frac{\rho A*l g}{A} [/tex]

this will cancel down to:

[tex] P = \rho l g [/tex]

Will the pump be able to continue sucking the water when this equilibrium is acheived? Why?

Well surely when equilibrium is achieved, the volume of vacuum will be 0, and this the water is at the top?

TFM
 
  • #11
TFM said:
okay so:

[tex] P = \frac{\rho A*l g}{A} [/tex]

this will cancel down to:

[tex] P = \rho l g [/tex]

Yup.

TFM said:
Well surely when equilibrium is achieved, the volume of vacuum will be 0, and this the water is at the top?

TFM

Sadly not. When equilibrium is achieved the water will be at a height at which the pressure at the bottom of the pipe equals atmospheric pressure. There may still be a vacuum above it, depending upon how long the pipe is.

What this means is you have an upper limit on the pressure at the bottom of the pipe and can thus find the maximum l in your equation.
 
  • #13
Okay so:

[tex] P = \rho l g [/tex]

P = 1 atm = 101 325

[tex] \frac{101325}{9.8 \rho} = l [/tex]

Density of water: 1000 kg/m^3

this gives l to be:

l= 10.34m

So how will this help with were to put the pump?

TFM
 
  • #14
Well it means that a suction pump can only raise the water to 10m. Since a suction pump is the only type of pump where it is entirley out of the water (except the pipe obviously) having such a type of pump further tan 10 m from the water would render it useless.

So you know where not to put the pump, which should help you choose where to put it.

The rest is down to arguments. You will have to have a pump somewhere that pushes rather than sucks the water. If this pump is under the water then it can exclusively push. If it's above the water then it will have to suck then push etc.
 
  • #15
So the above is useful for showing why surface based pumps are not useful.

If the pump is below the water, it won't have to suck at all, just push the water upwards.

TFM
 

1. How is water pumped from a deep mine?

Water is pumped from a deep mine using specialized pumps called submersible pumps. These pumps are designed to operate in high-pressure and high-temperature environments, making them suitable for deep mine conditions.

2. What is the purpose of pumping water from a deep mine?

The main purpose of pumping water from a deep mine is to prevent flooding and maintain safe working conditions for miners. It also helps to control the water levels in the mine and allows for efficient mining operations.

3. How deep can water be pumped from a mine?

The depth at which water can be pumped from a mine depends on the type and power of the pump being used. In general, submersible pumps can pump water from depths of up to 1000 meters.

4. What are the potential challenges of pumping water from a deep mine?

Some of the potential challenges of pumping water from a deep mine include high energy costs, pump maintenance and repair, and the risk of pump failure. The water may also contain minerals and other impurities that can cause damage to the pumps.

5. Are there any environmentally friendly ways to pump water from a deep mine?

Yes, there are environmentally friendly methods of pumping water from a deep mine such as using renewable energy sources like solar or wind power to operate the pumps. Additionally, recycling and treating the pumped water can help reduce the environmental impact of the pumping process.

Similar threads

  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
247
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
2
Replies
40
Views
2K
Replies
204
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
981
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
2
Replies
36
Views
654
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
1K
Back
Top