
#1
Sep1913, 10:07 PM

P: 22

I am interested in knowing if the inside radius of the inner most part of the electron cloud is a constant versus Z. For example is it always the Bohr radius, or does this inner radius change as a function of Z? What is the experimental evidence?




#2
Sep1913, 10:18 PM

Homework
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks ∞
PF Gold
P: 11,101

How are you defining/thinking of the radius?
By combining the concept of a "radius" and a "cloud" in the context of electrons, you appear to be mixing up two different models. All atoms have at least one s1 electron  the radial wavefunction for that state is continuous from 0 to infinity  where would you put the "minimum radius"? Here's how the radial wavefunctions vary with Z. You can google for the shapes. ...anyway, the atomic diameter is roughly the same order of magnitude regardless of Z, which means that the electrons get more tightly packed as Z increases. Which I suspect is what you are asking about. 



#3
Sep1913, 10:41 PM

P: 22

Thanks for your reply. I appreciate the information. Very useful.
I am asking about the radius at which the maximum of the radial probability of the electron occurs. I am not mixing up two different concepts. This is how the Bohr radius is defined nowas the radius of the maximum of radial probability of the s1 electron cloud, for a Hydrogen atom. I'm not interested in knowing the "minimum radius" of that s1 electron cloud. Rather, I am interested in the most likely radial position of that s1 electron, as a function of Z. From your information, I see that it varies, quite a bit. Thank you. 



#4
Sep2013, 06:43 AM

Homework
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks ∞
PF Gold
P: 11,101

Inside radius of atomic electron cloud vs Z
Cool  glad to be able to help.
I know, it can be vexing when people don't just "get" what you are asking, but I have to get a clearer picture if I am to avoid unwittingly sidetracking the thread. Thanks for your understanding on this. :) 



#5
Sep2013, 09:51 PM

P: 22

Thank you again for your help. Another question, though. In the link you gave me, both functions rR(r) and (rR(r))^2 are plotted, but with no explanation or definition.
So, I assumed that rR(r) was the radial probability, and I took the formula of rR(r) and differentiated it with respect to r. Then I set the resulting derivative equal to zero, and solved for r, which would be the r for the maximum of the function rR(r). This should give me what I wantthe maximum radial probability as a function of Z. What I got was rmax = a0/Z. (I'm assuming a0 is the Bohr radius of H1 atom, 5.29E11 meters.) If all this is right, then for U238, where Z=92, then this maximum radial probability of the s1 inner radius is: (5.29E11)/(92)=(2.62E13) meters. Which, of course, is a quite a bit smaller than the Bohr radius for the H1 atom. Does this make sense? Am I doing this right, or do I need to work with the function (rR(r))^2 instead? Thanks again for your help. 



#6
Sep2113, 02:30 AM

Homework
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks ∞
PF Gold
P: 11,101

##R_{nl}(r)## is the radial component of the singleelectron wavefunction.
The probability density function is the square modulus. i.e. The probability of finding an electron in state n,l> between r and r+dr is ##p(r)dr=R_{nl}(r)^2dr## so ##\int_0^\infty p(r)dr = 1## right? The mean radius is $$\langle r \rangle=\int_0^\infty R_{nl}^\star r R_{nl} dr$$ ... since ##R_{nl}## is real, that is where they get the ##rR_{nl}(r)^2## from. It's just the expectation value of r: E[r]. Similarly $$\langle r^2 \rangle=\int_0^\infty r^2 R_{nl}^2 dr$$ ... would be E[r^2]. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Atomic Hydrogen gas cloud to Star!!  Astrophysics  9  
Binding energy and orbital radius of the innermost electron vary with atomic ny  Introductory Physics Homework  0  
Electron Cloud  Quantum Physics  10  
Probability of finding electron inside bohr radius  Advanced Physics Homework  5  
Atomic Radius vs. Ionic Radius  Introductory Physics Homework  1 