Register to reply

Is it really possible to see down to mag 8?

by logic10
Tags: None
Share this thread:
logic10
#1
Apr25-14, 11:41 PM
P: 2
I saw this thread about Neptune's naked eye visiblity: http://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=362668 . I found this thread when I was searching for an answer to the very same question that is asked there.

In every source I've seen that actually details the Bortle Dark Sky scale it has been said that one can see down to Mag 8 under perfect conditions (I think I've seen some sources that have said 8.5, which makes this even more puzzling.) Neptune's magnitude is sometimes as bright as 7.78. Yet, every single source I've seen has said that Neptune is not naked-eye visible even under perfect conditions.

To be clear here, I do understand the basic issues relating to apparent magnitude and such. I am aware that Neptune is way farther from earth than the naked eye planets, and that that is the reason why it is so dim. But... it seems like according to the Bortle Dark Sky Scale it would be just barely within naked eye range under absolutely perfect conditions. Is this true? I've had trouble finding anything that actually addresses the issue, most of the sources that say you can go down to mag 8 do not address Neptune in particular, while most sources that talk about the naked eye planets just say "Neptune is too dim."

So... is it actually possible to see Neptune with the naked eye?
Phys.Org News Partner Astronomy news on Phys.org
The Great Debate over whether the universe is small or large
Smallest known galaxy with a supermassive black hole found
Mystery of rare five-hour space explosion explained
jedishrfu
#2
Apr26-14, 12:22 AM
P: 3,100
The wikipedia article says no in the Observation section owing its faintness at mag +7.7 to +8.0 and its angular diameter being the smallest of all the visible planets.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neptune

which cites this article:

http://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary...ptunefact.html
Bandersnatch
#3
Apr26-14, 01:17 AM
P: 741
I've always read that the limiting magnitude for the naked eye is 6-6.5, not 8. For example here: http://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0011310 (fig 6.) or here: http://www.astrometry.org/magnitude.php

There's always some variation between individuals, so perhaps that can account for rare cases of people being able to see down to mag 8, but for the majority of observers it should be too dim.

logic10
#4
Apr26-14, 10:37 AM
P: 2
Is it really possible to see down to mag 8?

I do know that its really, really hard to find a perfect dark sky site. Most places still get some light pollution, even if only just a tad. But, it seems like according to the Bortle Dark Sky Scale it is possible to see 8.0 under absolutely perfect conditions with good eyesight. I'm not sure what the angular diameter thing is though. That might be the answer to the question. Does angular diameter have anything to do with apparent magnitude?
jedishrfu
#5
Apr26-14, 11:28 AM
P: 3,100
Yes there is a relationship:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Absolut...laxies_.28M.29


Register to reply