Gravitational field from earth/ center of massby Excalibur1152 Tags: earth or, field, gravitational, mass 

#1
Feb2612, 11:20 AM

P: 11

When calculating the gravitational field from the earth, why can we make the assumption that all of the mass of the earth is 'averaged' at the the geometrical center???
If we imagine the earth as a bunch of pieces, and then calculate the sum of forces from each of these pieces, would it not be different from imagining the earth as a single piece at the center with all of its mass? What I mean is that a 'piece' of earth on the other side of the earth is pulling one me with a much much weaker force than a piece of earth that is right under my feet. The transition from the strength of the gravity from the earth that is close to me to the earth that is farther away is not linear, so why can we average the distances? 



#2
Feb2612, 11:51 AM

P: 1,262

The story is that Newton invented calculus to answer that very question.
He created the idea of the 'integral' to sum the forces of every piece of the earth to find the net effectand he found that the situation is identical to the entire mass of the earth collapse to a point at its center. The calculation is, in effect, 'averaging' in a nonlinear way (you take into account the inversesquare lawwhich is why the answer is what it is). But I think a better way to think about how it works is by symmetry. While the piece of earth directly below you pulls you more strongly, there are far more pieces of earth on the opposite side. And the amount more stuff on the other side, increases exactly so as to compensate for the inverse square decrease of the force. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
gravitational field intensity at the center of the earth  Introductory Physics Homework  3  
Gravitational Force at the Center of the Earth?  Classical Physics  23  
center of mass and center of gravity different in non uniform gravitation field?expl  General Physics  4  
Gravitational pull at the center of the Earth  General Physics  34  
the geometric center of the Earth and the center of mass  Classical Physics  9 