Thread Closed

"We are ready to attack Iran..."

 
Share Thread Thread Tools
May26-12, 01:09 PM   #120
 

"We are ready to attack Iran..."


Quote by ThomasT View Post
Thanks for getting back on topic. My current view is that Iran does want to develop nuclear weapons. Why wouldn't it?

But a nuclear armed Iran doesn't necessarily present any more of a threat to Israel than already exists, imo. Iran would be absolutely stupid to do a preemptive nuclear strike on Israel. It would be national suicide. So, I assume, they just won't do that. But the possession of nuclear weapons, and ability to deliver them long range, would give them a bargaining chip that they apparently don't now have. Why this is important, I don't know. How Iran would use it if it had it, I don't know. I don't understand exactly what's at stake, what the game is. If anybody does, then your input would be most appreciated.
I'm no Middle East expert but what worries me is that once they get them, if ever, there's no going back. If they get them, 20, 30, 40 years down the road some lunatic might get into power there and start launching, just as Saddam would have done had he had them. The internal power struggles in the Mid-East strike me as more extreme and there's much greater potential for an unstable person to take power. Or, suppose Iran had had them during the Iran/Iraq war. Might they have been tempted to take Baghdad out with a nuke at some point during that struggle when they were really hurting? I think there's an excellent chance Saddam would have nuked Teheran if he could have during that war. He was not a very reasonable person.
May26-12, 01:20 PM   #121
 
Quote by zoobyshoe View Post
I'm no Middle East expert but what worries me is that once they get them, if ever, there's no going back. If they get them, 20, 30, 40 years down the road some lunatic might get into power there and start launching ...
I don't think that's even remotely likely.

Quote by zoobyshoe View Post
... just as Saddam would have done had he had them.
I don't think he would have.

Quote by zoobyshoe View Post
The internal power struggles in the Mid-East strike me as more extreme and there's much greater potential for an unstable person to take power.
I don't think that's necessarily true. People who are granted power are generally people who are more emotionally stable than the average person, imo.

Quote by zoobyshoe View Post
Or, suppose Iran had had them during the Iran/Iraq war. Might they have been tempted to take Baghdad out with a nuke at some point during that struggle when they were really hurting?
Tempted maybe, but they wouldn't have done it, imho.

Quote by zoobyshoe View Post
I think there's an excellent chance Saddam would have nuked Teheran if he could have during that war. He was not a very reasonable person.
Saddam was both reasonable and emotionally strong. That's part of why he became the boss. Imho, he wouldn't have used nuclear weapons had he had them.
May26-12, 01:30 PM   #122
 
Quote by ThomasT View Post
Saddam was both reasonable and emotionally strong. That's part of why he became the boss. Imho, he wouldn't have used nuclear weapons had he had them.
I don't see how you figure he was reasonable. Strong, obviously, but reasonable?
May26-12, 01:35 PM   #123
 
Quote by zoobyshoe View Post
I don't see how you figure he was reasonable. Strong, obviously, but reasonable?
Well, thankfully, it's off-topic. So, we needn't consider it.
May26-12, 01:58 PM   #124
 
Quote by ThomasT View Post
Well, thankfully, it's off-topic. So, we needn't consider it.
You were just yankin' my chain.
May26-12, 02:03 PM   #125
 
Quote by zoobyshoe View Post
You were just yankin' my chain.
I do that sometimes, but not wrt the considerations presented in this thread. The questions associated with the OP are difficult. I have certain ideas, but can't say that I know the answers.
May26-12, 04:39 PM   #126
 
Recognitions:
Gold Membership Gold Member
Quote by ThomasT View Post
...

Saddam was both reasonable and emotionally strong...
Saddam was not insane as I understand the term. But reasonable? His reason for gassing a ~peaceful town of thousands? For attacking Iran? For genocide on the Marsh Arabs? For trying to kill a US president between the wars?

Edit: nevermind - see above posts from Zooby
May26-12, 06:59 PM   #127
 
Blog Entries: 27
Recognitions:
Gold Membership Gold Member
Homework Helper Homework Help
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Quote by ThomasT View Post
Judaism is a theistic religion. Jewishness is associated with that religion. It isn't a race.
jews aren't a race?

antisemitism (meaning hatred of jews) is universally recognised as a form of racism

(why are you denying this?? )
One might disagree with the establishment of the Jewish state of Israel … without being in any way a racist.
"in any way"?

that's very difficult … to call for the elimination of the only jewish state in the world and not to call for the elimination of any other state, is obviously antisemitic
Quote by Tosh5457 View Post
You're confounding race with nationality.
anti-israeli racists sometimes like to claim
"israelis aren't a race, so i can't be accused of anti-israeli racism, becaue it doesnt exist!"
And I'm not criticizing the population of Israel, I'm just criticizing their government actions and political ideology behind it (zionism).
but which israeli government?

you're being very disingenuous

if you mean you were criticising the present israeli government, then you did so on the basis of things done over 60 years ago

if you mean you were criticising every israeli government, both left-wing and right-wing, then you were criticising most of the population of israel
May26-12, 09:53 PM   #128
Evo
 
Mentor
Blog Entries: 4
This thread has continued a bit too long.
Thread Closed
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: "We are ready to attack Iran..."
Thread Forum Replies
In binary can we have a value with "deci" "centi" "mili" or more lower valued prefix? Computers 14
Animals which attack their "cousins" Social Sciences 16
"Little Paige not ready for daddy's departure to Iraq" General Discussion 4
Difference between "Identical", "Equal", "Equivalent" Calculus & Beyond Homework 9
Rough and ready "compactness" General Math 14