Lifting Weight VS Pushing a Scale

In summary, the conversation discusses the concept of whether a scale would read 200lbs if a person with a maximum bench press of 200lbs pushes against it at the weakest point of their bench press motion. The conclusion is that the scale would read 0 at that point, but if the bar was secured and stability was not an issue, the person could potentially push more than 200lbs due to the added stability. The discussion also touches on the role of acceleration and velocity in weightlifting and how it can affect the force applied.
  • #1
BobbyB2
5
0
Is the concept the same? If I am able to bench press a maximum of 200lbs, and I were to push with full force a scale bolted in a stationary position at the weakest point of my bench press motion, would the scale read 200lbs?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Yes, with the caveat that stability plays a role in weightlifting. If you can bench 200 lb, can you dumbell press 2x 100 lb?
 
  • #3
At the "weakest point of my bench press motion" the scale would read 0, as no force is being applied.
 
  • #4
pallidin said:
At the "weakest point of my bench press motion" the scale would read 0, as no force is being applied.
No, at the weakest point, you are just barely able to get the bar off your chest. If the bar+weights is 200lb, then the force is 200 lb. If you couldn't apply any force at the weakest point, you'd choke yourself to death.
 
  • #5
the dumbell question doesn't really come into play because I am only comparing a straight bar with 200lbs on it to the same straight bar being pushed against the scale.
 
  • #6
Thanks Bobby. I'm not sure if my answer is correct(though I think it is), but I do understood your question.
 
  • #7
You can probably push more with a setup like that since its more stable.
 
  • #8
So you are pushing on the barbell and weights and a scale? Or a barbell only? The OP doesn't suggest you are pushing against anything except a scale.

If you are pushing against a bar (and no weights) bolted to a scale, then the force is 200-45= 135.
 
  • #9
Emreth said:
You can probably push more with a setup like that since its more stable.
That was my point with the dumbell comment. You can lift more with a bar than with dumbells because you have 1 axis of stability to deal with instead of 2. And if the setup described by the OP is completely immoble, then you have 0 axes of stability to deal with instead of 2. Essentially, you can push as hard as you want and not have to worry about the force being perfectly vertical.
 
  • #10
russ_watters said:
That was my point with the dumbell comment. You can lift more with a bar than with dumbells because you have 1 axis of stability to deal with instead of 2. And if the setup described by the OP is completely immoble, then you have 0 axes of stability to deal with instead of 2. Essentially, you can push as hard as you want and not have to worry about the force being perfectly vertical.

Well he says its bolted in the first posting. What is 200-45 about?He can probably push 300 lbs with a bolted scale.
 
  • #11
Emreth said:
Well he says its bolted in the first posting.
It didn't say bolted to what, but fair enough.
What is 200-45 about?He can probably push 300 lbs with a bolted scale.
I don't know how much more force he could apply due to the added stability, but if he can only apply 200 lb, the 200-45 is the 200 lb he is capable of generating minus the 45 lb of the bar.
 
  • #12
let me clarify:
senario 1 - a man lifts a 200lbs plate off his chest. we will call the position of the starting point on his chest '0'. his muscles are only capable of lifting this 1 time and he is not capable of lifting any more weight than this. this is called his 1 rep max.
senario 2 - the same man has a scale the exact size and shape as the plate in scenario 1 bolted in place at position '0'. he pushes on the scale with all his force as if to try and do the same motion as from scenario 1.

question: does the scale reach 200lbs? does it pass the 200lbs mark? etc..?

assumption: this is a perfect world and balance does not come into play.

Thanks for all the responses so far!
 
  • #13
Like i said, the scale will pass 200 lbs mark, probably up to 250-300.
 
  • #14
Thanks Emreth! Could you please explain? I saw one mention of stability, but I mentioned in the repost that that is not a factor as both are sompletely stable/balanced. And I saw a mention of the 45lbs of bar, but that has also been removed in the repost.
 
  • #15
The weight of the bar is irrelevant in this case, only the total weight matters, which is 200 lbs. When you're lifting free weights, some of the muscles are used just for balancing. When it's secured as in your case, you can use all the muscles in the single direction, you can push with more force which would show up on the scale as something larger than 200 lbs. If you bench press in a machine in a gym for example, which are stable compared to free weights, you can lift more for the same reason.
 
  • #16
So let's say the weights are guided in scenario 1, so the lifter doesn not have to control stability on his own. Would it the scale then stop at 200lbs?
 
  • #17
no it will go higher. you can push more in that case.
 
  • #18
Force = mass x acceleration
1kg = 2.2 lbs, 200 lbs = 91kg

91 kg barbell resting on a scale on your hand without any movement will show 91 kg X 9.8m/s^2 netwons (equal to 891.8N or 91kg or 200lbs)

Now when you accelerate uniformly it at say 0.2 m/s the force will now become 91 kg x 10 Newtons which is also equal to 93kg. A 3 kg or 6.6lb increase reading on the scale

So in other words acceleration has everything to do with it. The faster you try to lift it, the heavier it will be until velocity is constant.
 
  • #19
BobbyB2 said:
let me clarify:
senario 1 - a man lifts a 200lbs plate off his chest. we will call the position of the starting point on his chest '0'. his muscles are only capable of lifting this 1 time and he is not capable of lifting any more weight than this. this is called his 1 rep max.
senario 2 - the same man has a scale the exact size and shape as the plate in scenario 1 bolted in place at position '0'. he pushes on the scale with all his force as if to try and do the same motion as from scenario 1.

question: does the scale reach 200lbs? does it pass the 200lbs mark? etc..?

assumption: this is a perfect world and balance does not come into play.

Thanks for all the responses so far!

200 lbf is 200 lbf so the scale will read the same thing in a perfectly balanced situation. Different muscles are used for stability when performing a flat bench press (shoulders primarily whereas the pectorals do most of the work in a flat bench press) so in the real world the reading would be essentially the same.

CS
 
  • #20
Infamous_01 said:
Force = mass x acceleration
1kg = 2.2 lbs, 200 lbs = 91kg

91 kg barbell resting on a scale on your hand without any movement will show 91 kg X 9.8m/s^2 netwons (equal to 891.8N or 91kg or 200lbs)

Now when you accelerate uniformly it at say 0.2 m/s the force will now become 91 kg x 10 Newtons which is also equal to 93kg. A 3 kg or 6.6lb increase reading on the scale

So in other words acceleration has everything to do with it. The faster you try to lift it, the heavier it will be until velocity is constant.

Most everyone lifts the weight at a constant velocity so the additional acceleration doesn't exist.

CS
 
  • #21
Emreth said:
no it will go higher. you can push more in that case.

If, as assumed in the OP's statement, the two scenarios are balanced conditions, the scale will read the same and not higher. All of the muscles' force would be applied in the same direction on both the lifts.

CS
 
  • #22
stewartcs said:
Most everyone lifts the weight at a constant velocity so the additional acceleration doesn't exist.

CS

But from rest to that velocity there will be acceleration, until the velocity is constant like i mentioned.
 
  • #23
Assuming the person doesn't try to cheat, it should weigh 200 pounds, since that has been identified as the most he can push. OTOH, if he slammed his hands into the scale, he might be able to get a higher reading (I mention this solely to forewarn you if you're applying this to an actual device)
 
  • #24
Office_Shredder said:
Assuming the person doesn't try to cheat, it should weigh 200 pounds, since that has been identified as the most he can push. OTOH, if he slammed his hands into the scale, he might be able to get a higher reading (I mention this solely to forewarn you if you're applying this to an actual device)

No. A 200lb barbell resting on a table would have the table exerting a 200lbs (x9.8) normal force back onto the weight. The ending result is no movement. Newtons first law: every object will stay at rest or constant velocity if no force acts upon it. So for a weightlifter to hold a 200lb weight and then accelerate it upwards, he would need an additional force to start the acceleration
 
Last edited:
  • #25
Infamous_01 said:
But from rest to that velocity there will be acceleration, until the velocity is constant like i mentioned.

Sorry I didn't see that last part before. However, the initial acceleration would be negligible since the person would hit their constant velocity almost immediately.

CS
 

1. What is the difference between lifting weight and pushing a scale?

Lifting weight and pushing a scale are two different types of physical activities. Lifting weight involves exerting force against gravity to move an object, while pushing a scale involves exerting force against a fixed object to measure its weight.

2. Which activity burns more calories, lifting weight or pushing a scale?

Lifting weight typically burns more calories than pushing a scale, as it requires more muscle engagement and movement. However, the number of calories burned will depend on the intensity and duration of the activity.

3. Is lifting weight or pushing a scale better for building muscle?

Lifting weight is generally considered better for building muscle, as it allows for progressive overload and targets specific muscle groups. Pushing a scale may also engage some muscles, but it is not as targeted as lifting weight.

4. Can lifting weight and pushing a scale have different effects on the body?

Yes, lifting weight and pushing a scale can have different effects on the body. Lifting weight can help increase muscle mass and strength, while pushing a scale may have a more limited impact on muscle development. Additionally, pushing a scale may be better for assessing overall body weight and strength.

5. Which activity is more suitable for beginners, lifting weight or pushing a scale?

For beginners, it is generally recommended to start with lifting weight under the guidance of a trained professional. This allows for proper form and technique to be learned, reducing the risk of injury. Pushing a scale can also be a good starting point for assessing overall strength and setting goals for weightlifting in the future.

Similar threads

Replies
17
Views
1K
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
1K
Replies
10
Views
3K
Replies
14
Views
10K
  • Classical Physics
4
Replies
128
Views
6K
Replies
12
Views
1K
  • Mechanics
Replies
4
Views
600
Back
Top