How to teach the origin of science - Thales

In summary, the conversation revolved around the topic of teaching a 13-year-old girl about the origin and importance of science. The speaker discussed the need to make the lessons interesting and relevant to the student's life, and to use history and experiments to engage her. They also expressed their concerns and sought advice on how to effectively interact with the student and encourage critical thinking. The importance of being flexible and adapting to the student's interests and level of understanding was emphasized. The conversation also touched upon the potential challenges of teaching science to young students and the role of parents in their education.
  • #1
Ethan0718
39
2
Hello, everyone!

I have some education problems about how to teach(or share?) child the origin of science.
By the way, I'm Taiwanese so my English talking ability may not be good...

I've studied so many physics educational theses, history of physics and philosophy..and realize the importance of history of science. Recently, in next week, I'll teach a 13 year-old girl science. It's her first time to learn science seriously so that I want to make it as perfect as possible.

I discuss some ideas with myself as the following:

Q:What's important to me if I want to learn something seriously?
A:Tell me the reason why I "should" learn and persuade me.
Q:What kind of things do I should learn?
A:Something benefits my life.

Afterwards, I found I need to let her know HOW science is closely related to life, HOW human beings created "science". I want to show her the differences between science, myth and religion. In addition, I think the information on the textbook is not good. Most of the science textbooks treat history of science just as "stories". It's not a good way to use history of science to teach students the way to discover nature, ask good question, reasoning from known facts. Instead, it makes science far away from our life experience, just like myths.

So, I want to teach her how ancient people thought about sky, stone, and all natural phenomenon. Try to use these history facts make her know what myth is, what kind of attitude the ancient people take towards the nature. Next, I'll introduce her the leap of Thales. What's the significance of Thales's thought about nature? What is reasoning? How does Thales's thoughts affect the human beings? And finally, what exactly is science? HOW do we benefit from science?

I plan to teach her the contemporary science knowledge until all of the above ideas are practiced and completed.

However... I'm not confident. I can't find someone else who does something like this on the web. I'm not sure if I can do it well. And I don't know how to imagine what kind of problems I'll meet on the class.
I need someone who have this kind of experience to share some ideas and thoughts with me.
Please give me some suggestions...

Please help me! Thank you very much!..
 
Science news on Phys.org
  • #2
I think it's very important to have a good interaction between teacher and student. With that I mean, you should actively try to find out what she finds interesting, and then go into that and use those things as examples.

I'm sure you have a lot of ideas right now, but you should be flexible and realize that these ideas should all change by getting to know her personal interests, and by things she knows already.

Furthermore, science is experimental in nature. So don't shy away from doing experiments. Don't restrict yourself to only theory and saying only facts, but do bring things into practice. The best thing you should do is that science are not just a collection of facts that people made up, but that it is something that we can verify ourselves experimentally.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #3
micromass said:
I think it's very important to have a good interaction between teacher and student. With that I mean, you should actively try to find out what she finds interesting, and then go into that and use those things as examples.

I'm sure you have a lot of ideas right now, but you should be flexible and realize that these ideas should all change by getting to know her personal interests, and by things she knows already.

Furthermore, science is experimental in nature. So don't shy away from doing experiments. Don't restrict yourself to only theory and saying only facts, but do bring things into practice. The best thing you should do is that science are not just a collection of facts that people made up, but that it is something that we can verify ourselves experimentally.

Thank you very much! You're right! It's very important to have a good interaction between teacher and student. It's also troubling me now. I'm not familiar with her... I'll do experiments and thank you for encouraging me!

Hmm...How about telling her why "science" exists? Okay...maybe she won't have that kind of problem. After all, she's just a kid used to accept things blindly...
 
  • #4
Ethan0718 said:
Thank you very much! You're right! It's very important to have a good interaction between teacher and student. It's also troubling me now. I'm not familiar with her... I'll do experiments and thank you for encouraging me!

It's ok not to be familiar with her. But you should try to interact as well as possible. So get to know her by asking good open questions. Try to get her to say what her personal philosophy is. Don't focus only on questions with a right and a wrong answer.

Hmm...How about telling her why "science" exists? Okay...maybe she won't have that kind of problem. After all, she's just a kid used to accept things blindly...

The best thing you can possibly do is to get her to stop accepting things blindly. Get her to start thinking critically about things. If you can at least do that, then you achieved something remarkable.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #5
Not everyone at that age has the maturity to see the point of all those lovely and ambitious things you want to put over. Or maybe it is the opposite, it is at a later age that the attitude 'Francis Bacon? - what's this guy got to do with passing the physics exam?' attitude sets in. Not to mention parents. So you will have to be, as micromass suggests, flexible.

Don't forget scientific experiments are in truth often a long way from what people think of as 'Nature'. Maybe the more dramatic and colourful ones should at first be preferred over 'instructive'!
 
  • #6
I have recently read one book Conceptual Physics, which really shed light on the relation between daily life and physics. This book benefit me a lot even I'm now a senior student in physics.
 

What is the origin of science according to Thales?

Thales believed that the origin of all things came from a single, basic substance known as water. He believed that all things in the universe were made up of water, including the Earth and all living beings.

Why is Thales considered the first scientist?

Thales is considered the first scientist because he was the first person to use rational thinking and observation to explain natural phenomena, rather than relying on mythology or religious beliefs. He also used mathematical principles to make accurate predictions about eclipses and other astronomical events.

How did Thales' teachings impact the development of science?

Thales' emphasis on rational thinking and observation laid the foundation for the scientific method, which is still used by scientists today. He also encouraged others to question traditional beliefs and seek logical explanations for natural phenomena, leading to advancements in fields such as astronomy, mathematics, and philosophy.

What challenges did Thales face in teaching his theories?

Thales faced challenges in teaching his theories because they went against traditional beliefs and were met with skepticism. He also faced criticism from other philosophers and scientists, who may not have agreed with his ideas or methods.

What can we learn from Thales' approach to teaching the origin of science?

We can learn from Thales' approach to teaching the importance of critical thinking, observation, and experimentation in understanding the natural world. His teachings also demonstrate the value of questioning traditional beliefs and using logic and evidence to support theories. Thales' emphasis on the basic substance of water also highlights the importance of simplicity and finding a unifying principle in scientific explanations.

Similar threads

  • STEM Educators and Teaching
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • STEM Educators and Teaching
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • STEM Educators and Teaching
Replies
19
Views
1K
  • STEM Educators and Teaching
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
22
Views
461
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
15
Views
1K
Replies
14
Views
841
  • STEM Educators and Teaching
2
Replies
39
Views
5K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
17
Views
1K
Replies
7
Views
743
Back
Top