- #1
Permanence
- 53
- 2
Hi and thank you for clicking on my thread. I am currently planning to independently study introductory Biology. I ordered two reading supplements; a textbook and a short-reading "Biology For Dummies, 2nd Edition".
I did not expect great content in the book by Kratz, but I do expect the information to be valid. With-in the first fifty pages I came across two comments the author made that I do not agree with.
A. In her discussion of an atom she claimed that an electron does not have any mass. While I can recognize that the mass of an electron is very small, the claim that is non-existent goes against everything I've learned in my classical mechanics course. Who is in the wrong here? Is that a notion that is held in Bio 101 courses?
B. The author claimed that DNA is found in every single cell. I do not agree with that statement. I recall learning that DNA is not found in red blood cells. Once again, who is in the wrong here? Would that statement be correct in a Bio 101 course?
I've stopped reading the book entirely at this point, as I frankly do not feel comfortable reading something that may contain many errors. Could someone weigh in on this matter or perhaps, someone familiar with the text, provide me with some feed back?
With Regards,
Permanence
I did not expect great content in the book by Kratz, but I do expect the information to be valid. With-in the first fifty pages I came across two comments the author made that I do not agree with.
A. In her discussion of an atom she claimed that an electron does not have any mass. While I can recognize that the mass of an electron is very small, the claim that is non-existent goes against everything I've learned in my classical mechanics course. Who is in the wrong here? Is that a notion that is held in Bio 101 courses?
B. The author claimed that DNA is found in every single cell. I do not agree with that statement. I recall learning that DNA is not found in red blood cells. Once again, who is in the wrong here? Would that statement be correct in a Bio 101 course?
I've stopped reading the book entirely at this point, as I frankly do not feel comfortable reading something that may contain many errors. Could someone weigh in on this matter or perhaps, someone familiar with the text, provide me with some feed back?
With Regards,
Permanence