(BSME only) Scientific Paper Question

[myshadow]

I only have a BSME with a very small amount of work experience (I graduated recently). I'm hoping that there is a decent scientific journal out there that would seriously look at my paper regardless of my credentials (or lack thereof), review it, and if they find it correct publish it. Also, I am trying to do this cheaply.

I don't live near my University and I was never really acquainted with any of my Engineering professors so I think asking my school for help may be out of the question. The paper is about a particular solution to the Navier Stokes equation in 3D. Lastly, I'm not sure how correct or incorrect my paper is so it would be great if the journal does peer review. I wouldn't want something completely wrong published with my name on it. haha. Basically, what scientific journal can I submit my paper to given my lack of strong credentials? Thanks.

 

[boneh3ad]

Sounds like you want something like the Journal of Fluid Mechanics, Journal of Fluids Engineering, Physics of Fluids, AIAA Journal, etc. They are all peer reviewed. However, your paper will have to be pretty good to get into a journal. You ought to know if it is correct before you submit it.

 

[myshadow]

Thanks for the suggestions. Do you think they would seriously read my paper given my lack of strong credentials? Or would they look at my credentials and just ignore my paper?

 

[boneh3ad]

If the paper is good they won't care about your credentials. What they care about is results and analysis. If that is valid then Peewee Herman could be the author.

Make sure your work is new though. It will look pretty bad if it has been published before.

If you don't mind me asking, what solution to NS are you trying to publish on?

 

[alphy]

Firstly, congratulations on completing your BSME and writing a scientific paper on a complex topic such as the Navier Stokes equation. As a fellow scientist, I understand the desire to have your work published in a reputable journal and the importance of peer review.

In terms of finding a suitable journal for your paper, I would recommend starting by researching and identifying journals that specialize in the field of fluid mechanics and specifically, the Navier Stokes equation. You can also look for journals that publish papers from early career researchers or those with less experience.

Additionally, consider reaching out to your university's engineering department or professors for guidance and support. They may be able to provide valuable insights and help you identify potential journals for submission.

It is also important to carefully review and revise your paper to ensure it is as accurate and well-written as possible before submitting it. This will increase your chances of getting accepted for publication.

In terms of cost, many journals offer discounted or waived fees for early career researchers or those with limited funding. You can also consider open-access journals that may have lower or no fees for publication.

Lastly, I would advise against submitting your paper to a journal that does not have a rigorous peer review process. While it may be tempting to submit to a less reputable journal in order to save money or due to lack of credentials, it is important to prioritize the quality and accuracy of your work.

Overall, I encourage you to not let your lack of strong credentials discourage you from pursuing publication of your paper. With thorough research and preparation, you can find a suitable journal and hopefully see your work published. Best of luck!