Why do electric motors have full torque at start while IC engines don't?

In summary, electric motors can have full torque at start because the peak of the magnetic force and the peak of the turning moment occur at the same time.
  • #1
sr241
83
0
how electric motor can have full torque at start? is it because magnetic forces are in phase with turning moment curve of rotor of electric motor. i mean the peak of magnetic forces and peak of turning moment occurs at same time. if we implement this in IC engine does it to can have full torque at start. I mean if we make presuure curve in phase with the turning moment curve of crank
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2


I was under the impression that an electric motor has its maximum torque when its angular velocity is 0 because if the angular belocity is 0, there is no change in flux, and no induced EMF (or Back EMF) opposing the direction of the EMF driving the motor.
 
  • #3


sr241 said:
how electric motor can have full torque at start?

It has nothing to do with the phasing. The torque in question is over several phase cycles.

Ignoring the finer and unenlightening details, for a DC motor, torque is proportional to current.

T = KI

The applied voltage minus the current through the series resistive loss (I times R) is proportional to angular velocity.

V - IR = Vmotive

Vmotive = Kω

This is as sr241 was saying. The angular velocity corresponds to a voltage of it's own that subtracts from the applied voltage with the name "back emf". With less voltage available, the current through the resistive loss is reduced; therefore less torque.
 
Last edited:
  • #4


An automobile ICE engine, by design, has to be spinning to make torque. It has to suck in air, compress it, and expel it, and it's not going to do that at 0 RPM. It's not going to do it at 10 RPM either, or even 100 unless it's some huge marine engine. Remember, a piston only makes power 25% of the time, and this power has to pay for the remaining strokes, including compression, which slows it WAY down. So in general, it has to spin at a decent speed to make enough power to be able to even pay for itself. Once it gets there, it has to spin faster to make extra power, and even faster to make the kind of power you want. Depending on design, you'll usually end up being in the thousands of RPM before you get there...

Electric motors, on the other hand...they're just some wires and magnets. You run a current through a wire and it becomes a magnet, which pushes against another magnet and vuoila! you've got force (torque).

The more current you supply, the more torque. I'm guessing the greatest current usually runs at 0rpm, since there's practically no resistance in the wires. Once the motor starts spinning, the moving magnetic field resists the current, and slows it down.

That's my layman's explanation of it, it's extremely simple and obviously will differ as there are many ways to make electric motors, and it may not even be 100% correct...in which case I invite someone to correct me.
 

1. How does an electric motor have full torque at start?

Electric motors are designed with a specific type of rotor called a "squirrel cage" rotor. This rotor has a unique shape that allows it to produce high torque at low speeds. Additionally, electric motors use electromagnets to create a strong magnetic field, which helps to generate high torque at start.

2. Why can't IC engines have full torque at start?

IC engines, or internal combustion engines, rely on the combustion of fuel to generate power. However, at start, there is not enough fuel and air mixture in the engine to produce a strong enough explosion to generate full torque. Additionally, IC engines need to reach a certain speed for the fuel and air mixture to ignite and produce enough power.

3. How does an electric motor maintain full torque at start?

Electric motors are able to maintain full torque at start because they do not rely on combustion or explosions to generate power. Instead, they use electromagnets to create a strong magnetic field, which can produce high torque at low speeds. This allows for consistent and reliable torque at start.

4. Why is it important for an electric motor to have full torque at start?

Having full torque at start is important for an electric motor because it allows for efficient and smooth operation. This is especially crucial in industrial and commercial applications where machines need to start and stop frequently, as well as maintain consistent torque for various tasks.

5. Can an IC engine be modified to have full torque at start?

It is possible to modify an IC engine to have full torque at start, but it would require significant changes to the design and mechanics of the engine. This may not be practical or cost-effective, as the engine would also need to be able to handle the increased stress and strain of producing full torque at start. Electric motors are better suited for this type of high torque, low-speed operation.

Similar threads

  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
10
Views
1K
Replies
34
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
3
Views
3K
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
10
Views
3K
Replies
10
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Back
Top