About the so-call two errors (mistakes) in Misner-Thorne-Wheeler

  • Thread starter dickeywang
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Errors
In summary, during a talk, Kip Thorne mentioned that there are two errors in the Misner-Thorne-Wheeler text. One of the errors involves the misspelling of "Schwarzschild" as "Schwarzs-child" three times. The other error was not mentioned during the talk. It is unclear what the second error is, but it may have been discussed in a previous forum discussion. It is best to wait for clarification from Chris Hillman, who is knowledgeable about the topic.
  • #1
dickeywang
1
0
About the so-call "two errors (mistakes)" in Misner-Thorne-Wheeler

If I remember correctly, Kip Thorne once said that "there are two errors (mistakes) in Misner-Thorne-Wheeler".
I am wondering if anyone know exactly what errors these are (he mentioned one of them during the same talk, but I can't remember it at all:blushing:)?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
They write three times "Schwarzs-child" instead of "Schwarz-schild". That makes a total of 5. :tongue2:
Seriously, I remember having relied on an allegedly erroneous section in a forum discussion not long ago. But the same problem: I can't remember what topic, which forum, or if it really was me. :confused:
Better wait for Chris Hillman, he's the one who should know.
 
  • #3


The "two errors (mistakes)" in Misner-Thorne-Wheeler refer to two mathematical errors that were found in the original edition of the book "Gravitation" by Misner, Thorne, and Wheeler. These errors were pointed out by physicist John Baez in his review of the book in 1973.

The first error was in Chapter 21, where the authors used a formula for the stress-energy tensor that was incorrect. This error was later corrected in the second edition of the book.

The second error was in Chapter 35, where the authors used an incorrect sign convention for the metric tensor. This error was also corrected in the second edition of the book.

Overall, these errors did not significantly affect the main content and ideas presented in the book, but they were important to correct for the sake of mathematical accuracy. It is worth noting that the authors themselves acknowledged and corrected these errors in the second edition of the book, showing their commitment to ensuring the accuracy and reliability of their work.
 

1. What are the two errors in Misner-Thorne-Wheeler?

The two errors in Misner-Thorne-Wheeler (MTW) are known as the "Kasner error" and the "infinity error". The Kasner error relates to a mistake in the calculation of the gravitational field equations, while the infinity error refers to an incorrect assumption about the behavior of matter at the edge of the universe.

2. How were these errors discovered?

The errors in MTW were discovered by physicist Kip Thorne during his graduate studies. He noticed discrepancies in the equations and brought them to the attention of his advisor, John Wheeler, who had co-authored the book with Charles Misner. Together, they investigated and confirmed the presence of the two errors.

3. Have these errors been corrected?

Yes, the errors in MTW have been corrected in subsequent editions of the book. In 1973, a revised version was published with the corrections made to the equations. This version, known as the "Corrected edition", is now the standard reference for MTW.

4. Did these errors have any significant impact on the field of physics?

The errors in MTW did not have a significant impact on the field of physics. They were relatively minor mistakes that did not affect the overall concepts and theories presented in the book. However, their discovery did highlight the importance of rigorous proofreading and peer review in scientific publications.

5. Are there any other notable errors in scientific literature?

Yes, there have been other notable errors in scientific literature throughout history. One famous example is the "Piltdown Man" hoax in the early 20th century, where a fossil was falsely presented as evidence for the missing link between apes and humans. Another example is the "Ars Magna" by Girolamo Cardano, which contained a false proof for solving cubic equations that went unnoticed for over 250 years.

Similar threads

  • Set Theory, Logic, Probability, Statistics
Replies
4
Views
778
  • Special and General Relativity
5
Replies
144
Views
6K
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Set Theory, Logic, Probability, Statistics
Replies
9
Views
1K
  • Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
Replies
30
Views
3K
  • Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
2
Replies
51
Views
4K
  • Set Theory, Logic, Probability, Statistics
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
26
Views
5K
  • Classical Physics
Replies
18
Views
1K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
28
Views
2K
Back
Top