Register to reply 
Tricky circuit 
Share this thread: 
#1
Mar414, 07:31 AM

P: 555

Hi All,
Concerning the first circuit in the attached figure: By applying Kirchhoff laws we arrive at two different currents in the central resistor. But if we consider the second circuit with its auxiliar resistances we see no problem with the definition of the central current. Is it due to the fact that batteries always have some resistance? Infinite currents will appear in the side branches of this first circuit, but even so is there any way to get the appropriate answer to the question of what is the current in the central resistor? I am not sure I have understood well the superposition principle which may well be the method to be used here (in the first circuit). Thanks, Best Wishes, DaTario 


#2
Mar414, 07:38 AM

Mentor
P: 17,213

Superposition doesn't help. If you use the principle of superposition then you get two self contradictory circuits. The first where one node is both 10 V and 0 V and the second where one node is both 20 V and 0 V. 


#3
Mar414, 07:56 AM

PF Gold
P: 370

By applying the Kirchhoff law to the first circuit, you do not get two different currents.
Instead you come to an impossibility (which is 20V=10V). Analyzing what happens makes sense only by comparing to a similar circuit that has been modified to avoid this. The second circuit allows you to think so. Applying the superposition principle to the first circuit leads twice to impossibilities (like 0V = 10V). To use the superposition principle: calculate the current in the central resistor when the left battery is replaced by a 0V battery, calculate the current in the central resistor when the right battery is replaced by a 0V battery, add the two and you will get the result with both batteries in the circuit make sure you understand why this principle holds 


#4
Mar414, 08:35 AM

P: 555

Tricky circuit
Thanks Mr. DaleSpan, but what is the reason to this status of having no solution?



#5
Mar414, 08:42 AM

Mentor
P: 17,213

v=20 v=2i v=10 This is three linear equations in two unknowns. The system is over determined. Over determined systems of equations either have no solution or the equations are not linearly independent. In this case the first and third equation have no solution, so the system has no solution. 


#6
Mar414, 08:42 AM

P: 555

Hi maajdl,
Best Wishes, DaTario 


#7
Mar414, 08:52 AM

P: 555




#8
Mar414, 09:01 AM

P: 555

Consider the attached graphic. It is current versus the value of the auxiliary resistance (both r1 and r2 were taken as equal). The red curve is the central current, the blue and the green are the currents in the side branches. The blue one corresponds to the branch with the smaller battery (10 V). Observe:
1) the convergence to 7.5 A when we take the limit of r > 0, and 2) ther fact that the current in the left side branch inverts its direction at r = 2. Best wishes, DaTario 


#9
Mar414, 09:14 AM

Thanks
P: 1,948

The first circuit is an example of a short circuit. That's why it is potentially dangerous to connect different batteries in parallel with each other.



#10
Mar414, 11:19 AM

Sci Advisor
Thanks
PF Gold
P: 12,132




#11
Mar414, 12:41 PM

Mentor
P: 17,213

That limit depends strongly on the assumption that r1 and r2 are equal. If you violate that assumption then you do not get the same limit. In fact, if r1 is any amount larger than r2 then you get i = 5 A, and if r2 is any amount larger than r1 you get i = 10 A, both as the smaller resistance approaches 0. This kind of instability in the solutions of limiting cases is typical of circuits that do not have a solution. 


#12
Mar414, 04:56 PM

P: 3,135

Aside: You shouldn't connect two ideal current sources in series either :)



#13
Mar414, 05:09 PM

Sci Advisor
Thanks
PF Gold
P: 12,132




#14
Mar414, 08:05 PM

P: 555

Thank you all, I guess a sufficiently good explanation was given here.
Best Regards, DaTario 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Tricky circuit with variable resistor  Introductory Physics Homework  4  
Unknown resistor in circuit  find current through it (tricky)  Engineering, Comp Sci, & Technology Homework  6  
Another circuit task, but tricky.  Engineering, Comp Sci, & Technology Homework  1  
My tricky wave problem. ehh its probably not tricky.  Introductory Physics Homework  15  
Tricky(?) resistance question in a series circuit  Introductory Physics Homework  7 