Explain Where My Argument (MTW Ex 4.10) is Going Wrong - TerryW

Thread starter TerryW
Start date Nov 27, 2013

In summary, the purpose of MTW Ex 4.10 is to provide an exercise for students to practice identifying and analyzing weak arguments. This exercise helps improve critical thinking skills by training individuals to think critically and logically about the validity of an argument. Some common mistakes students make when completing MTW Ex 4.10 include failing to identify all of the flaws in the argument, not providing enough evidence to support their analysis, and not thoroughly explaining their reasoning. To effectively explain where their argument is going wrong in MTW Ex 4.10, students should carefully analyze each statement in the argument and identify any logical fallacies or inconsistencies, provide evidence to support their analysis, and clearly explain how the argument is flawed. Overall, MTW Ex

Nov 27, 2013

TerryW

Gold Member

Can someone explain where my argument (attached) is going wrong?RegardsTerryW

Last edited: Nov 27, 2013

Physics news on Phys.org

Nov 27, 2013

TerryW

Gold Member

Here is the attachment, (didn't click the upload button - doh!)

TerryW

1. What is the purpose of MTW Ex 4.10?

The purpose of MTW Ex 4.10 is to provide an exercise for students to practice identifying and analyzing weak arguments.

2. How does MTW Ex 4.10 help improve critical thinking skills?

MTW Ex 4.10 requires students to carefully examine an argument and identify any flaws or weaknesses. This process helps improve critical thinking skills by training individuals to think critically and logically about the validity of an argument.

3. What are some common mistakes students make when completing MTW Ex 4.10?

Some common mistakes students make when completing MTW Ex 4.10 include failing to identify all of the flaws in the argument, not providing enough evidence to support their analysis, and not thoroughly explaining their reasoning.

4. How can students effectively explain where their argument is going wrong in MTW Ex 4.10?

To effectively explain where their argument is going wrong in MTW Ex 4.10, students should carefully analyze each statement in the argument and identify any logical fallacies or inconsistencies. They should also provide evidence to support their analysis and clearly explain how the argument is flawed.

5. How can MTW Ex 4.10 be used to improve overall argumentation skills?

MTW Ex 4.10 can be used to improve overall argumentation skills by helping students understand the importance of identifying and addressing flaws in arguments. By practicing this exercise, students can develop the ability to construct stronger and more compelling arguments in the future.