Register to reply 
Doppler Effect inconsistent in terms of relative velocities 
Share this thread: 
#1
Mar1614, 08:14 PM

P: 28

Hi all!
Let me use an example to make this clear. There is a car travelling directly toward a man at 10m/s. The car is pressing down its horn, producing a frequency of 100hz. The speed of sound is 330 m/s. What frequency does the man hear? Ok, so we can use the equation: f_observer=( (v+v_o)/(vv_s ) ) * f_source Where v=330, v_o=0 & v_s = 10 Thus f_observer = 103.125 But, if the car was still and the observer moved toward the car at 10m/s we could say: f_observer=( (v+v_o)/(vv_s ) ) * f_source Where v=330, v_o=10, v_s =0 thus f_observer = 103.0303.... 103.0303 does not equal 103.125. Why is there a difference, surely these two things could be the same. 


#2
Mar1614, 08:29 PM

Sci Advisor
Thanks
PF Gold
P: 1,908

Your formula does not agree with Hyperphysics:
http://hyperphysics.phyastr.gsu.edu...d/dopp.html#c2 


#3
Mar1614, 08:55 PM

Engineering
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks
P: 7,112

The two situations are not the same. In one, the sound source is moving relative to the air. In the other, the observer is moving relative to the air.
To see the difference, think about extreme situations, like (1) the source is moving towards the observer at twice the speed of sound (660 m/s) (2) the observer is moving towards the source at 660 m/s 


#4
Mar1714, 10:43 AM

Thanks
P: 1,948

Doppler Effect inconsistent in terms of relative velocities
[tex]f_o=f_s \sqrt \frac{c+v_{rel}}{cv_{rel}},[/tex] where [itex]v_{rel}[/itex] is the relative speed between source and observer. Here there is no medium and the speed of the source is measured relative to the observer. Motion is relative here. 


#5
Mar1714, 12:17 PM

P: 131

So the source gets closer to the observer and the second wave has shorter distance to go and it arrives sooner than if the source was stationary. The speed of the wave relative to observer is the same as this with stationary source(wave can not move in the medium slower or faster ) => speed of sound in the medium. When the source is stationary and observer is moving, the speed of wave relative to him is the sum of his speed and waves speed (they are traveling against each other and wave travels with the speed of sound in the medium) http://hyperphysics.phyastr.gsu.edu...ound/dopp.html 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Angular Velocities using Relative Velocities  Introductory Physics Homework  7  
2D Doppler Shift / Relative Velocities  Classical Physics  1  
Relative Doppler Effect  Special & General Relativity  5  
Doppler effect and relative motion  Introductory Physics Homework  1  
Doppler Radar Relative Velocities  Introductory Physics Homework  3 