Register to reply 
Water to Iceby Naveen345
Tags: water 
Share this thread: 
#1
Jan213, 05:38 AM

P: 19

When water freezes to ice, it becomes so strong that we can move over it.
This freezing takes place of bonding between water molecules, the mass of water being the same. 1. Does it mean that we are virtually walking on forces? 2. Does it mean that forces are more important than mass because the solid structure (or even liquid or gaseous structure) of this universe is basically because of forces? 3. Are these forces energies of one or the other kind (I know energy and mass are interchangeable under special circumstance, but still force is a force and mass just mass under normal conditions)? If force is a form of energy, why don’t we call it energy? (Though for gravity we usually say gravitational force or gravitational energy, both meaning the same) 4. If we treat ice quantum mechanically, what would it deal with to a large extent? Force or mass? 


#2
Jan213, 09:08 AM

Mentor
P: 11,631

1. what do you mean with "virtually walking on forces"?
Keep in mind that you walk on solid surfaces all the time, you don't need ice. 2. How do you define importance of force and mass? Is a day more important than 1km? 3. Force is not energy, those are two different concepts. Force multiplied with displacement is energy. 4. Mass and energy would be more interesting than forces in the calculations. 


#4
Jan213, 12:47 PM

P: 3,109

Water to Ice
Brilliant as ever.



#5
Jan213, 09:49 PM

P: 535




#6
Jan313, 12:05 AM

P: 19

Is this inability because of language? Why in the very first place is so much complexity involved in our universe that even language and expression fail to decipher it. I thought nature loved simplicity. 


#7
Jan313, 02:38 AM

Admin
P: 23,397




#8
Jan313, 02:50 AM

P: 887




#9
Jan313, 03:12 AM

P: 535

Look at the universe of Ptolemy. It took how many centuries to finally get some working model of the cosmos. And it was basically a patch job. But it worked, mostly. To the scientists and lay people of the day, that was as good as it was going to get. That was how the universe worked, for them. Of course, Ptolemy’s model was unnecessarily complicated, as Copernicus soon pointed out. The same state of overcomplexity exists right now, Higgs discovery or not. Until we’ve found the bridge between GR and QM, you can be sure of that. 


#10
Jan313, 03:40 AM

Admin
P: 23,397




#11
Jan413, 05:52 AM

P: 19

1. But why is multiplication used instead of simpler concept of ‘addition’ in formulas like F=m.a and not F=m+a I know what is wrong with F=m+a, I just wanted to ask if nature prefers multiplication over addition in manymany formulas that are derived until now. Nature itself seems to favour the more complex concept i.e multiplication. 2. If we consider the abstract and complex maths of quantum mechanics with all its operators and all that, it seems that nature is a product of ‘something or someone’ that is more obsessed with complexity rather than simplicity. 3. To ask further: What is the ‘normal’ or ‘preferred’ state of this universe? Everybody would say increase in entropy (chaos). So please answer these questions as I have been fed since school time that nature loves simplicity and symmetry and that the best explanation of nature turns out to be a simpler one rather than a complex one? 


#12
Jan413, 08:30 AM

Mentor
P: 11,631

I don't think multiplication is more complex than addition. Multiplication occurs naturally if you want something to be proportional to something else.
In addition, multiplication is addition on a logarithmic scale: ##a=bc## is equivalent to ##\log(a)=\log(b)+\log(c)## (assuming a,b,c>0). 


#13
Jan413, 09:12 PM

P: 535




Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Cooling hot water by adding in cool water and draining out the hot water  Formulae  General Physics  5  
Re: Building a hydrodynamics water tunnel for surface water wheel testing.  General Engineering  4  
Heat power needed to partially evaporate water from a water container  Introductory Physics Homework  1  
Basic question regarding triple point of water and physical properties of water  Introductory Physics Homework  9 