Triac heatup question


by Smed
Tags: heatup, triac
Smed
Smed is offline
#1
Oct26-13, 03:35 PM
P: 28
Let's say I have two separate 120V AC circuits, each with a triac (15A) that controls a heat element. The first circuit has a heat element that draws a maximum of 1000W. The second circuit heat element draws 2000W. In the first circuit, I leave the triac gate on at all times, and in the second circuit, the triac has a 50% duty cycle, so that the total power drawn is 1000W.

If both of these circuits draw 1000W, will both triacs heat up at the same rate?
Phys.Org News Partner Engineering news on Phys.org
Fiber-optic microscope will help physicians detect cancer, diseases at early stages
Wind tunnel tests support improved aerodynamic design of B61-12 bomb
Smart sensor technology to combat indoor air pollution
Windadct
Windadct is offline
#2
Oct26-13, 05:55 PM
P: 532
Actually no, the one with the 50% duty cycle (estimated) will probably heat up more, because is is conducting the same power in less time. If this is 120V Branch ckts, the triac is undersized for the 2000W load. Also - there is pretty big variation between types / quality of triac dimmers, so running at > 15A is likely a fire hazard.
meBigGuy
meBigGuy is offline
#3
Oct27-13, 04:45 AM
P: 960
Assume the triac has a fixed resistance. Since power is I^2 * R, if there is twice the current, there is 4X the power. 4X the power for 1/2 the time is 2X the power (on average).

Also, if you do not use zero-point switching there will be additional power when the triac switches on.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Optoisolator + Triac Question Electrical Engineering 1
Split of fuel oil consumption to heatup multiple type liquid Classical Physics 0
Detecting triac failure whether under load or not Electrical Engineering 5
problems with triac control on IR heaters Electrical Engineering 4
[Electrical Eng.] TRIAC & ISM research Introductory Physics Homework 0