How does high school maths compare to university maths?

In summary, the conversation discusses the difference between high school and university mathematics, with emphasis on the importance of learning proofs and being able to prove things yourself. It is suggested to start by learning basic logic and proofs and to practice by doing exercises. Book recommendations for learning proofs are also given. The conversation also touches on famous proofs and the significance of learning them, as well as the types of proofs typically given in university. Finally, the conversation concludes by emphasizing the need to focus on understanding the methods used in proofs rather than just memorizing famous proofs.
  • #1
Synchronised
47
0
I am in my final year of high school, I am doing the highest level of maths available but I don't find it difficult at all, so I was wondering whether or not I should cover some university level mathematics before doing bachelor of science (Advanced) next year.

For this BSc I am allowed to do two majors (1 major replaces electives) over 3 years, the available majors are physics, chemistry, maths, nanotech, medical science, computer science, biology erc... so I am thinking about doing physics and maths.

The topics I will cover by the end of high school (October 2013) are curve sketching, complex numbers, polynomials, advanced calculus, mechanics, conics, series and induction, inequalities, circle geo, combinations and permutations, binomial theorem, probability, trig, parametric equations and more... so which topics should I study during the 2013 December holidays before uni starts? I am thinking differential equations because we don't study those in HS, what else? By the way the university website doesn't say what topics are covered in first semester for physics and maths so I have no idea what to study?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
University mathematics is vastly different from high school mathematics. Unless you went to a really good high school, your current high school experience in mathematics is probably memorizing formulas and rules and plug-n-chug exercises. This will end in university. Mathematics there is much more proof based. Instead of being able to calculate things, you will be expected to know why and how something works.

That you did well in high school is not a guarantee that you will be good in university math. The opposite is also true: I know people who were very bad in high school math, but who excelled in university.

If I were you, I would absolutely try to learn basic logics and proofs. Being able to prove things is so important in mathematics.

You can learn proofs either from a proof book or by working through an actual math course. If you want a proof book, then I don't think there is a better book than https://www.amazon.com/dp/0521675995/?tag=pfamazon01-20.
If you want to do some actual mathematics, then you might want to think of going through https://www.amazon.com/dp/0914098918/?tag=pfamazon01-20 (this is a highly nontrivial book!) or you might want to consider this gem: https://www.amazon.com/dp/9048166098/?tag=pfamazon01-20

The trick to writing proofs is to make as much proofs as you can, and then to present the proofs you have written to somebody else (for example, on our homework forum). Then you should ask that other person to give as much criticism of the proof as he can. In the beginning, he will probably rip your entire proof to shreds. But you will see that you will get gradually better in time. This is really the only way of learning proofs.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #3
Should I start by learning famous proofs like Wallis Product, Taylor Series for e, Gregory/Leibniz Series, Sine Integral and the Riemann-Lebesgue Lemma, Basel Problem, Ceva's theorem, Gama function, The fundamental theorem of algebra, riemann zeta function, Irrationality of various real numbers etc...? After that I will buy one of the books you suggested to learn more proofs.
What other proofs can I learn? and at university do we get asked to just prove something or are we given step by step instructions?
Thank you a lot micromass, this kind of opened my eyes, I now realize that the level of maths I am studying is just the basics even though it is labeled advanced mathematics at high school level and 90% of the students struggle with it.
 
  • #4
Synchronised said:
Should I start by learning famous proofs like Wallis Product, Taylor Series for e, Gregory/Leibniz Series, Sine Integral and the Riemann-Lebesgue Lemma, Basel Problem, Ceva's theorem, Gama function, The fundamental theorem of algebra, riemann zeta function, Irrationality of various real numbers etc...? After that I will buy one of the books you suggested to learn more proofs.
What other proofs can I learn? and at university do we get asked to just prove something or are we given step by step instructions?

You seem to have the wrong idea. The goal is not that you should learn famous proofs. The goal should be that you could invent and make a proof yourself. Reading proofs is good, but it won't help you as much as doing proofs yourself. It's a bit like watching others swim: you might learn from seeing their technique, but it won't teach you to swim.

So no, you shouldn't "learn proofs", you should learn how to prove! That's a big difference. At university, they will often just give a statement and ask you to prove it yourself. In the beginning, they might give some hints or instructions, but that won't last very long.

You mention all these famous theorems. But you won't really see the significance of them until you know how to prove things yourself. If you read mathematics, then your focus should be on "how can I use this theory to prove things myself later?" and "Does this proof contain important ideas that might be helpful?" So you should always read mathematics with the goal of proving things yourself later on. Doing exercises is an essential part of this.

Thank you a lot micromass, this kind of opened my eyes, I now realize that the level of maths I am studying is just the basics even though it is labeled advanced mathematics at high school level and 90% of the students struggle with it.
 
  • #5
So what I should concentrate on now is doing exercises where I can prove things myself. Do the textbooks you mentioned have exercises?
In my high school textbook there are a lot of prove questions and I do them all but they are very simple, for example, if n is a positive integer, prove that [tex]\sqrt[n]{n!}\geq \sqrt{n}[/tex]. If they were to ask us to prove something more difficult like prove pi is irrational or prove the Basel problem they would step us through the question making it much easier.
I will learn the famous proofs I mentioned earlier but as you said I will try to learn the methods used in the prove and how I can use them to prove other problems but where can I find other problems?
 
Last edited:
  • #6
My way of looking at a introductory pure math course at the University level is much like building something completely from scratch.

You are given axioms (laws) that "govern" how the objects they describe are related.
From these axioms, you construct results or theorems by combining them. And from there, more and more abstract theorems and objects are manufactured until you construct an entire subfield of mathematics.

But it's a bit more complicated than that. Different math subfields collaborate for instance.
 
  • #7
Synchronised said:
So what I should concentrate on now is doing exercises where I can prove things myself. Do the textbooks you mentioned have exercises?
In my high school textbook there are a lot of prove questions and I do them all but they are very simple, for example, if n is a positive integer, prove that [tex]\sqrt[n]{n!}\geq \sqrt{n}[/tex]. If they were to ask us to prove something more difficult like prove pi is irrational or prove the Basel problem they would step us through the question making it much easier.
I will learn the famous proofs I mentioned earlier but as you said I will try to learn the methods used in the prove and how I can use them to prove other problems but where can I find other problems?

All the textbooks I mentioned have exercises. In fact, I suggested the textbooks especially because they have good exercises.
 
  • #8
You may want to read this post by Tim Gowers, which although expressly aimed at Cambridge students is in fact generally applicable.
 
  • #9
I will buy the Daniel J. Velleman's book since it is the cheapest :) thank you again!
 
  • #10
I'm just about to finish first year Linear Algebra tomorrow morning (that's my final), and all I can say is it truly does not compare to high-school maths at all. High-school was based on, "here's an equation, here's some value, solve for x", university level maths are more like, "here are some values, what can I do with them and why am I doing it? How can I take these values and apply them to things we encounter on a daily basis?".

As an example, in high-school I learned how to solve simple matrices, in university I've learned how these matrices essentially make up the way Googletm ranks pages in a search. Or how the 3x3 lights out game is mathematically defined.

There's not a whole lot you can do to prepare for university maths, seeing as it is like starting from scratch all over again. But as micromass suggested, learning to prove things on your own could be of benefit to you.
 

1. How does the difficulty level of high school math compare to university math?

University math is typically more challenging than high school math. The concepts are more advanced and require a deeper understanding of mathematical principles. In addition, the pace at which material is covered is faster in university, making it more difficult to keep up.

2. Are the topics covered in high school math the same as those in university math?

There is some overlap between high school and university math, but the topics covered in university math tend to be more complex and in-depth. University math also covers a wider range of topics and may include more abstract concepts.

3. Is there a difference in the teaching style between high school and university math?

In high school math, the focus is often on memorizing formulas and solving specific types of problems. In university math, the emphasis is on understanding concepts and applying them to real-world situations. Professors may also use more advanced and interactive teaching methods in university math courses.

4. Are there any major differences in the expectations for high school and university math students?

In high school math, students are expected to complete assignments and pass exams. In university math, students are expected to not only complete assignments and exams, but also actively participate in class, ask questions, and engage in independent learning. The expectations for critical thinking and problem-solving skills are also higher in university math.

5. How can I prepare for the transition from high school to university math?

To prepare for university math, it is important to have a strong foundation in high school math. This includes understanding basic concepts and being able to solve problems independently. Additionally, developing good study habits and time management skills can also help with the transition to university math. It may also be helpful to review and refresh your knowledge of high school math topics before starting university math courses.

Similar threads

Replies
23
Views
633
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
1
Views
824
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
22
Views
466
Replies
6
Views
758
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
14
Views
1K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
3
Views
806
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
1K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
2
Views
566
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
5
Views
1K
Back
Top