Why can't people grow infinitely tall?

In summary, the conversation discusses the relationship between muscle size and strength and how people cannot grow indefinitely tall due to the limitations of their muscle strength. The conversation then goes on to explore this concept in the context of a larger planet and concludes that the maximum height of a person on a larger planet would be proportional to the surface gravity of that planet.
  • #1
black_squirrel
21
0
This is a strange one:

1. The problem statement

It is known that the strength of the muscles is proportional to the area of their section.
In other words, if the muscles are two times more thick, they have four times greater strength.Explain why people cannot grow indefinitely tall.


The Attempt at a Solution



I have no idea where to start actually and I'm completely stuck. I would appreciate any help i can get here.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Maybe,muscles with greater area need more energy.
 
  • #3
If the muscle is twice as thick and twice as long, how much more is it's volume?
What is it's weight proportional to?
Does the muscle strength increase faster or slower than the weight it needs to support?
 
  • #4
Okay so muscles strength is proportional to the square of the thickness while mass it needs to support is proportional to the cube of the thickness. Mass grows faster so there's a limit. that's clear.

the question then asks: The size of some planet is 10 times greater than that of the earth. Its mass is 1000 times greater than the mass of the Earth. Suppose that the tallest person on the Earth is 2 meters high, what would be the height of the tallest man living on the surface of this planet?

Okay so I know using the 2 meters high, I need to find some sort of constant that relates strength to mass. not too sure how to do this. and I'm thinking i need to somehow incorporate the different "g" that will be observed because of the different size of the planet. aah so confused. Help please!
 
  • #5
black_squirrel said:
It is known that the strength of the muscles is proportional to the area of their section.
In other words, if the muscles are two times more thick, they have four times greater strength.Explain why people cannot grow indefinitely tall.

I didn't realize there is a direct relationship to one's muscle size and how tall they are!

It would seem that their height is independent of their muscle size. Otherwise all the small people in the world would start bodybuilding and get taller! :rofl:
 
  • #6
black_squirrel said:
the question then asks: The size of some planet is 10 times greater than that of the earth. Its mass is 1000 times greater than the mass of the Earth. Suppose that the tallest person on the Earth is 2 meters high, what would be the height of the tallest man living on the surface of this planet?

Okay so I know using the 2 meters high, I need to find some sort of constant that relates strength to mass. not too sure how to do this. and I'm thinking i need to somehow incorporate the different "g" that will be observed because of the different size of the planet. aah so confused. Help please!

You are absolutely on the right track. Find the surface gravity on the planet in terms of g.
 
  • #7
but i don't see how i can relate the weight of the person to the thickness of the muscle. that's the part that's keeping me from doing this.
 
  • #8
The accn due to gravity at the surface of a spherical body is GM/R^2. If that of planet is g’, whose mass is Mp and radius Rp, then g/g’ = (Me/Mp)(Rp/Re)^2, where suffix e stands for earth. The ratios are given.

The max weight/muscle area should be constant if the muscles on both planets are made of the same material. Suppose Lp and Le are the max heights. I’ll use the symbol ~ for “is proportional to”. Mass ~ volume = L^3 for same density. We can write,

maximum weight/muscle area ~ mg/L^2 ~ L^3*g/L^2 = L*g. So, L*g is constant.

Then, Lp*g’ = Le*g => Lp = Le*g/g’.

Plug in the values now.

(By the size I presume the volume is meant, which is giving a very small height indeed on the other planet, because g’ of the other planet is very high. Confirm whether they mean radius is 10 times. Anyway, the method is what matters.)
 

1. What factors contribute to a person's strength?

The main factors that contribute to a person's strength include their muscle mass, genetics, and physical activity level. Additionally, a person's diet and overall health can also play a role in their strength.

2. Is there a correlation between height and strength?

There is some evidence to suggest that taller individuals may have a slight advantage in terms of strength due to their longer levers and larger muscle mass. However, this is not always the case, as factors such as muscle composition and training can also play a significant role in a person's strength regardless of their height.

3. Can a person's strength be improved through training?

Yes, a person's strength can be significantly improved through regular training and exercise. By challenging their muscles and gradually increasing the intensity of their workouts, individuals can see significant improvements in their strength over time.

4. Is there a limit to how strong a person can become?

While there is no definitive limit to how strong a person can become, there are physical limitations based on genetics and muscle structure. Additionally, factors such as age and overall health can also impact a person's potential for strength gains.

5. How do genetics play a role in a person's strength and height?

Genetics can play a significant role in a person's strength and height. Certain genetic traits can affect muscle size and composition, as well as bone structure and height potential. However, genetics are not the only determining factor and can be influenced by other factors such as diet and exercise.

Similar threads

  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
10
Views
1K
  • Science Fiction and Fantasy Media
Replies
0
Views
881
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
14
Views
2K
Replies
32
Views
2K
Replies
22
Views
1K
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Engineering and Comp Sci Homework Help
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
9
Views
1K
  • Sci-Fi Writing and World Building
Replies
31
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
1K
Back
Top