Reversed water sprinkler

  • Thread starter thomasxc
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Water
In summary, the circular motion of a sprinkler underwater can be turned the wrong way if the nozzles are small.
  • #1
thomasxc
140
0
this is quoted from feynman's "surely youre joking, mr. feynman"


"i once did an experiment in the cyclotron lab at princeton that had some startling results. there was a problem in a hydrodynamics book that was being discussed by all the physics students. the problem was this: you have an S-shaped lawn sprinkler- and S-shaped pipe on a pivot- and the water squirts out at right angles to the axis and makes it spin in a certain direction.everyone knows which way it goes around; it backs away from the outgoing water. now the question is this: if you had a lake, or a swimming pool-a big supply of water- and you put the sprinkler completely under water, and sucked the water in, instead of squirting it out, which way would it turn?"


so, which way would it spin?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
The other way, but not as fast.
 
  • #3
The problem with the underwater sucking spinkler is that due to viscosity, the suction stream induces a larger stream of water that generates an opposing force onto the sprinkler parts, so the sprinkler will barely move, or perhaps move the "wrong" way. In addition, the flow inside the sprinker pipes is curved and this generates a force and torque in the "wrong" direction as well.
 
  • #4
Think about it like a pinwheel - wind going one way spins it that way, wind going the other spins it the opposite. It would indeed spin in the opposite direction, but the viscosity of the water would keep it extremely slow.
 
  • #5
that makes sense.thanks!
 
  • #7
I had this in an interview once and the 'correct' answer was that it spins the same way.
The logic being that in normal mode the thrust comes from the reaction of the water against the closed end of the tube opposite the nozzle (just like in the simple explanation of a rocket engine) .
In the suck case - the water would rush in and hit the wall opposite the nozzle in the same way (although flowing in the opposite direction) there is still a change in momentum in the same rotation direction.
 
  • #8
mgb_phys said:
In the suck case - the water would rush in and hit the wall opposite the nozzle in the same way (although flowing in the opposite direction) there is still a change in momentum in the same rotation direction.
The water has a momentum toward the nozzle and as a result of conservation of momentum, the nozzle has a momentum toward the water: the net angular momentum of both systems is zero. I think the answer given to you is wrong.

In any case, I don't like such intentionally argumentative and misleading questions.
 
  • #9
russ_watters said:
The water has a momentum toward the nozzle and as a result of conservation of momentum, the nozzle has a momentum toward the water: the net angular momentum of both systems is zero.
I was picturing it (the suck case) as equivalent to an empty nozzle having high pressure water blown into the open end - that would seem to make the nozzle move with the flowing water, like drinking from a firehose.


In any case, I don't like such intentionally argumentative and misleading questions.
I was on the receiving end of this one - I guessed it was the same direction largely on the basis that the only reason they would ask this sort of question is that the answer was counter intuitive!
 
  • #10
or perhaps i asked the question because i didn't know the answer and genuinely wanted to...
 

1. What is a reversed water sprinkler?

A reversed water sprinkler is a type of sprinkler that is designed to push water downwards rather than upwards. This is achieved by reversing the direction of the water flow, causing the water to flow in the opposite direction from traditional sprinklers.

2. How does a reversed water sprinkler work?

A reversed water sprinkler works by connecting to a water source and using a pump to push water through a series of pipes and nozzles. The water is then directed downwards towards the ground, creating a spray pattern that is ideal for watering plants and lawns.

3. What are the benefits of using a reversed water sprinkler?

Using a reversed water sprinkler can have several benefits, including more efficient water usage, better coverage for larger areas, and reduced water waste due to evaporation. It can also help to prevent water runoff and reach areas that traditional sprinklers may miss.

4. Are there any drawbacks to using a reversed water sprinkler?

One potential drawback of using a reversed water sprinkler is that it may require more maintenance, as the pump and pipes may need to be cleaned more frequently. Additionally, they may be more expensive upfront compared to traditional sprinklers.

5. Can a reversed water sprinkler be used for other purposes besides watering plants?

Yes, a reversed water sprinkler can be used for other purposes such as cooling outdoor areas, cleaning outdoor surfaces, and creating a misting effect for hot days. Some models also have adjustable nozzles that allow for different spray patterns, making them versatile for various uses.

Similar threads

  • Mechanics
Replies
13
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Mechanics
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Classical Physics
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
5K
  • Classical Physics
Replies
12
Views
1K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
0
Views
412
Replies
5
Views
7K
Replies
11
Views
5K
Back
Top