Protecting Your Scientific Work: How to Safeguard Your Ideas and Discoveries

  • Thread starter Fragment
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Work
In summary, the conversation discusses concerns about sharing and protecting original work in the field of mathematics. Some suggestions are made, such as submitting the work to a journal or using a lawyer to testify the date of possession. The concept of independent discovery is also brought up, as well as the idea of hiding or encrypting the work for added security. It is mentioned that mathematicians place a high value on honor and integrity in regards to authorship and recognition of work.
  • #1
Fragment
149
3
To hide under the great cover of anonymity, let us suppose that I have found something worth great recognition and possibly a prize in mathematics, how do I know that I will not be stolen out of it? How do I know that by sharing it someone will not try to write out their own copy of it and submit it before I do? This leads me into an endless chain of paranoia since that I know of nothing that can protect me if I was to check the validity of my formulation with an expert in the field. Any insight would be greatly appreciated.
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Fragment said:
To hide under the great cover of anonymity, let us suppose that I have found something worth great recognition and possibly a prize in mathematics, how do I know that I will not be stolen out of it? How do I know that by sharing it someone will not try to write out their own copy of it and submit it before I do? This leads me into an endless chain of paranoia since that I know of nothing that can protect me if I was to check the validity of my formulation with an expert in the field. Any insight would be greatly appreciated.

If you have indeed found something worth publishing, submitting it to a journal is an appropriate method of publicizing your work. If there are errors, they will return it but it will at least be on record as being your original work so if you then decide to collaborate, it is at least traceable that you were the person behind the original work :).
 
  • #3
Is there a way other than this to get it revised? I do know that journals often select an "intermediate" that will judge your work based on his expertise, but I am trying to focus on another way if possible. Publishing is definitely in my scope albeit the fact that I do not take errors lightly:smile:.
 
  • #4
The sooner you submit your work, the earlier you can stake a claim to priority. The longer you hold onto it the more you risk someone else independently publishing the same (or a similar) result.
 
  • #5
So I deduce that trying to get the work revised by someone else than a journal is not recommended? If so, than all my questions seem answered. And for one more thing, surely I am not the only one who feels this, but, how do others go through life without being acquainted with science or mathematics? How do some people just carry on their same everyday tasks and wait for retirement? Were maths taken away from me, I'd have an infinitely large hole of emptiness!:rolleyes:
 
  • #6
To be honest, quite the opposite. Unless you're surrounded by some screwed up people, the more people you tell the better since it would be more obvious that you were the one to create it.
 
  • #7
Are you not scared that your idea will be thieved?
 
  • #8
Fragment said:
Are you not scared that your idea will be thieved?

Honestly, that's less of a danger than independent discovery. Just look at how many major discoveries were found by multiple people at around the same time!

Just put it up on a preprint server and have whoever you want help you revise it. That should put your (unwarranted, IMO) fears to rest.
 
  • #9
What exactly do you mean by independent discovery?
 
  • #10
Fragment said:
What exactly do you mean by independent discovery?

Many discoveries have occurred simultaneously by different people. That is, multiple people, working independently of each other, discovered the same thing. First one to publish wins :)
 
  • #11
Independent discovery as in someone else who never saw your work publishes a very similar paper. If the foundation for a good paper has been laid (which it has if you were able to write one) and there are enough people who care about the topic then often times it gets discovered more than once. This has happens all the time with breakthrough discoveries.

edit:ninja'd
 
  • #12
Ahh, well of course, Calculus, Natural selection,Relativity, and Quantum Mechanics come to mind... Thanks for the help.

Edit: I had seen this as more of simultaneous discoveries. Independent to me sounds as "Finding something on one's own, without help."
 
  • #13
If you are doing a PhD thesis, you can put it on Arxiv, this is not the best option but at least you will have a chance if your teacher or other try to plagiarize your work

there are many journals helping Ph D or similar student , if you have confidence on him you can tell your teacher .
 
  • #14
If you don't trust fellow scholars, get a copy to a lawyer, have him testify the date that you gave it into his possession, and then go on to speak with the other scholars.
 
  • #15
I like arildno's suggestion. Such a thing would be considered as confidential to the lawyer, it would be legitimate and very secure. Thank you very much.
 
  • #16
Hiding your work is considered anathema to many mathematicians; some still do not like the way that Wiles went about things. Mathematicians pride themselves on their honour; which fields list authors on papers in strict alphabetical order?
 
  • #17
arildno said:
If you don't trust fellow scholars, get a copy to a lawyer, have him testify the date that you gave it into his possession, and then go on to speak with the other scholars.

Maybe it is also possible hiding your concept, more or less "crypted", in a picture you deposit at an "image host" - free and automatically dated. Then only you know your secret... At least it might be used as a reserve "emergency" security if the lawyer stole your promising concept :cool:
 

1. How do you protect your work from being stolen?

As a scientist, there are several steps I take to protect my work from being stolen. First, I make sure to keep my research and data confidential and only share it with trusted colleagues. Additionally, I apply for patents or copyrights for any inventions or discoveries I make. I also keep thorough records and documentation of my work to prove ownership if necessary.

2. What measures do you take to prevent others from plagiarizing your work?

To prevent others from plagiarizing my work, I make sure to properly cite and reference any sources I use in my research. I also use plagiarism detection software to check my work before publishing or sharing it. If I suspect that my work has been plagiarized, I will take legal action to protect my intellectual property rights.

3. How do you protect your work from being used without your permission?

To protect my work from being used without my permission, I make sure to clearly state my terms of use and copyright on any publications or presentations. I also monitor for any unauthorized use of my work and take legal action if necessary. Additionally, I make sure to have contracts and agreements in place when collaborating with others to protect my rights.

4. What steps do you take to ensure the confidentiality of your research?

To ensure the confidentiality of my research, I limit access to only those who need to know and sign non-disclosure agreements. I also encrypt any sensitive data and use secure storage systems. When presenting my research, I make sure to only share what is necessary and avoid discussing unpublished or confidential findings.

5. How do you protect your work from being compromised by cyber attacks?

To protect my work from cyber attacks, I use strong passwords and regularly update my security software. I also make sure to back up my data regularly and have secure backups in case of a breach. I am also cautious when opening emails or clicking on links from unknown sources to avoid potential malware. In case of a cyber attack, I have a response plan in place to minimize damage and protect my work.

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
878
  • General Discussion
Replies
13
Views
1K
  • General Discussion
Replies
4
Views
605
Replies
5
Views
905
  • Feedback and Announcements
Replies
1
Views
262
  • General Discussion
Replies
12
Views
865
Replies
13
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
916
Replies
10
Views
928
  • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
4
Views
1K
Back
Top