Alternators: Better Conductors than Copper? Carbon Nanotubes, Superconductors

  • Thread starter eli_lied
  • Start date
In summary: The problem with cables is that they are brittle and can break, but that is being worked on.In summary, there is no clear winner when it comes to best conductor for windings. Carbon nanotubes could be a good option, but they may not be as efficient as copper. It is also possible to use a cryocooler to improve power savings, but it may not be necessary.
  • #1
eli_lied
12
0
is there a better conductor than copper to be used in the windings? Could carbon nanotubes be used instead? what if a superconducting material is made into a tube and a coolant is run through it...would that affect the material's tendency to stop conducting as a strong magnetic force permeates it?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
I'm pretty sure that driving around with a cryogenic refrigerator will negate any power savings from the windings.
 
  • #3
The efficiency of alternators is already pretty high. I don't think there is much value in exotic upgrades. It isn't worth the cost.

[edit] ...Ranger Mike said in the related thread that alternators are only about 40% efficient. It would surprise me if they were really that low.

[edit2] ...According to the wiki, car alternators are 50-60% efficient. Still pretty surprising to me.
 
  • #4
Here is a list of the electrical condutivity of metals at room temperature:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrical_conductivity
Silver is about 10% better than copper. Silver was used in the Calutron coils during WW II, not because silver has a better conductivity, but because copper was needed to make brass shell casings. Aluminum is best per unit mass density.
Research has been done on superconducting generators and alternators. The biggest problem is getting adequate cooling to the rotating armature. Google superconducting generator OR alternator.
Bob S
 
  • #5
eli_lied said:
what if a superconducting material is made into a tube and a coolant is run through it...would that affect the material's tendency to stop conducting as a strong magnetic force permeates it?
Liquid helium permeates the windings of magnets using superconducting wire to keep it cool.

Superconductors have a "critical field" limit, the magnetic field beyond which the superconductor "quenches" or becomes normal (non-superconducting).

Superconductors exhibit the Meissner effect, which leads to the superconductor excluding the magnetic field. There are type I and type II Meissner effect superconductors. This causes magnets to lose inductance as the conductor becomes superconducting. See thumbnail in post #3 in
https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=317523
The upper curve is at 10 kelvin, above the critical temperature (the critical temperature for niobuim-3 tin is about 9 kelvin). The lower curve is at 4.2 kelvin.
Bob S
 
  • #6
Vanadium 50 said:
I'm pretty sure that driving around with a cryogenic refrigerator will negate any power savings from the windings.

You can use a "bolt on" cryocooler. As long as you only need to go down to 50-60K a very simple single-stage cooler is enough and they don't use much power as long as the system is well insulated.
There have been plenty of demonstratations of working superconducting generators, etc based on high-temperature superconductors although as far as i know there are yet no commercial products available. Last I heard American Superconductor were developing equipment for wind energy and I am sure they are not the only ones.

Cooling a normal metal wouldn't make sense. If you are going to cool it down you might as well use superconducting wires.
 
  • #7
f95toli said:
You can use a "bolt on" cryocooler. As long as you only need to go down to 50-60K a very simple single-stage cooler is enough and they don't use much power as long as the system is well insulated.
There have been plenty of demonstratations of working superconducting generators, etc based on high-temperature superconductors although as far as i know there are yet no commercial products available. Last I heard American Superconductor were developing equipment for wind energy and I am sure they are not the only ones.

Cooling a normal metal wouldn't make sense. If you are going to cool it down you might as well use superconducting wires.
Which leads back to the Big Problem in developing practical high temp superconductors: So far, all high temp superconducting materials have been non-malleable ceramics which cannot be made into practical wires for conventional windings, at least the last time I looked.

Can anyone bring us up to date on this problem? I haven't looked into it for a while.
 
  • #8
seerongo said:
Which leads back to the Big Problem in developing practical high temp superconductors: So far, all high temp superconducting materials have been non-malleable ceramics which cannot be made into practical wires for conventional windings, at least the last time I looked.

Well, the latest generation of wires (well, tapes) are quite malleable. The reason being that the superconductor is deposited on a thin metallic tape and is granular, meaning the tape is easy to bend. The performance of tape now exceeds most of the design goals that people set up 10-15 years ago.

Currently,the main problem with HTS cables is the insulation (specifically the conduits for the coolant) which tend to break if you bend it too many times. There are also issues when it comes to aging (the main issue being that there aren't any old cables around, and companies aren't willing to invest money in a technology until it has been shown to be reliable).
However, this is not an issue for generators etc where the whole assembly is cooled.

The US Navy succesfully tested a HTS ship propulsion motor a couple of years ago. As far as I remember it was built by American Superconductor.
A few Japanese companies have also demonstrated motors for ships (I saw one at a conference a couple of years ago).

Somewhat OT: One of the main reasons why I don't go to conferences on applied superconductivity anymore is that they are now completely dominated by power applications. At the last one I went to it seemed like a half the participants were actually power engineers and not physicists; there were whole poster sessions on bending cables, generators, flywheels, fault current limiters etc.
How many of these potential applications that will actually reach the market is hard to say; but the physics relevant for power applications (flux pinning etc) seems to be done; it is up the engineers to design products.
 
  • #9
f95toli: Very interesting information. Thank you. Does all this imply that materials people are giving up on developing inherently malleable materials? That is, are we stuck with ceramics? I've always hoped that some niobium alloy-like material could somehow be found. Or perhaps the viability and economy of the tapes is good enough? I see that the tapes can be made quite thin, measuring in microns.

In particular, I'm interested the application of these HTS technologies to high field magnets, >1Tesla or so. From what I can determine, superconducting magnets for MRI's and such are still using older technology cooled by LHe. I wonder what the problems are for adapting these tapes to this particular application? I have a background in MRI systems (but not for a while) and the magnets are a terrible problem in maintenance and cryogen expense. Not only is LHe expensive, but the cryostats have to be buffered by L nitrogen or expensive refrigeration systems (cold-heads). I can only imagine the magnitude of the problem at the LHC! High temp current-carriers have always been the holy grail for large magnets.

Do you know the status of HTS application to these kinds of magnets?
 

1. What are alternators?

Alternators are devices that convert mechanical energy into electrical energy. They are commonly used in cars to provide electricity to power the vehicle's electrical components.

2. How are carbon nanotubes used in alternators?

Carbon nanotubes, which are tiny cylindrical structures made of carbon atoms, are used in alternators as a replacement for copper. They are excellent conductors of electricity and can handle high amounts of current without overheating.

3. What makes carbon nanotubes better conductors than copper?

Carbon nanotubes have a higher electrical conductivity than copper due to their unique structure. They have a high surface area, which allows for more efficient electron transport, and their carbon-carbon bonds are extremely strong, allowing for better current flow.

4. What are superconductors and how are they used in alternators?

Superconductors are materials that can conduct electricity without any resistance at low temperatures. They are used in alternators to reduce energy loss and increase efficiency. Superconductors are typically made of ceramic materials and are used in conjunction with carbon nanotubes to further improve the conductivity of alternators.

5. What are the advantages of using carbon nanotubes and superconductors in alternators?

The use of carbon nanotubes and superconductors in alternators offers several advantages. These include higher energy efficiency, improved performance, and reduced maintenance costs. Additionally, these materials are more environmentally friendly and can help reduce the carbon footprint of energy production.

Similar threads

  • Electromagnetism
Replies
5
Views
220
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
2
Replies
40
Views
764
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • Materials and Chemical Engineering
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Biology and Chemistry Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
28
Views
40K
  • Sci-Fi Writing and World Building
Replies
0
Views
627
  • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
1
Views
2K
Back
Top