Cuurent statuses of theories of gravity

In summary: Euclidian space is a special case of curved GR space. It is used to describe the solar system and smaller realms. It is valid only for those realms. Above a certain size, GR would be more accurate.
  • #1
chaszz
59
2
I know that Newton's theory of gravity fails to predict certain features of Mercury's orbit in comparison with GR, and also fails to predict the bending of spacetime around a star shown by the path of light. And perhaps one or two other failures which I forget. But I've read that Newton's laws are adequate for calculating pathways of spacecraft in the solar system, and are used by NASA and presumably other space agencies for their flights, because GR is so much more complicated to use. So, what is the current status of Newton's theory of gravity in physics? Is it considered a special case of Einstein's theory, or an entirely different theory? Is it considered valid in the realms it covers, or outdated and overturned? Does Einstein's theory *contain* Newton's? Is Euclidian flat space which I believe Newton uses, a special case of curved GR space, valid only for smaller realms like the solar system, or could Euclidian space be said to be able describe also a large large area of the universe, say several long walls of galaxies together? If a flight path to another star say, 400 million light years away were calculated with Newton's laws, would it be in error as compared with a calculation made with GR? As the laws of physics break down in a singularity, could Newton's laws be said to break down above a certain size of spatial area?
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Yes, you can derive Newtonian gravity as a first order approximation to General Relativity. That's pretty much what it is understood to be and why it is useful for most orbital dynamics problems.
 
  • #3
Newton's law of gravitation is basically a simplified form of einstein's theory of general relativity. It does not account for frame dragging and all that fancy relativistic stuff but it is sufficient to explain gravitational interactions to a high degree of accuracy.
 
  • #4
Newtonian gravity is not a special case of GR. In the case of weak gravity, it is a good approximation to GR. However, even in weak gravity we can detect deviations from Newton's theory, such as the clock corrections that GR predicts are needed for the global positioning system (GPS) to run correctly.
 
  • #5
Thanks. What about the later part of my query? What is the relationship of Euclidian space to GR space? Am I describing that correctly, including the parts about small and large scales and Newton's laws breaking down at large scales?

I am very curious about the relationship between any kind of geometry of space, Euclidian or one of the more complex geometries, and real space, or real space-time. Is the geometry of GR considered to be

1. A depiction of a real spacetime, or
2. A model that merely mathematically represents a physical reality we do not really understand (in the way that we do not really understand wave-particle duality, but are forced to live with it)??
 

1. What is the current status of Einstein's theory of general relativity?

The current status of Einstein's theory of general relativity is that it is the most widely accepted theory of gravity. It has been extensively tested and has successfully explained a wide range of phenomena, including the bending of light by massive objects and the precession of Mercury's orbit.

2. Are there any alternative theories to general relativity?

Yes, there are several alternative theories to general relativity, such as modified Newtonian dynamics (MOND) and loop quantum gravity. However, none of these theories have gained as much support or success as general relativity.

3. What is the current understanding of gravity at the quantum level?

The current understanding of gravity at the quantum level is still incomplete. General relativity and quantum mechanics, which are two of the most successful theories in physics, are not yet reconciled. There are ongoing efforts to develop a theory of quantum gravity that can unify these two theories.

4. How has our understanding of gravity evolved over time?

Our understanding of gravity has evolved significantly over time. From the classical Newtonian theory of gravity to Einstein's theory of general relativity, our understanding has become more precise and has been able to explain more phenomena. However, there is still much to learn and understand about gravity.

5. What are some current areas of research in the field of gravity?

Some current areas of research in the field of gravity include the search for a theory of quantum gravity, testing general relativity in extreme environments such as black holes and neutron stars, and studying the effects of gravity on the expansion of the universe. There is also ongoing research on the nature of dark matter and dark energy, which are thought to play a role in the behavior of gravity at large scales.

Similar threads

  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
21
Views
2K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
1
Views
619
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
24
Views
3K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
1
Views
877
  • Special and General Relativity
2
Replies
35
Views
4K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
4
Replies
105
Views
10K
  • Special and General Relativity
2
Replies
61
Views
13K
Replies
14
Views
29K
Back
Top