Thermodynamics: P,V,T graphs and other misc. questions.

In summary, the conversation discusses a problem related to thermodynamics and the steps needed to solve it. The main obstacle is that the states are not fixed, but they can be determined by using the quality and pressure. The conversation also touches on the use of graphs in solving thermodynamic problems and how to identify an isentropic problem. The conversation ends with a question about finding a mathematical proof for a specific thermodynamic formula.
  • #1
fractal01
14
1
ReaverKS said:
I've attached a picture that is essentially the setup for the problem. There's really only one other major obstacle to overcome and that is that the states are not fixed. I.e. state 1 all you know that is obvious is that P1=0.1Mpa=100kpa but you need to know something else to be able to start doing some calculations. My advice is to open your book or notes and look for the basic definition of quality. Once you get the quality, with knowing the pressure the state is fixed and you can easily calculate anything you could want (including internal energy, u1). State 2 also needs to be fixed, they give you x2=1, you have to read the problem carefully to gather this information. You need to know more information about state 2 in order to fix it, so that you can calculate other information about state 2, such as u2. You can actually calculate v1 and you know that v1=v2 because it's a closed system, and I assume the vessel to be rigid, therefore V1=V2 and v1=v2. Now you know x2=1 and v2=v1 which you can calculate v1 if you know x1. Now you've got state 2 fixed and you can calculate the quality at state 2, then you can calculate the internal energy at state 2. Then by utilizing the first law, you just need to determine what the work is, look at my post above for the general formula for a closed system for work. Notice that this is an isometric system (constant volume) so what does that mean about dV?

Hey! You seem to kn ow what youre talking about here and I am stuck on a similar question, so is it ok if i ask you something?
Basically I found your tips on things that you need to include when solving the question really helpful, and I was wondering, should you sketch graphs of specific volume against pressure, temperature, etc, or should you just use regular volume, or both?
And I was wondering, how do you identify a isentropic problem?
 
  • Like
Likes Kavita Rathore
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2


fractal01 said:
Hey! You seem to kn ow what youre talking about here and I am stuck on a similar question, so is it ok if i ask you something?
Basically I found your tips on things that you need to include when solving the question really helpful, and I was wondering, should you sketch graphs of specific volume against pressure, temperature, etc, or should you just use regular volume, or both?
And I was wondering, how do you identify a isentropic problem?

Hello! I certainly don't mind helping you, feel free to ask me anything thermo I, I truly loved the course and it challenged me at the same time. Generally speaking you're always going to want to sketch P-v (specific volume) or T-v (specific volume) graphs because specific volume is in your thermodynamic tables, volume is not, and although you can calculate the total volume if you know the mass, there's a lot of problems where you don't know the mass. What's also important on those graphs is to put your vapor dome in there (if it belongs, don't put the vapor dome in if you're graphing an ideal gas!) and put your isobars and isotherms. You have isobars on a T-v diagram and isotherms on a P-v diagram. They're lines of constant temperature and pressure and I could possibly dig up a picture for you if need be.

An isentropic problem can be identified in a couple ways: 1) they tell you it's isentropic 2) they tell you its reversible AND adiabatic (need both!) 3) they tell you it's an ideal gas with n=k.
 
  • #3


ReaverKS said:
Hello! I certainly don't mind helping you, feel free to ask me anything thermo I, I truly loved the course and it challenged me at the same time. Generally speaking you're always going to want to sketch P-v (specific volume) or T-v (specific volume) graphs because specific volume is in your thermodynamic tables, volume is not, and although you can calculate the total volume if you know the mass, there's a lot of problems where you don't know the mass. What's also important on those graphs is to put your vapor dome in there (if it belongs, don't put the vapor dome in if you're graphing an ideal gas!) and put your isobars and isotherms. You have isobars on a T-v diagram and isotherms on a P-v diagram. They're lines of constant temperature and pressure and I could possibly dig up a picture for you if need be.

An isentropic problem can be identified in a couple ways: 1) they tell you it's isentropic 2) they tell you its reversible AND adiabatic (need both!) 3) they tell you it's an ideal gas with n=k.
Oh thank you! If you actually enjoy being asked thermo questions then I've got a few more for you! :) I've been trying to do question 2 above sticking to your tips and I couldn't tell what type of process it was so I just put "Process:not isobaric, isometric, isentropic or reversible. Ideal gas compression". Would this be right? It feels like it should be wrong...
Also, I've been trying to work out how you would see that, in the last part of all of the questions the value would always be positive and I got to the point where it must be that (T1+T2)/2 > sqrt(T1 T2). I think that there must be some mathematical proof that you should be able to use to prove that this is true, but I've been trying for hours now and I can't think of what it would be. Any ideas appreciated!
 
  • #4


ReaverKS said:
Hello! I certainly don't mind helping you, feel free to ask me anything thermo I, I truly loved the course and it challenged me at the same time. Generally speaking you're always going to want to sketch P-v (specific volume) or T-v (specific volume) graphs because specific volume is in your thermodynamic tables, volume is not, and although you can calculate the total volume if you know the mass, there's a lot of problems where you don't know the mass. What's also important on those graphs is to put your vapor dome in there (if it belongs, don't put the vapor dome in if you're graphing an ideal gas!) and put your isobars and isotherms. You have isobars on a T-v diagram and isotherms on a P-v diagram. They're lines of constant temperature and pressure and I could possibly dig up a picture for you if need be.

An isentropic problem can be identified in a couple ways: 1) they tell you it's isentropic 2) they tell you its reversible AND adiabatic (need both!) 3) they tell you it's an ideal gas with n=k.

If you wrote a book with these things in you could probably sell quite a few copies because I think a lot of people have problems getting clear on some parts, like, containing the graphs for each process. I'm just saying cause there arent many clear concise ones out there, and I've seen quite a few now! Alas none have made me a thermo pro yet!
 
  • #5


fractal01 said:
If you wrote a book with these things in you could probably sell quite a few copies because I think a lot of people have problems getting clear on some parts, like, containing the graphs for each process. I'm just saying cause there arent many clear concise ones out there, and I've seen quite a few now! Alas none have made me a thermo pro yet!

I think it's my background, I currently work as a math tutor while I go to school and I find myself trying to find different ways to help students understand what's going on. Right now it's mostly high school kids so it's fairly simple math, but I've managed to help quite a few students that were struggling with calculus. Everybody learns differently though so what might seem good to you is harder for others to grasp. I'm actually in the process of getting a blog up and running that's going to be general help/information for engineering students (not ready to be unveiled though) but I love thermo so maybe something will be made for that specifically.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

What is thermodynamics?

Thermodynamics is a branch of physics that deals with the relationship between heat, energy, and work. It is concerned with the behavior of systems that involve the transfer of energy as heat and work.

What is a P,V,T graph?

A P,V,T graph is a graphical representation of the relationship between pressure (P), volume (V), and temperature (T) of a substance. It is often used to visualize the changes in these properties as a substance undergoes a physical or chemical process.

What do the slopes of a P,V,T graph represent?

The slope of a P,V,T graph represents the change in one of the properties (P, V, or T) while the other two are held constant. For example, the slope of a P,V graph at constant temperature represents the change in volume as pressure is varied.

What is the first law of thermodynamics?

The first law of thermodynamics states that energy cannot be created or destroyed, only transferred or converted from one form to another. This law is often summarized as "energy is conserved."

How is entropy related to thermodynamics?

Entropy is a measure of the disorder or randomness in a system. In thermodynamics, it is related to the second law of thermodynamics, which states that the total entropy of a closed system will either remain constant or increase over time. This law is often summarized as "entropy always increases."

Similar threads

  • Biology and Chemistry Homework Help
Replies
8
Views
275
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
10
Views
4K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
8
Views
665
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
16
Views
1K
  • Thermodynamics
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Thermodynamics
Replies
3
Views
789
Replies
7
Views
784
Replies
15
Views
1K
  • Classical Physics
Replies
2
Views
764
Back
Top