Are there limits to our imagination within the universe?

  • Thread starter RiddlerA
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Limits
In summary, imagination is the ability to generate hypothetical models based on our experiences and knowledge. It is an emergent property of the brain and is intimately linked with memory. There are no predefined laws governing imagination, as it can be compared to a simulation with extreme constraints. The current scientific and philosophical theories on imagination include the hard problem of consciousness, emergence, and qualia. Any suggestion of a non-material universe is considered a supernatural or religious claim and has no explanatory power.
  • #1
RiddlerA
58
0
Everything that exists, had existed and will ever exist are all contained within the universe...
(Leave out the parallel universes concept for now)..
So that means our imagination also exists within the universe...
I mean with our mind we think and our mind is contained within the universe... So the thoughts which the mind produces must also be the part of the universe...

The weird part is that the physics laws doesn't work in our imaginations.. I mean that we can imagine a car moving faster than light, we can imagine a drop of water flowing upwards against the gravity and so forth... But we cannot simply say that our imagination is limitless..
Cause it does have some limits like Da Vinci said

All our knowledge has its origin in our perceptions.
-(Leonardo da Vinci)

That quote is quite true.. If you spend some time thinking about it, you will realize it...


So my question is that
Is there any laws that governs our imagination?
Is there any research going on it?
Does it belong to just the field of Psychology?
 
Biology news on Phys.org
  • #2
RiddlerA said:
So that means our imagination also exists within the universe...
I mean with our mind we think and our mind is contained within the universe... So the thoughts which the mind produces must also be the part of the universe...
Of course the mind exists within the universe; the mind is an emergent property of the brain.
RiddlerA said:
The weird part is that the physics laws doesn't work in our imaginations.. I mean that we can imagine a car moving faster than light, we can imagine a drop of water flowing upwards against the gravity and so forth... But we cannot simply say that our imagination is limitless..
Imagination is the faculty to generate hypothetical models in order to plan behaviour. It relies on our ability to accurately model the world around us: trying to envision a solution to a problem requires you to imagine within the physical laws you know. We can however model all sorts of things that we have not seen but still based on our experience. There are obvious limits to our imagination however, it is not possible to imagine paradoxes for example.
 
  • #3
Imagination is how well our modeling errors match something they weren't intended for. : )
 
  • #4
RiddlerA said:
Everything that exists, had existed and will ever exist are all contained within the universe...
(Leave out the parallel universes concept for now)..
So that means our imagination also exists within the universe...
I mean with our mind we think and our mind is contained within the universe... So the thoughts which the mind produces must also be the part of the universe...

For some reason this reminded me of http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell's_paradox]Russell's[/PLAIN] [Broken] Paradox

RiddlerA said:
Is there any laws that governs our imagination?

Imagination can be compared to a crude simulation. In a simulation you have the freedom to make your own laws and govern how things do what they do. So no, there are no predefined laws.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #5
mishrashubham said:

Cool paradox... Thanks for the link...:smile:

mishrashubham said:
Imagination can be compared to a crude simulation. In a simulation you have the freedom to make your own laws and govern how things do what they do. So no, there are no predefined laws.

Yeah i agree... Its a lot more like a simulation with some extreme constraints...
But what i can't understand is that in what form this thoughts exist in the universe?
I mean Materials have mass and energy and the universe which we perceive with our eyes are full of materials... But the universe which we perceive with our mind are so non-materialistic...

Have you guys heard of the dual universe theory of plato?
About the material and the non-material universe?

For instance, take any material, it is composed of many atoms...
Energy radiation, composed of photons...
But our thoughts are made of what?

Yeah surely you can argue that it is a result of atomic interpretation within our mind that creates the illusion of reality within our head...
But my question is how the interaction of some atoms with other atoms would make a make believe world in itself?

The current physics' theories on the atomic level interactions doesn't even come close to explain this phenomenon, do they?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #6
RiddlerA said:
But what i can't understand is that in what form this thoughts exist in the universe?
I mean Materials have mass and energy and the universe which we perceive with our eyes are full of materials... But the universe which we perceive with our mind are so non-materialistic...

For instance, take any material, it is composed of many atoms...
Energy radiation, composed of photons...
But our thoughts are made of what?

Yeah surely you can argue that it is a result of atomic interpretation within our mind that creates the illusion of reality within our head...
But my question is how the interaction of some atoms with other atoms would make a make believe world in itself?

The current physics' theories on the atomic level interactions doesn't even come close to explain this phenomenon, do they?
Look up the hard problem of consciousness, emergence and qualia for the current scientific and philosophical takes on the issue. Also note that as far as we are aware it is the actions of neural networks that give rise to consciousness (see NCC) not the atoms in the brain themselves.
RiddlerA said:
Have you guys heard of the dual universe theory of plato?
About the material and the non-material universe?
Any suggestion of a "non-material universe" is simply a supernatural/religious claim and therefore has no explanatory power.
 
  • #7
According to this Science news article (it doesn't look peer-reviewed, but it draws on peer-reviewed studies) imagination is intimately linked with memory.

http://www.sciencemag.org/content/315/5810/312.summary

This lends credence to the position that imagination is nothing more than recombining learned information in novel ways.
 
  • #8
Pythagorean said:
This lends credence to the position that imagination is nothing more than recombining learned information in novel ways.

'nothing more than'?

Those words do not do justice to the words 'combining' and 'novel' - as if combining things in novel ways is trivial.

In fact, I would posit that 'combining' and 'novel' are far more important than 'learned information'. Dogs and gerbils have plenty of the latter but very little of the former.

Leonardo's Mona Lisa is 'nothing more than' recombining common paint dabs a novel ways...

I'd say you've confused the cart with the horse.
 
  • #9
I don't really disagree with your nitpicking, but all you've really done is added pathos.
 
  • #10
Pythagorean said:
I don't really disagree with your nitpicking, but all you've really done is added pathos.

Well, true.

I wasn't refuting your statement so much as remarking on your choice of emphasis and gift for understatement.
 
  • #11
I do agree with the subjective assessment that this a magnificent emergent property, I just always feel like feelings are under scrutiny on PF, so I try to omit them.
 
  • #12
Pythagorean said:
I do agree with the subjective assessment that this a magnificent emergent property, I just always feel like feelings are under scrutiny on PF, so I try to omit them.

I'm trying to imagine someone scrutinizing your feeling that feelings are under scrutiny, but it's beyond the limits of my imagination.
 
  • #13
Skrambles said:
I'm trying to imagine someone scrutinizing your feeling that feelings are under scrutiny, but it's beyond the limits of my imagination.

I imagine so.
 
  • #14
This is becoming more complex than it needs to be.
 
  • #15
Ryan_m_b said:
Any suggestion of a "non-material universe" is simply a supernatural/religious claim and therefore has no explanatory power.

What does the idea of presence of non-material universe has anything to do with religion or superstition?
We know our thoughts exist and this non-material universe idea might be one possible explanation to account for it... Why you people are so closed-minded? (No offense intended)
btw I am an agnostic... I neither support religion nor deny them...
 
  • #16
RiddlerA said:
What does the idea of presence of non-material universe has anything to do with religion or superstition?
We know our thoughts exist and this non-material universe idea might be one possible explanation to account for it... Why you people are so closed-minded? (No offense intended)
btw I am an agnostic... I neither support religion nor deny them...
I am entirely open minded about things for which there is evidence. Being open minded does not mean that you never disregard things or that you admit to everything having a possibility. I will view any hypothesis without prejudice and judge it according to its evidence. There is no evidence that a non-material universe exists nor that our thoughts are the product of it. There is ample evidence that the brain is the seat of the mind and it is not a receiver for thoughts from elsewhere.
 
  • #17
Ryan_m_b said:
I am entirely open minded about things for which there is evidence. Being open minded does not mean that you never disregard things or that you admit to everything having a possibility. I will view any hypothesis without prejudice and judge it according to its evidence. There is no evidence that a non-material universe exists nor that our thoughts are the product of it. There is ample evidence that the brain is the seat of the mind and it is not a receiver for thoughts from elsewhere.

Sorry, everyone is entitled to their own opinion and I respect that...
Anyway i believe the existence of non material universe which our mind is the interface between these two universes... I believe qualia is evidence enough to believe in this theory... Even many bizarre psychological disorders can be explained through it such as multiple personalities, telepathy, phobias, emotions, intuition, ESP and so on...
 
  • #18
Sorry but "I believe" is not good enough for a science forum. Thread closed.
 

What are the limits of the imagination?

The limits of the imagination are subjective and vary from person to person. Some may argue that the only limit is one's own mind and creativity, while others believe that societal norms and cultural influences can also play a role.

Can imagination be limited by scientific knowledge?

Some may argue that scientific knowledge and understanding can enhance and expand the boundaries of the imagination. However, others may believe that scientific knowledge can limit the imagination by providing logical explanations and constraints.

Are there any benefits to pushing the limits of the imagination?

Yes, pushing the limits of the imagination can lead to creativity, innovation, and problem-solving skills. It can also help individuals think outside the box and challenge traditional ideas and beliefs.

Is there a difference between imagination and reality?

Yes, imagination is the ability to create and visualize things that do not exist in reality. While reality is the physical world and the things that can be perceived through our senses. However, the line between imagination and reality can sometimes be blurred, such as in virtual reality or lucid dreaming.

How can one expand their imagination?

There are various ways to expand one's imagination, such as reading, traveling, trying new experiences, and engaging in creative activities like drawing, writing, or brainstorming. It is also essential to have an open mind and be willing to explore new ideas and perspectives.

Similar threads

  • Classical Physics
Replies
10
Views
932
  • Cosmology
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
815
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
26
Views
6K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
15
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
971
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
23
Views
631
Replies
11
Views
1K
  • General Math
Replies
12
Views
2K
Back
Top