Microphone in Vacuum: What Would Happen?

  • Thread starter Nick89
  • Start date
In summary, the sound pressure level in a vacuum would be -infinity dB, but this value is only obtained through mathematical conversion and does not violate physical laws. The microphone itself would still have electrical noise output and the minimum signal it can discern would not be infinite unless at absolute zero temperature.
  • #1
Nick89
555
0
Hi,

I was recently wondering this, might be a stupid question but hey, here to learn :)...

Since the sound pressure level is defined as:
[tex]L_p = 20 log_{10} \left( \frac{p}{p_{ref}} \right)[/tex]

What would happen if you put a microphone in a perfect vaccuum? Obviously there can be no sound pressure [itex]p[/itex], so would the microphone measure a value of [itex]-\infty[/itex] dB? ([itex]lim_{x \rightarrow 0} log(x) = -\infty[/itex], right?)

Intuitively I would say no since with most microphones if you are in a completely silent room (except for thermal noise), they would measure 0 dB, right? And this would probably be the lowest spl the microphone can measure, any lower pressure will not move the vibrating coil?

Meh, just thought I'd ask.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Nick89 said:
Hi,

I was recently wondering this, might be a stupid question but hey, here to learn :)...

Since the sound pressure level is defined as:
[tex]L_p = 20 log_{10} \left( \frac{p}{p_{ref}} \right)[/tex]

What would happen if you put a microphone in a perfect vaccuum? Obviously there can be no sound pressure [itex]p[/itex], so would the microphone measure a value of [itex]-\infty[/itex] dB? ([itex]lim_{x \rightarrow 0} log(x) = -\infty[/itex], right?)

Intuitively I would say no since with most microphones if you are in a completely silent room (except for thermal noise), they would measure 0 dB, right? And this would probably be the lowest spl the microphone can measure, any lower pressure will not move the vibrating coil?

Meh, just thought I'd ask.

No, 0dB means that the pressure is equal to the reference pressure. Just like 0dBm means that the power is equal to 1mW (dBm is dB above 1mW into 50 Ohms).

So just take the log of 0 and see what you get. Yep, negative infinity.
 
  • #3
I know 0 dB means the pressure is the reference pressure. But was my 'problem' is, is that it doesn't make sense for a microphone to display -infinity dB... Does it? Probably just because there can be no perfect vaccuum.

BUT. A microphone is obviously never perfect either. If I'm right in thinking that a microphone works by a coil that is vibrated due to the sound waves, it will ofcourse take some minimal amount of force (pressure) to get the coil moving (due to friction etc). If the sound pressure is below this minimal pressure, the microphone should display -infinity, since the coil is not moving and the micrphone will detect no sound pressure, right? (That is ofcourse if the microphone is displaying the soundlevel instead of the sound pressure, but afaik most microphones do?)
 
  • #4
Well, in a vacuum, Pref is 0, isn't it...?

So what's log(0/0)?
 
  • #5
russ_watters said:
Well, in a vacuum, Pref is 0, isn't it...?

So what's log(0/0)?

No, I think Pref is some reference value, independent of the environment. Just like 1mW is used as the reference for dBm, and like 1uV is used as the reference for dBuv.
 
  • #6
Nick89 said:
I know 0 dB means the pressure is the reference pressure. But was my 'problem' is, is that it doesn't make sense for a microphone to display -infinity dB... Does it? Probably just because there can be no perfect vaccuum.

To get the most sensitive measurement, you would connect the microphone to an audio spectrum analyzer. When the microphone is not picking anything up, the spectrum analyzer would display its own noise floor (it would see a very small level of white noise), probably around -70dB for a good analyzer.
 
  • #7
Microphones don't measure dB directly. The microphone output will be a voltage signal, and that voltage would be 0 in a perfect vacuum (ignoring electronic noise that is unrelated to the sound).

dB is just something we humans calculate using the output voltage signal.
 
  • #8
Just because you eliminated the energy contribution from sound pressure coupling to the diaphragm by sucking out the air, you do not have zero signal yet! There would still be electrical noise output at the terminals. Some may come from other mechanical coupling to the microphone, some from thermoelectric effects at the connections, some from local electromagnetic couplings from a.c. power distribution and more.

Even if all these are somehow eliminated, the noise of molecules shaking about will not subside until you resort to cryogenic cooling. The minimum signal you can discern, as ratio relative to some reference, expressed as dB=10*log(ratio) will not be infinite unless you can truly achieve absolute zero in a totally frozen, yet still somehow functional microphone..
( I think )
 
  • #9
Sorry for waiting so long to respond, for some reason I did not get an email that someone replied...

Redbelly, is the voltage 0 because the sound pressure is 0? If so then, if you would convert that to dB's, you would get -infinity dB's...

GTrax, good point. I was using a vacuum in my 'thought experiment' to cancel out the thermal noise of the air. But obviously the microphone itself contains molecules moving about so you can never actually meassure an absolute zero sound pressure (you might be able to acchieve that in a perfect vaccuum, but you cannot measure it with a mechanical microphone).
 
  • #10
Nick89 said:
Redbelly, is the voltage 0 because the sound pressure is 0?
Yes. Or more accurately, because the amplitude of the sound pressure is zero.

If so then, if you would convert that to dB's, you would get -infinity dB's...
Yes. But my point was that it becomes -infinity only when you do the math conversion. The microphone itself is not "outputting" -infinity, so no physical laws are being violated.
 
  • #11
russ_watters said:
Well, in a vacuum, Pref is 0, isn't it...?

So what's log(0/0)?

Pref is 20 micropascals (20 μPa) by definition.
 

1. What happens to sound waves in a vacuum?

In a vacuum, sound waves cannot travel because they require a medium, such as air, to propagate. Without air molecules to vibrate, sound cannot be produced or heard.

2. Would a microphone work in a vacuum?

No, a microphone would not work in a vacuum because it relies on sound waves to convert sound into electrical signals. Without sound waves, the microphone would not be able to pick up any sound.

3. Can sound be produced in a vacuum?

No, sound cannot be produced in a vacuum because it requires a medium to travel through. However, some rarefied gases can still transmit sound waves in a vacuum, but it would not be audible to the human ear.

4. How would a microphone behave in a vacuum?

A microphone in a vacuum would not behave as it does in a normal environment. It would not pick up any sound, and any electrical signals it produces would be from internal noise or vibrations.

5. Is it possible to use a microphone to detect sound in space?

No, it is not possible to use a traditional microphone to detect sound in space. However, specialized microphones or other instruments can be used to detect other forms of waves, such as radio waves or electromagnetic waves, in space.

Similar threads

  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
16
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
9K
  • MATLAB, Maple, Mathematica, LaTeX
Replies
0
Views
1K
  • Advanced Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Differential Equations
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • General Discussion
Replies
4
Views
605
Replies
46
Views
2K
Back
Top