Isnt this a bogus claim?

  • Thread starter thetexan
  • Start date
In summary, this conversation discusses the amount of carbon that is released when burning one gallon of fuel. The Department of Energy states that 21.1 pounds of carbon dioxide are released, but some question the accuracy of this claim. However, when taking into account the amount of oxygen needed for combustion, the claim seems to be reasonable. The weight of gasoline is mainly from the carbon it contains, and when burned, it combines with oxygen to create carbon dioxide and water. This explains the 21.1 pounds of carbon dioxide released when burning one gallon of fuel. The conversation also touches on the weight of gasoline and the other components involved in combustion.
  • #1
thetexan
266
11
Please look at this article...

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...th-Day-emitting-375-TONS-carbon-dioxide.html\

Gasoline weighs about 6lbs per gallon. According to the Department of Energy burning one gallon of fuel releases 21.1 lbs of carbon. How is this possible?

That would be getting something for nothing wouldn't it. In no case will you get more than the component weight of carbon in the gas molecule, right. So it couldn't be more than 6 lbs of carbon released and probably much less than that...proportional to the amount of carbon atoms in the molecule.

Isnt this a bogus government claim that supports their agenda? In fact, what would be the amount of carbon in a gallon of gas?

tex
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
  • #2
When you burn the gasoline, you require oxygen. Gas is a hydrocarbon. When it is burned, the hydrogen bonds with oxygen in the air to form 2(H20), and the Carbon bonds with O2 to form CO2. There is a lot of air required to burn one gallon of gasoline.
 
  • #3
thetexan said:
According to the Department of Energy burning one gallon of fuel releases 21.1 lbs of carbon.
It doesn't say that. It says carbon dioxide.

Carbon makes about 12/44 of CO2 by mass. That gives roughly 2.6 kg of carbon emitted per 3.8 litres of fuel as per the USDoE source(http://www.eia.gov/environment/emissions/co2_vol_mass.cfm).

Assuming the jet fuel is kerosene, 1 gallon makes about 3kg. Kerosene is C12H26, with carbon making up roughly 144/160 by mass.
The end result of complete burning of 1 gallon of kerosene is ~2.7 kg of carbon released to be bound with oxygen to form CO2. Looks like it's about right.
 
  • #4
What does it mean to "burn" something?

What is the other thing - apart from fuel - that is required for a combustion engine to work?

Hint: will the combustion engine work under water?
 
  • #5
When you factor in the mass of oxygen needed for the fuel to undergo a combustion reaction the claims in the article seem to be reasonable. It is the carbon(and hydrogen) in the fuel and the oxygen drawn in from the atmosphere that contribute to the weight of combustion products (mainly carbon dioxide and water) produced.
 
Last edited:
  • #6
Gasoline's weight ( mass) is mostly from the carbon it contains
I disagree with your 6 pounds - gasoline I buy here in Maryland weighs just 8.6 US pounds per gallon.
So for rough math, 8.6 pounds of gasoline is almost 7.25 pounds of carbon (about 84% by weigh)
When used as in burned ( think about the cars engine) it combines with a lot of oxygen from the air
There they are talking about CO2 - 1 carbon atom combined with 2 oxygen atoms
Oxygen weighs a little more than carbon, but for here we will use the same . so simple simple math - 7.25 times 3 is 21.75
Close to the 21 pounds of CO2 in the article.
It also makes 1.5 gallons of water ( ever notice the puddle of water behind a tailpipe of a idling vehicle?)
 

What does it mean for a claim to be "bogus"?

A bogus claim is one that is false or fraudulent, lacking any evidence or proof to support its validity. It is often used to describe claims that are misleading or deliberately deceptive.

How can I determine if a claim is bogus or not?

To determine if a claim is bogus, it is important to critically evaluate the evidence and sources supporting it. Look for credible, unbiased sources and consider the motivations of those making the claim. Additionally, seek out contradictory evidence and use critical thinking to analyze the validity of the claim.

Why do people make bogus claims?

There are a variety of reasons why people may make bogus claims. Some may do so for financial gain, to manipulate others, or to spread misinformation. Others may genuinely believe the claim to be true, but lack evidence to support it.

What are some red flags that indicate a claim may be bogus?

Red flags that may indicate a bogus claim include lack of evidence or sources, use of emotional appeals instead of facts, claims that go against established scientific principles, and claims that are not supported by reputable experts or organizations.

How can we combat the spread of bogus claims?

One way to combat the spread of bogus claims is by promoting critical thinking and media literacy. Encouraging individuals to question and fact-check information before accepting it as true can help prevent the spread of misinformation. It is also important for reputable sources and experts to speak out against bogus claims and provide evidence-based information to counter them.

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
956
Replies
16
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
870
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
7
Views
4K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
14
Views
2K
Replies
25
Views
46K
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
5K
Replies
4
Views
3K
Back
Top