Clothes Iron versus baseboard heater

[drewtupps]

Hi,

My friend and I were having a discussion and had a disagreement. I'm hoping one of you intelligent people can settle it for us. There are two points I'd like to talk about.

1. Safety concerns and practicalities aside why would one choose to heat a room with a baseboard heater versus an oven or say a clothes iron.

2. In a given amount of time, would a 1500 Watt iron produce as much heat as a 1500 watt baseboard heater?
His argument was that, although a baseboard heater would heat up quicker, after they were turned off, an iron would give off heat for a longer period of time. If all energy that goes into the two systems is converted to heat, then why wouldn't they produce the same amount of heat.

Thank you,

Drew

 

[mgb_phys]

Power is a measure of the RATE of energy transfer.
So a 1500W iron and a 1500 watt computer PSU both put out the same amount of energy in the same time. But they do so at different temperatures.

In a closed room it doesn't make a lot of difference. The iron will heat up a small amount of air to a higher temperature - that air will heat up other air until the whole room is at the same lower temperature. The baseboard heater will heat up a large volume of air to a middle temperature - that air will then heat up the remainign air in the room to the same final temperature (assuming no losses).

 

[astrokreng]

Hello Drew,

Thank you for your question. I would like to provide an objective response to your discussion about heating a room with a baseboard heater versus a clothes iron.

1. Safety concerns and practicalities aside, the choice between a baseboard heater and an oven or clothes iron for heating a room would depend on several factors such as the size of the room, insulation, and the desired temperature. A baseboard heater is designed specifically for heating a room and is more efficient at evenly distributing heat throughout the space. An oven or clothes iron may not be able to provide the same level of heating as a baseboard heater and could potentially be a fire hazard if left unattended.

2. In terms of heat production, a 1500 watt iron and a 1500 watt baseboard heater would produce the same amount of heat in a given amount of time. However, the difference lies in how the heat is distributed. A baseboard heater is designed to provide continuous heat while an iron is designed for short bursts of heat. Once the iron is turned off, it will cool down quickly and stop producing heat. On the other hand, a baseboard heater can maintain a consistent temperature for a longer period of time.

In conclusion, while both a clothes iron and a baseboard heater can produce the same amount of heat in a given amount of time, a baseboard heater is a more efficient and practical option for heating a room. It is important to consider safety concerns and practicalities when choosing a heating method for a room. I hope this helps settle your discussion.